Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, January 2007, p. 732-742, Vol. 81, No. 2
0022-538X/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JVI.01430-06
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Heinrich-Pette-Institut, Hamburg, Germany
Received 7 July 2006/ Accepted 19 October 2006
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Using MuLVs as tools to identify novel or cooperating oncogenes or as safe gene-transfer vectors requires a better understanding of the mechanisms that control leukemia induction. How can these tools be manipulated to transform (or avoid transforming) a specific hematopoietic cell lineage? A central question is thus what viral and cellular determinants contribute to the lineage specificity of leukemia induction? Functional analysis of oncogenes implicated in acute leukemias of humans, mice, and chickens have clearly shown that oncogenes that regulate cell fate decision can determine the cell lineage specificity of the leukemia (17, 30, 35, 53, 55). However, the role of viral elements in determining lineage specificity is less clear. Are these elements necessary for targeting infection of specific cell types or are they necessary to induce oncogene expression to a critical level required to disrupt normal controls? The characterization of different MuLV isolates that induce distinct leukemia subtypes with varying kinetics has demonstrated the significance of enhancer elements within the long terminal repeats (LTR) in disease induction, in particular the T-lymphomagenic Moloney (Mo) and SL3-3 MuLV variants (2, 18, 51, 52, 61). However, although the importance of the LTR in disease specificity goes unquestioned, it is also clear that other viral elements contribute to disease kinetics and specificity. Furthermore, mouse strain differences are often ignored, although inherent mutations can be strong modifiers of both virus spread and disease induction.
To obtain better insight into the importance of sequences outside the LTR for determining cell lineage specificity in MuLV-induced leukemogenesis, we chose to investigate the viral determinants involved in the unique pathogenicity of 10A1-MuLV. 10A1-MuLV was generated upon in vivo recombination between an exogenous amphotropic MuLV and endogenous polytropic env sequences (25, 40, 43). Previous studies have shown that 10A1-MuLV induces early blast cell leukemia in NIH Swiss mice, distinct to the lymphoid leukemia induced by the related amphotropic 4070A-MuLV (41, 42). In contrast to 4070A-MuLV, which uses the solute transporter PiT2 as a receptor, 10A1-MuLV also utilizes the closely related PiT1 for cell entry (32, 59). It has thus been postulated that the unique pathology of 10A1-MuLV may be due to its distinct receptor usage that enables targeting of an early hematopoietic stem cell (42). To investigate the importance of receptor usage in cell lineage specificity, we constructed retroviral chimeras using a 10A1 backbone with the env genes from either 4070A-MuLV or the T-cell-tropic Mo-MuLV, which uses the Cat1 receptor for cell entry. The results reported here underline the importance of cell targeting in disease specificity by showing that the unique blast cell pathology of 10A1 requires the use of either the PiT1 or Cat1 receptor. Strikingly, all mice developing blastic leukemia also showed integrations within the Fli1 locus, originally identified as a common integration site in Friend MuLV (F-MuLV)-induced erythroleukemia (7, 8, 48). We show that this leukemia phenotype is mouse strain specific and suggest that critical levels of Fli1 synergize with an inherent mutation in these mice and thereby induce the specific (erythro)blastic phenotype. These results have important implications in understanding cell lineage specificity in MuLV-induced leukemogenesis and manipulating these tools for insertional mutagenesis studies.
|
|
|---|
Virus assays. Marker rescue assays were employed to verify the host range of the viral recombinants. SC1 cells expressing an MPEVneo retroviral vector (26) were infected with supernatant from virus-producing cells and cultured for a minimum of 10 days to ensure complete virus spread. Medium was replaced 24 h prior to harvesting of virus stocks from confluent monolayers and passed through a Millex-GP 0.22-µm filter (Millipore). Titers of virus stocks of MPEVneo pseudotypes were determined by end-point dilution. Human TE671 or murine SC1 cells expressing the indicated viruses were plated at 104 cells per well of a 24-well plate on day 1. On day 2, medium was replaced with medium containing virus stock serial dilutions (1:5) and 8 µg of Polybrene per ml. After 12 h, medium was replaced, and on day 3 to 4, G418 (400 µg/ml; specific activity, 0.6) was added. Drug-resistant colonies were counted and were expressed as G418-resistant transfer units (GTU) after 10 to 14 days. All virus dilutions were analyzed in triplicate.
Mice, virus inoculations, and clinical evaluation. NIH/Ola and C57BL/6J mice were bred in the Heinrich-Pette-Institute animal quarters. C57BL/6 Icsbp/ mice (20) were kindly provided by Ivan Horak and maintained as homozygotes in our animal quarters. Mice were infected intraperitoneally within 24 to 48 h after birth with 50 µl of virus-containing supernatant with a virus titer of between 3 x 105 and 8 x 105 infectivity units/ml. Mice were regularly monitored for disease symptoms. Moribund mice were bled and then sacrificed and examined for hepatosplenomegaly, thymomas, and lymphomas.
Flow cytometry. For lineage marker analysis of diseased organs, single-cell suspensions were prepared from hematopoietic tissues after lysis of erythroid cells with PharmMLyse (BD PharMingen) and incubated at 4°C for 30 min in phosphate-buffered saline containing 2% bovine serum albumin with phycoerythrin-, allophycocyanin-, or CyChrom-conjugated monoclonal antibodies (BD PharMingen). Nonspecific binding of monoclonal antibodies was prevented by preincubation with Fc Block (BD PharMingen). Only vital cells, as determined by exclusion of propidium iodide, were measured. Cells were washed twice with phosphate-buffered saline containing 2% bovine serum albumin and applied for analysis on a FACSCalibur (BD Biosciences, Heidelberg, Germany).
Histopathology and immunohistochemistry of infected mice. Peripheral blood smears and organ sections were fixed and stained using the indicated stains obtained from Sigma (Tauchenkirchen, Germany). Immunohistological inspection of hematopoietic tissue was performed as previously described (47). Briefly, antigen retrieval was achieved by autoclaving deparaffinated sections for 30 min in a citrate-based demasking solution (Antigen Retrieval Citra solution; BioGenex, San Ramon, CA). After incubation with primary antibodies, specifically bound antibodies were detected using a highly sensitive phosphatase- and polymer-conjugated anti-rabbit immunoglobulin G (IgG) detection system (Histofine; Nuchirei, Tokyo, Japan). Phosphatase activity was revealed with naphthol-AS-BI-phosphate and New Fuchsin (DakoCytomation) as a substrate.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (27K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. (A) Schematic representation of 10A1-MuLV env recombinants used in this study. (B) Kaplan-Meier survival curves of mice infected with indicated virus recombinants.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Receptor interference assays confirm the expected receptor usage for recombinant 10A1-Eenv
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Receptor interference assays confirm the expected receptor usage for recombinant 10A1-Aenv
|
10A1-Eenv induces an (erythro)blastic leukemia, similar to that induced by wild-type 10A1. Animals infected with 10A1-Eenv developed two distinct diseases. The majority of the mice developed a hematopoietic neoplasia involving the erythroid/myeloid progenitor compartment; however, a significant proportion developed a lymphoid-derived malignancy (see below). In the former case, the disease was strikingly uniform, clinically characterized by anemia and hepatosplenomegaly, but with no involvement of lymph nodes (Table 3). Histological analysis revealed that the normal architecture of the spleen was almost completely destroyed due to the accumulation of blastic tumor cells within the expanded red pulp, leading to a compression and breakdown of the white pulp (Fig. 2A). Similarly, tumor infiltrates destroyed the bone marrow structure, and both myelo- and erythropoiesis was drastically reduced. The liver was generally pale and greatly enlarged (up to 2.5-fold the normal weight) as a consequence of tumor cell invasion (Fig. 2B). Not surprisingly, due to the breakdown of the blood-forming tissue of both the bone marrow and spleen, only a very few mature erythroid cells were found in the blood, which were often distorted (acanthocytosis) (Fig. 2C). Disrupted erythropoiesis was also evidenced by the presence of immature erythroid forms, including normoblasts, in the blood. Importantly, blastic forms with either myeloid or lymphoid characteristics were also detected in blood smears. The leukocyte count varied greatly between mice (range, 4 to 211 cells/nl) (Table 3 and Fig. 2C), which probably reflects the fact that egression of the transformed cells into the blood was a late event.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Summary of the leukemic phenotypes induced in MuLV-infected NIH/Ola mice
|
![]() View larger version (142K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Histological analysis of indicated organs from mice infected with either 10A1-Eenv or 10A1 at the time of death. Shown are the typical characteristics of mice with either a blastic leukemia (A to C) or a B-cell leukemia (D to F). (A) Spleen section stained with hematoxylin-eosin. Hematopoietic cells of the red pulp are replaced by invading tumor cells. (B) Liver section stained by periodic acid-Schiff reaction. Sinusoids between hepatocellular trabeculae are strikingly dilated through the infiltration of hematopoietic tumor cells, primarily composed of immature erythroid cells but also myelo- and lymphoblastic cells. The hepatocytes show a microvesicular fatty degeneration. (C) Blood smear stained by the method of Pappenheim. Clear evidence of anemia is seen by the decreased number and the thorny form of the erythrocytes (acanthocytosis). In addition, the erythrocytes appear polychromatic. The presence of proerythroblasts, erythroblasts, and normoblasts in the blood reflects the transformation of the erythroid compartments. (D) Spleen section stained with hematoxylin-eosin. The accumulation of lymphoblastic tumor cells (lower left corner) leads to the expansion of the splenic white pulp. Hyperplastic erythropoiesis, presumably as compensation to impaired bone marrow erythropoiesis, is also observed (right side). (E) Liver section stained by the method of Giemsa. Depicted is a typical leukemic infiltrate in a portal field of the liver. The neoplastic cells show a high level of both mitosis and apoptosis. The liver tissue surrounding the tumor invasion is intact. (F) Blood smear stained by the method of Pappenheim. The presence of lymphoblasts in the blood reflects the egression of differentiation blocked B cells from the bone marrow into the circulation. The polychromasia of erythrocytes is indicative of a secondary tumor anemia.
|
![]() View larger version (55K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Representative FACS analysis of hematopoietic organs of moribund mice infected with either 10A1-Eenv or 10A1-MuLV. Single-cell suspensions obtained from either enlarged spleens (A and B) or an enlarged axillary lymph node (C) were stained with antibody recognizing the indicated antigens to determine the hematopoietic lineage of the tumor cells. Mice with the characteristics of a blast leukemia were negative for all lineage markers and variably expressed the Sca-1 antigen (A) or the erythroid antigen TER119 (B). In contrast, mice with a characteristic B-cell leukemia/lymphoma were positive for the B-cell marker B220, but not for IgM, reflecting their blast morphology.
|
In summary, the pathogenicity of 10A1-MuLV is not drastically altered when its env gene is replaced with that of the T-tropic Mo-MuLV. Although the disease penetrance is somewhat reduced, the mice succumbed to either a blastic leukemia or B-cell malignancies, similar to that induced by 10A1 in this mouse strain.
10A1-Aenv retains its capacity to induce a B-cell neoplasia but has lost its blast cell-transforming capacity. In striking contrast to both wild-type 10A1 and 10A1-Eenv infections, mice infected with the 10A1-Aenv recombinant, which carries the amphotropic env and thus solely uses the Pit2 receptor for cell entry, presented with clinical symptoms of a fatal wasting syndrome (cachexia) which was not due to advanced stages of a hematopoietic neoplasia, as assessed by normal spleen size, absence of lymphadenopathy, and normal blood counts (Table 3). However, in three mice (0.8%, n = 38) small B-cell lymphomas were observed and confirmed by FACS analysis (Table 3 and data not shown). Histological inspection of hematopoietic organs of six animals suffering from the wasting disease but without enlarged hematopoietic organs confirmed early signs of a lymphoid disorder, as evidenced by the expansion of the white pulp in the spleen due to increased lymphopoiesis (data not shown). Notably, there were no signs of the rapid dissemination of erythroid blasts in the liver and spleen, which was a consistent characteristic of the blastic leukemia observed as early as 9 weeks after infection with 10A1-MuLV or 10A1-Eenv (M. Rodenburg and J. Löhler, unpublished results). In view of the fact that the 10A1-Aenv-infected mice had approximately the same life span as 10A1-infected controls, we conclude that the 10A1-Aenv virus has lost its ability to induce blast cell leukemia. However, the recombinant virus is still able to induce a B-cell neoplasia which is not fully manifested due to the development of a second disease entity that leads to the death of the mice. Histological analysis of different tissues from these animals has revealed several defects, including severe odontopathy, hepatitis, and uropathy, which contribute to their deaths. These findings will be published separately.
In accord with the theory that 10A1-Aenv mice still have the potential to develop B-cell neoplasias, all mice infected with 4070A developed B-cell tumors (B220+, CD19+) with a mean disease latency of 228 days (Fig. 1C), a time point when most of the 10A1-Aenv-infected mice have died. The disease resembled the B-cell neoplasia observed in 10A1-infected mice, characterized by moderate splenomegaly and consistent involvement of the mesenteric lymph node (Table 3). Ott et al. have previously reported that the tumors induced by 4070A in NIH Swiss mice with a similar latency were of T-cell origin, due to the expression of CD90 (Thy1.1). Although these tumors were reported to be B220neg, rearrangements of the Ig heavy chain locus were observed in 6 of 7 tumors. We thus predict that these are indeed early pro-B cells with low levels of B220 expression, not detectable by the antibodies used in that study. Importantly, we have also observed CD90 expression in several murine B-cell tumors (unpublished results).
Taken together, restricting the receptor usage of 10A1 to the Pit2 receptor results in its inability to transform an early blast cell compartment, but not its ability to induce a B-cell hyperplasia (and presumably neoplasia), similar to the highly homologous 4070A virus. The mice, however, succumbed to a second disease entity that does not involve the hematopoietic system.
Retroviral integration within the Fli1 gene locus is observed in all blastic leukemias, whether induced by 10A1-Eenv or wild-type10A1. Ott et al. have previously reported a striking correlation of 10A1-induced blast leukemia and integration within the first coding exon of the Fli1 gene, encoding an ETS transcription factor (41). To determine if transformation of the same cell compartment by 10A1-Eenv also involved disruption of the Fli1 regulatory regions, Southern blot analysis on tumor DNA was performed using an upstream Fli1 probe. As shown in Fig. 4A, integrations clustered in the same locus as that observed in 10A1-induced tumors, indicating the importance of Fli1 activation in this distinct disease phenotype. In one tumor from a total of 12 analyzed, another restriction digest pattern was observed. Isolation of the integration site by ligase-mediated PCR and sequence analysis showed that this integration had occurred in the same region. To verify that the tumors arose from 10A1-Eenv and were not due to contaminating 10A1-MuLV, tumor DNA was also hybridized to env probes. This analysis confirmed that the tumors contained ecotropic env and not 10A1 env-containing provirus (Fig. 4B).
![]() View larger version (81K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Southern blot analysis of DNA isolated from the enlarged spleens of mice infected with the indicated virus and developing the typical blast leukemia. (A) DNA was digested with BamHI, size separated by gel electrophoresis, and transferred to a nylon membrane. Hybridization with a Fli1 probe detects both two endogenous bands (indicated by arrows on right side) and a rearranged allele (indicated by arrows on left side) which were not detected in DNA isolated from the spleen of an uninfected NIH 3T3 mouse. Numbers correspond to different infected mice. (B) DNA digested with BglII and hybridized with either an ecotropic (Mo-MuLV) or amphotropic (10A1-MuLV) env probe demonstrated that the virus in the blast tumors contained the expected env sequences. Each band denotes an independent provirus. Unlike the ecotropic env probe, which does not detect endogenous viral sequences, the 10A1 probe detects an endogenous virus, indicated by the arrow on the right.
|
The blast cell transformation capacity of 10A1 is mouse strain specific. Our results show that a 10A1 variant that uses the Cat1 receptor induced the same disease phenotype as wild-type 10A1-MuLV. F-MuLV also uses the Cat1 receptor and induces an erythroleukemia, which strictly correlates with Fli1 integrations. A review of the literature describing the F-MuLV disease (29, 50, 54) suggested that 10A1-MuLV induces the same disease. It is known that F-MuLV does not induce an erythroleukemia in C57BL/6 mice. To test the disease pathogenicity of 10A1-MuLV in this mouse strain, it was necessary to exchange gag sequences with an NB (or B)-tropic MuLV, such as Mo-MuLV, because C57BL/6 mice are Fv1bb. This recombinant, designated 10A1-Mogag, was shown to induce blast cell leukemia with a similar latency and incidence as wild-type 10A1-MuLV in NIH/Ola mice (Table 3 and Fig. 5A and B, compare with Fig. 1B). In contrast, C57BL/6 mice infected with 10A1-Mogag generated B-cell leukemia at a very low incidence and with a long latent period (Fig. 5C and data not shown).
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. (A) Schematic representation of 10A1-MuLV gag recombinant (10A1-Mogag), in which the gag sequences from 10A1 were replaced with that from Mo-MuLV using the indicated conserved restriction sites. (B) Kaplan-Meier survival curves of mice of different strains infected with either 10A1-Mogag or, as a control, Mo-MuLV.
|
|
|
|---|
Role of receptor usage in MuLV pathogenicity. The ability of a retrovirus to efficiently infect hematopoietic cells within a specific cell lineage or during a distinct differentiation stage is an obvious prerequisite for transforming this cell compartment. Thus, it was predicted that the unique stem-cell-transforming properties of 10A1-MuLV may reflect its unique usage of PiT1 (42). Indeed, substitution of the 10A1 env gene with that from the B-lymphogenic and amphotropic 4070A-MuLV resulted in a virus recombinant that lost its ability to induce blast cell leukemia, supporting this hypothesis. Somewhat surprisingly, replacing the env gene of 10A1 with that of Mo-MuLV did not change its ability to induce blastic leukemia. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the unique disease induction of 10A1-MuLV is not strictly related to its ability to use PiT1 as a receptor, although it does require a receptor, such as Cat1 but not PiT2, which enables efficient targeting of an early hematopoietic progenitor. In support of this hypothesis, retroviral vectors pseudotyped with ecotropic Env (using Cat1), but not amphotropic Env (using PiT2), can efficiently infect long-term repopulating cells of the bone marrow (24, 39). Similarly, retroviral vectors pseudotyped with gibbon ape leukemia virus, which recognizes human PiT1, are used routinely for transduction of human hematopoietic progenitors and have been shown to be more efficient than amphotropic pseudotypes (6, 22). These observations are also supported by the fact that transcript levels of Cat1 and Pit1 are relatively higher than Pit2 in early murine hematopoietic progenitors (39).
It is not surprising that env sequence variations that alter receptor usage or affinity may have a drastic influence on the cell types targeted during infection; however, few studies have addressed this issue. A prominent example of the importance of receptor usage in MuLV pathogenicity is the generation of polytropic (mink cell focus-forming virus) viruses (which use the Xpr receptor) during infections by the ecotropic Mo- and F-MuLV (15, 57). This is generally thought to be important for rapid spread of the virus during early stages of infection (and thus targeting rapidly proliferating cells) and for permitting multiple integrations. However, other roles, such as inducing hyperproliferation in a preleukemic stage by interaction with other host cell factors, may also be important (15). Interestingly, we found that recombinants with endogenous retroviral sequences were a rare event in 10A1 infections and were only observed in B-cell tumors with a long latent period (M. Rodenburg, M. Fischer, and C. Stocking, unpublished results). Variations in the env gene have also been implicated in the altered leukemia specificity in feline leukemia viruses, although this may involve a receptor-independent mechanism (12, 14, 28).
Fli1: the common denominator in erythro(blastic) leukemia? The diseases induced by 10A1 and 10A1-Eenv were strikingly similar, with most mice (>65%) succumbing to blast leukemia closely associated with severe anemia and hepatosplenomegaly, but not lymphadenopathy. In all cases analyzed, the distinct blast cell phenotype was strictly correlated with provirus insertion upstream of the coding sequence of the Fli1 gene. Ott et al. also noted a 100% correlation between disease phenotype and Fli1 integration. Notably, Fli1 was first identified as a common integration site in F-MuLV-induced erythroleukemia (with >80% correlation) (7, 8, 48) and has since been found to be a common integration site in "non-B/non-T-cell" tumors induced by Cas-Br-E and "myeloid leukemia" induced by Graffi-MuLV (9, 13, 41). A review of the literature and methodology used to classify these tumors suggests that they most likely represent the same disease entity, characterized by anemia, splenomegaly, and frequent infiltration of the liver but not lymph nodes (29, 50, 54, 60). The target of transformation appears to be a very early progenitor, variably committed to the erythroid lineage (e.g., TER119 and/or cKit positive), probably explaining the discrepancies in the classification. The latent period of the disease differs between the various mouse strains, correlating with the strength of the LTR (see below). The strong association of this phenotype to a single oncogene suggests that the single most important criteria for MuLV induction of (erythro)blastic leukemia is its ability to activate the Fli1 oncogene in an early progenitor. Interestingly, Fli1 encodes an ETS transcription factor, closely related to the PU.1 transcription factor activated by integration of the Friend spleen focus-forming virus into the Spi1 locus in erythroleukemia induction (10, 23, 55). Transformation thus probably occurs by down-regulation of the GATA family of transcription factors, which are important regulators of early multipotent (GATA-2) and erythroid (GATA-1) differentiation (23, 33).
Interestingly, the integration sites of 10A1-Eenv were consistently found in the first coding exon, similar to 10A1 and Cas-Br-E (with highly homologous LTR and gag sequences) but in contrast to Graffi- and F-MuLV-induced tumors, in which the integrations are generally found in an upstream intron (9, 13, 41). Strikingly, the permissive Fli1 integration sites of Cas-Br-E and 10A1-MuLV, which do not have duplicated enhancer elements within the LTR, are much more limited than those of Graffi (1.2)-MuLV and F-MuLV, which have duplicated enhancer regions (9, 13). Similarly, the latent period is generally shorter for these latter two viruses. Importantly, growing evidence suggests that the expression level of a transcription factor required to induce leukemogenicity is defined by a very small window (46); thus, the two distinct integration clusterings probably reflect the limited number of permissive sites, dictated by the configuration of the enhancer/promoter or other cis-regulatory elements of the provirus, that enable critical Fli1 expression levels. Transcriptional assays of Cas-Br-E, Graffi (1.2), and Friend LTRs have provided evidence that all are expressed at relatively high levels in erythroid cells, in contrast to the T-cell-tropic Moloney and SL3-3 MuLVs (5, 49). Significantly, the former LTRs contain binding sites for the GATA family of transcription factors (4). We thus predict that both high transcriptional activity of the LTR in this compartment and integration within defined regions of the gene are necessary to activate Fli1 to levels required for transformation.
The results discussed below show that at least two criteria have to be met to ensure outgrowth of a transformed pool of (erythro)blasts after 10A1-MuLV infections: (i) targeting of a relatively early progenitor and (ii) integration within a relative small region of the small Fli1 locus. It is thus not surprising that not all mice succumbed to the blast leukemia. Significantly, both 10A1 and 10A1-Eenv also induced a second disease entity, namely a B-cell neoplasia, at a reduced incidence. On the whole, these malignances had a longer latent period than the blast leukemias (mean latency of 167 days versus 132 days) and appeared to be oligoclonal, as assessed by Southern blotting (data not shown). In many respects they resembled the B-cell neoplasia induced by 4070A, with the exception that the latency was significantly shorter. We predict that these leukemias arise after a more random chain of cooperating oncogenic events. Indeed, several different common integration sites have been identified in these tumors.
Influence of mouse strain genetic factors on MuLV "lineage specificity." Strikingly, although not unexpectedly, the typical blastic leukemia induced by 10A1-MuLV, which we observed in NIH/Ola and previously observed in NIH/Swiss mice, was not observed in C57BL/6 mice. This was previously also reported for F-MuLV but has not been evaluated for Cas-Br-E and Graffi-MuLV, which are N-tropic viruses.
An early study provided genetic evidence that the resistance to F-MuLV (erythro)blastic leukemia in C57BL/6 mice is governed by a single dominant resistance locus, which was coined Frer (50). A recessive locus sensitive for disease development was found in BALB/c- and NIH-related mouse strains (e.g., FVB/n, NFS, and NIH/Swiss). These studies also showed that the locus did not affect viral replication, consistent with our studies and in contrast to other known resistant loci that modulate leukemia formation (including Fv1, Fv4, and Fv6/Rmcf). Importantly, the Frer locus is also unlikely to be the same as the Fv2r locus, also found in C57BL/6 mice, which confers resistance in a recessive fashion to disease induction by the Friend virus complex, composed of the replication-defective Friend spleen focus-forming virus and the helper virus F-MuLV. Interestingly, the recent identification of the Stk/Ron gene, encoding the stem cell tyrosine kinase, as the target gene of Fv2 genetic variations, has resulted in a better understanding of Friend virus complex pathogenicity and erythroid regulation (36, 38, 44, 62). Studies are thus warranted to determine if Fv2s is also required for Fli1-associated erythroblastic leukemia induced by these numerous MuLV variants.
Unfortunately, there have been no follow-up publications on the Fre locus. It is thus not clear at what level the resistance locus may suppress the development of the (erythro)blast leukemia. Either Fress may be required to provide sufficient target cells (early progenitors) to increase the likelihood of infection and thus Fli1 gene activation or its product may directly be required to synergize with Fli1 activity during transformation. It is important to note that as early as 6 weeks after 10A1 infection of NIH/Ola mice, we observed a hyperplasia in the spleen involving both the white pulp (with increased numbers of B cells) and the red pulp (with increased levels of erythroid cells) (J. Löhler and M. Rodenburg, unpublished results). The increased levels of erythropoiesis confirm the early results of Niho et al. (37), who demonstrated dramatic increases in the number of very early progenitors (blast-forming units-erythroid) but not later progenitors (CFU-erythroid) 7 weeks after F-MuLV infection. Whether this hyperproliferation is modulated by Fre, Fli1, or nonspecific effects of virus infection remains to be determined. Molecular identification of the Fre locus or other mouse strain variations that modulate the induction of Fli1-associated (erythro)blastic leukemia will be instrumental in understanding this unique pathology. The presence of disease modifiers in other mouse strains has been clearly demonstrated in a recent study of Graffi (1.2)-MuLV, in which "erythroleukemia" was observed in 72%, 45%, and 26% of mice from FVB/n, NFS, and BALB/c strains, respectively (60).
Conclusions and outlook. Although our in-depth analysis of 10A1-MuLV pathogenicity clearly points to the importance of env (i.e., receptor usage) and LTR (i.e., transcriptional activity) sequences for the induction of a unique blast cell pathology, we find that inherent genetic alterations in the mouse strain are equally important and have been too-often ignored. Somewhat to our surprise, our study has also led us to the conclusion that the erythroleukemia/blastic leukemias induced by several different viruses are exclusively linked to the ability of the virus to activate a single oncogene, Fli1. Thus, although the enhancer element of some MuLVs may be optimized for Fli1 activation within a very early progenitor, inherent properties of the mouse strain are as important, if not more important, for lineage determination. Interestingly, the influence of mouse strain variations appears to be less relevant for the T-cell transformation capacity of Mo-MuLV (and probably SL3-3). This is probably due to the fact that a wider range of oncogenes can be activated to strongly transforming levels by these viruses, either due to the optimal expression levels of these viruses in the T-cell compartment, less rigorous constraints on optimal transforming levels of the oncogene, or the high infectivity of this compartment during fetal development (e.g., more hits). However, even the specificity of these T-tropic viruses can be completely changed when predisposing mutations for B-cell tumors are made in the mouse (58) or when viral mutations increase the frequency of activating an oncogene predisposing to myeloid transformation (3, 45). With the availability of the mouse genomic sequence, future work directed at deciphering differences between mouse strains should provide invaluable insight into MuLV pathogenicity and leukemia. Importantly, the fact that MuLVs generally have pleiotropic infectivity and transcriptional activity, and not lineage-specific activity, makes them excellent tools for delineating cooperating events in carcinogenesis (1, 11, 31).
This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Sto 225/6-1) and the Deutsche José Carreras Leukämie Stiftung. The Heinrich-Pette-Institut is supported by the Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg and the German Ministry of Health and Social Safety.
Published ahead of print on 1 November 2006. ![]()
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»