Molecular Mechanisms of Coxsackievirus Persistence in Chronic Inflammatory Myopathy: Viral RNA Persists through Formation of a Double-Stranded Complex without Associated Genomic Mutations or Evolution

ABSTRACT

Enterovirus infection and persistence have been implicated in the pathogenesis of certain chronic muscle diseases. In vitro studies suggest that persistent enteroviruses mutate, evolving into forms that are less lytic and display altered tropism, but it is less clear whether these mechanisms operate in vivo. In this study, persistent coxsackievirus RNA from the muscle of mice afflicted with chronic inflammatory myopathy (CIM) was characterized and compared with RNA from a virus that had established a persistent infection of G8 mouse myoblasts for 30 passages in vitro. Competitive strand-specific reverse transcription-PCR and susceptibility to RNase I treatment revealed that plus- and minus-strand viral RNAs were present at nearly equivalent levels in muscle and that they persisted in a double-stranded conformation. All regions of the viral genome persisted and were amplified as a series of seven overlapping fragments. Restriction endonuclease fingerprinting coupled with sequencing indicated that there was no evolution of the viral genome associated with its persistence in muscle. This contrasted with the productive persistent infection that was established in myoblast cultures, where plus-strand RNA predominated and persistent virus developed distinct mutations. In vitro persistence proceeded by a carrier culture mechanism and was completely dependent on production of infectious virus, since persistent viral RNA was not detected in cultures subjected to antibody-mediated curing. These experiments demonstrate that persistence of coxsackievirus RNA in muscle is not facilitated by distinct genetic changes in the virus that give rise to replication-defective forms but occurs primarily through production of stable double-stranded RNA that is produced as the acute viral infection resolves. The data suggest a mechanism for coxsackievirus persistence in myofibers and perhaps other nondividing cells whereby cells that survive infection could harbor persistent viral RNA for extended times without producing detectable levels of infectious virus.