Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, April 2005, p. 4159-4169, Vol. 79, No. 7
0022-538X/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JVI.79.7.4159-4169.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
HIV Drug Resistance Program, National Cancer Institute at Frederick,1 SAIC-Frederick, Frederick, Maryland2
Received 3 September 2004/ Accepted 17 November 2004
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gag plays important roles in virus assembly; devoid of other viral elements, Gag polyproteins are capable of assembling virus-like particles in cultured cells and in vitro (6, 7, 16, 19, 29, 42). Each domain in Gag plays distinct roles during virus assembly: MA is involved in Gag targeting to the plasma membrane, CA contains major determinants of Gag-Gag interactions that enable Gag multimerization, and NC is important in viral RNA encapsidation (38). Other domains in Gag also play important roles in assembly; for example, MLV p12 and HIV-1 p6 contain motifs, PPPY and PTAP, respectively, that interact with cellular proteins to allow efficient virus release (11, 15, 22, 31).
The cleaved, mature Gag proteins also play important roles in the early events of virus replication. CA is important in the early steps of viral infection; mutations in CA could lead to a decrease of reverse transcription products (2, 5). NC has been proposed to have nucleic acid chaperone activity; mutations in NC affect reverse transcription and efficiency of integration in vivo (4, 17, 24, 33, 47).
Other Gag proteins are also important in multiple steps of viral replication. MLV p12, as a domain in Gag, is important for virus assembly and release; as a mature protein, it plays a critical role in the early events of virus replication (46). Because of the multiple functions of p12, its mutants can have three distinct phenotypes with defects in virus release, viral DNA synthesis, or integration (46). When the PPPY motif in p12 is destroyed, MLV has defects in virus release that resemble mutants of other viruses without functional PPPY or PTAP motifs. Mutations in regions other than PPPY could result in defects in the early stages of viral infection. In some mutants, very little viral DNA synthesis is detected, indicating defects in uncoating or reverse transcription. In other mutants, full-length, newly synthesized DNA can be detected; however, these DNAs are unable to integrate or generate two long terminal repeat (2-LTR) circles, indicating defects in transport of the preintegration complex or other events leading to integration (46). Intriguingly, biochemical analyses indicate little differences in the contents of the preintegration complex between wild-type MLV and a p12 mutant with integration defects (45). Furthermore, the wild-type and mutant complexes both have DNAs with normal processing at the 3' termini, and the isolated preintegration complexes from both wild-type and mutant MLV can perform normal DNA integration in vitro (45). Although these results clearly revealed the importance of p12 during the early events of viral replication, the exact mechanisms of action of p12 have remained unknown.
To learn more about the roles of p12 during early events of viral replication, we have taken the approach of investigating whether a heterologous domain can replace the functions of p12. We selected three heterologous domains to be tested: p2b of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), p6 of HIV-1, and p18 of spleen necrosis virus (SNV). Studies by Yuan and colleagues have demonstrated that the PPPY or PTAP motif of RSV or HIV-1, respectively, can replace MLV PPPY and restore virion production and infectivity (44). However, in these experiments, the rest of the p12 domain was present in the chimeras to supply its functions during early infection. Therefore, whether HIV-1 p6 or RSV p2b can replace the functions of MLV p12 during the early stages of virus infection remains unknown. We selected the p18 domain of SNV because SNV is distantly related to MLV. Although p18 has low homology to p12, it may serve similar functions during the early phase of infection.
To test whether a heterologous domain can replace the functions of p12, we have generated MLV p12 deletion mutants and replaced the p12 domain with RSV p2b, HIV-1 p6, or SNV p18. Although all three domains were able to improve virus production, none of the chimeras were infectious. We previously showed that SNV Gag can replace MLV Gag to support MLV vector replication. We therefore hypothesized that other domains of Gag are needed for the p12/p18 functions. To test this hypothesis, we generated other chimeras and examined their ability to support replication and the possible blocks during replication. Our results demonstrated the restoration of infectivity when p12/p18 and CA were from the same virus, indicating a cooperative effect between homologous p12 and CA in the early stages of viral infection.
|
|
|---|
A cloning strategy was employed to generate mutant gag-pol expression constructs. Briefly, DNA fragments were generated by overlapping PCR and cloned into pWZH30 to generate various gag-pol expression constructs. Plasmids resulting from these procedures were characterized by restriction enzyme mapping, and regions that were generated by PCR were further examined by DNA sequencing to avoid any inadvertent mutations.
Plasmid pM
p12 was constructed as follows. Two overlapping PCR products were independently generated using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 39P and P38 plus 6P; these PCR products were gel purified and combined in an overlap extension PCR using primers P3N and 6PN. The final PCR product was digested with restriction enzymes BsrGI and ClaI, and the resulting fragment was ligated to BsrGI- and ClaI-digested pWZH30. Plasmids pM
p12/MPY and pM
p12/Rp2b were generated using the same strategy, except that the first two PCRs used either primer pair P3 plus 41P and P40 plus 6P (pM
p12/MPY) or P3 plus 47P and P46/6P (pM
p12/Rp2b).
To construct the following plasmids, three overlapping PCR products were generated. These PCR products were gel purified and combined in an additional PCR to generate a DNA fragment containing a partial hybrid gag. The DNA fragment was digested with BsrGI and ClaI and was cloned into pWZH30. For pM
p12/Hp6, two PCR products were amplified using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 45P and P44 plus 6P, and the third PCR product was amplified using pNL4-3 as the template and primer pair P42 plus 43P. For pM
p12/Sp18, two PCR products were generated using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 20P and P19 plus 6P, and the third PCR product was generated using pRD136 as the template and primer pair P17 plus 18P. For pM/SCA, two PCR products were generated using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 4P and P5 plus 6P, and a third PCR product was generated using pRD136 as the template and primer pair P1 and 2P. For pM/SPC, two PCR products were generated using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 20P and P5 plus 6P, and a third PCR product was generated using pRD136 as the template and primer pair P17 plus 2P. For pM/SPCN, two PCR products were generated using pWZH30 as the template and primer pairs P3 plus 20P and P13 plus 6P, and a third PCR product was generated using pRD136 as the template and primer pair P17 plus 14P.
Cell culture, DNA transfection, and virus infection. D17 cells are dog osteosarcoma cells permissive to amphotropic MLV infection (34). The 293T cells are human embryonic kidney cells (12). SR2-293T cells are a pool of 293T cells containing SR2 proviruses derived from the MLV-based vector pSR2 (10), which expresses the hygromycin phosphotransferase B gene (hygro) (20) and the green fluorescent protein gene (gfp) (9). Cells were maintained at 37°C with 5% CO2 in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) supplemented with 6% calf serum (D17) or 10% fetal calf serum (293T) in the presence of penicillin (50 U/ml) and streptomycin (50 µg/ml). SR2-293T cells were transfected by the calcium phosphate precipitation method (MBS transfection kit; Stratagene) (36) with a mixture of DNA containing the gag-pol expression construct and pSV-a-MLV-env at a 5:1 weight ratio, respectively. Plasmid pSV-a-MLV-env expresses amphotropic MLV env (23).
Viruses were harvested 48 h posttransfection and filtered through a 0.45-µm-pore-size membrane (Millipore) to remove cell debris. Serial 10-fold dilutions of the virus samples were performed and used to infect D17 cells in the presence of polybrene (50 µg/ml final concentration). Infected cells were selected with hygromycin (120 µg/ml final concentration), and virus titers were determined by scoring the number of hygromycin-resistant colonies.
Western analyses, RT assay, and electron microscopy (EM) analyses. Viruses were concentrated by ultracentrifugation at 25,000 rpm for 90 min at 4°C using a TH-641 rotor (Sorvall). Viral proteins in virions or in transfected cells were examined by Western analyses using polyclonal rabbit anti-MLV-CA, anti-MLV-MA (a kind gift from the AIDS Vaccine Program, SAIC-Frederick), or anti-SNV-CA antibodies (kind gifts from Nancy Rice, National Cancer Institute-Frederick). Reverse transcriptase (RT) assays were performed using standard procedures (10, 39).
To prepare the samples for EM analyses, transfected SR2-293T cells were washed with phosphate-buffered saline, pelleted by low-speed centrifugation, and fixed in 2% glutaraldehyde in cacodylate buffer (0.1 M, pH 7.4). EM analyses were performed as previously described (40) using a Hitachi H7000 electron microscope, and images were captured by a digital camera system (Gatan).
Viral RNA and DNA analyses. Cell-free virions were harvested from transfected SR2-293T cells, and virion RNAs were isolated using established protocols (13). The amounts of encapsidated SR2 RNA were detected by quantitative real-time RT-PCR using the ABI 7700 sequence detector (Applied Biosystems). Briefly, SR2 RNA was reverse transcribed using random primers, and the resulting DNA was quantified by real-time PCR as previously described (14) using the primers and probe in the hygro sequences (Table 1).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Primers and probes used for real-time PCR and PCR
|
) specific for viral DNA as previously described (14). In parallel experiments, the amounts of the housekeeping gene porphobilinogen deaminase (PBGD) were determined and used as an internal control to standardize DNA recovery during nucleic acid isolation procedures. Data obtained from these analyses were then standardized to the RT activity of the input virus. The sequences of the primers and probes used for real-time PCR are shown in Table 1.
For the analysis of 2-LTR circle viral DNA, total cellular DNA was isolated from target 293T cells 24 h postinfection using the QIAamp DNA Blood Mini kit. The amount of total viral DNA in each sample was determined by real-time PCR using the primer and probe set detecting the U5-
region. Unless specified, the same amount of viral DNA from each sample was used as the template for PCR to detect 2-LTR circle DNA with primers SR2-2LTR-F and SR2-2LTR-R, which annealed to the 5' end of U5 and the 3' end of U3, respectively.
|
|
|---|
To probe the functions of p12 and to test our hypothesis, we generated five MLV-derived gag-pol expression constructs that contained mutations or replacements in p12 (Fig. 1A) based on pWZH30. Because pWZH30 expresses MLV gag-pol from a truncated MLV LTR and does not contain most of the MLV packaging signal, its RNA cannot be efficiently packaged by MLV proteins. However, proteins generated by pWZH30 can efficiently package MLV vector RNAs. In pM
p12, the p12 domain was deleted except for the N- and C-terminal six amino acids to preserve the proteolytic cleavage sites. A DNA fragment encoding the MLV PPPY motif and flanking residues (LLTEDPPPYRDPR) was inserted into pM
p12 to generate pM
p12/MPY (Fig. 1A). Similarly, DNA fragments containing HIV-1 p6, RSV p2b, or SNV p18 sequences were inserted into pM
p12 to generate pM
p12/Hp6, pM
p12/Rp2b, or pM
p12/Sp18, respectively (Fig. 1A).
![]() View larger version (28K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. General structures of the MLV-based gag-pol expression constructs used to study the functions of p12. (A) Wild-type MLV gag-pol expression construct and its derivatives containing a deletion or substitution of the p12 domain. (B) Chimeric MLV-based gag-pol expression constructs containing CA and other domains from SNV. Open boxes, MLV-derived sequences; shaded boxes, SNV-derived sequences; hatched box, HIV-1 p6; stippled box, RSV p2b; dashed line, deleted region.
|
Domains from heterologous viruses restore virion production but not infectivity.
Western analyses were performed to examine the expression of viral proteins in the transfected cells and cell-free supernatants. Representative analyses are shown in Fig. 2. Anti-MLV CA antibody was used to detect viral proteins in cell lysates, whereas both anti-MLV CA and anti-MLV MA antibodies were used to detect viral proteins in the cell-free supernatants. All constructs expressed Gag precursor proteins in transfected cells (Fig. 2A). As expected, compared with pWZH30-transfected cells, pM
p12-transfected cells released reduced amounts of virions into the supernatants (Fig. 2B). However, cells transfected with other gag-pol expression constructs containing various late domain motifs released virus particles into the culture supernatants at levels similar to that of pWZH30 (Fig. 2B). In multiple experiments, virions derived from pM
p12 or pM
p12/Hp6 had more unprocessed Gag or processing intermediates than viruses derived from pWZH30, suggesting that these mutants have processing defects (Fig. 2B). Virions derived from pM
p12/MPY, pM
p12/Rp2b, or pM
p12/Sp18 had low levels of unprocessed Gag or Gag intermediates, generally within the same range of those from pWZH30 in various experiments, suggesting that these mutants had few if any processing defects (Fig. 2B).
![]() View larger version (32K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Western analyses of wild-type and mutant MLV gag gene products in transfected cells (A) and cell-free virions (B). Anti-MLV CA antibody was used to detect gag gene products in transfected cell lysates, whereas both anti-MLV CA and anti-MLV MA antibodies were used to detect gag gene products in virion lysates.
|
p12-, pM
p12/MPY-, pM
p12/Hp6-, or pM
p12/Rp2b-transfected cells did not generate significant SR2 virus titers; however, viruses from pM
p12/Sp18-transfected cells also did not generate significant SR2 titers. These data indicated that replacing p12 with domains from other viruses, including SNV p18, did not restore the functions of MLV p12 during virus replication. |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Virus titers generated by wild-type and mutant viruses
|
p12/Sp18.
In a previous report, we demonstrated that the MLV/SNV chimeric gag-pol construct pSNVgag, which encodes SNV gag and MLV pol, can generate infectious virions (8). In pM
p12/Sp18, MLV p12 was replaced with SNV p18; this substitution restored virus production but not infectivity. Constructs pSNVgag and pM
p12/Sp18 differ in the origins of the MA, CA, and NC domains. We hypothesized that other domains of Gag are important to p12 functions during the early events of virus infection. Of the different domains of Gag, the likely candidates are CA and NC, because MLV CA is present in the preintegration complexes (3, 35) and NC plays important roles during reverse transcription (17, 18, 47). To test this hypothesis, we generated three other MLV-based chimeras containing different Gag domains from SNV (Fig. 1B). Constructs pM/SCA, pM/SPC, and pM/SPCN have SNV CA, SNV P18-CA, and SNV P18-CA-NC replacing their MLV counterparts, respectively. The expression and release of the viral proteins from these chimeras were examined by Western analyses using various combinations of anti-SNV CA, anti-MLV CA, and anti-MLV MA antibodies. Representative Western analyses are shown in Fig. 3. All three chimeric mutants were expressed in the transfected cells (data not shown) and were able to produce cell-free virions. However, compared with the wild-type MLV Gag/Gag-Pol, the amounts of virions released from these three chimeras were reduced, as indicated by the lower intensity of the MA bands (Fig. 3) and consistently lower RT activities (data not shown). Additionally, virions derived from pM/SPCN had defects in Gag processing (Fig. 3B).
![]() View larger version (64K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Western analyses of cell-free virions harvested from cells transfected with wild-type MLV (A) or MLV/SNV chimeric gag-pol expression constructs (B). Anti-MLV MA and anti-MLV CA antibodies were used in the Western analysis shown in panel A, whereas anti-MLV MA and anti-SNV CA antibodies were used for panel B.
|
12/Sp18, both of which were four logs lower than the titers generated by pWZH30-derived viruses. In contrast, viruses derived from pM/SPC had much higher titers (approximately 104 CFU/ml). When standardized to the RT activity, viruses produced from pM/SPC had infectivity similar to that from pWZH30. Viruses derived from pM/SPCN also generated high viral titers (in the range of 104 CFU/ml). Interestingly, the observed Gag-processing defects in pM/SPCN-derived viruses did not eliminate the infectivity (Fig. 3B, Table 2). These results indicated that virus infectivity was restored when both SNV p18 and CA were present in the Gag. Virions derived from wild-type or mutant gag-pol expression constructs can efficiently encapsidate MLV vector RNA. Although most of the eight gag-pol expression constructs we tested did not have severe defects in virus production, only two constructs produced virions with high infectivity. Therefore, the other mutants had blocks elsewhere in the viral replication cycle. A substantial portion of the Gag polyprotein was modified in many mutant constructs; it is possible that the resulting proteins do not package SR2 RNA efficiently, thereby causing the loss of virus infectivity. Using a previously described quantitative real-time RT-PCR assay (14), we measured the amounts of SR2 vector RNA encapsidated in the cell-free virions. These measurements were standardized to RT activity, and the data summarized from three independent sets of experiments are shown in Fig. 4. Our analyses demonstrated that virions derived from all of the aforementioned mutants were able to package SR2 RNA efficiently, within twofold of that of pWZH30-derived virions. Therefore, the loss of infectivity in these mutant virions was not caused by the lack of SR2 RNA packaging in the viral particles. Additionally, these data also suggest that the p12 domain does not contribute to the specificity of virion RNA, which is consistent with the results from Yuan and colleagues (46).
![]() View larger version (25K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Quantitation of MLV vector RNA encapsidated in cell-free virions. Levels of MLV vector SR2 RNA encapsidated in the cell-free virions derived from various gag-pol expression constructs were determined by real-time RT-PCR and normalized to the RT activity of the input virus. For direct comparison, the amount of RNA encapsidated by virions derived from wild-type MLV (pWZH30) was set as 100%. Data from three independent experiments are summarized and are shown as means ± standard errors.
|
, or PBGD sequences. PBGD is a human housekeeping gene, and it serves as a control for DNA recovery during the isolation procedures. DNA samples containing equal copies of PBGD were used in the real-time PCR analyses, and the results obtained were normalized to the RT activity of the virus used to infect the target cells. For direct comparison of the efficiency of reverse transcription, in each set of experiments the copy number of viral DNA detected from cells infected with pWZH30-derived viruses was defined as 100%.
Data summarized from three sets of independent experiments are shown in Fig. 5. Detection of R-U5 DNA revealed that most of the viruses derived from mutant gag-pol expression constructs that failed to generate significant vector titers had a block in reverse transcription. For example, relative to cells infected with pWZH30-derived viruses, R-U5 DNA was drastically decreased (10- to 200-fold) in cells infected with viruses derived from pM
p12, pM
p12/MPY, pM
p12/Hp6, pM
p12/Rp2b, or pM
p12/Sp18. In contrast, viruses that generated significant titers, such as those derived from pM/SPC or pM/SPCN, synthesized R-U5 efficiently. One exception was pM/SCA-derived viruses, which had a 10,000-fold decrease in viral titer (Table 2) but synthesized R-U5 DNA relatively efficiently, with a threefold decrease relative to pWZH30-derived viruses (Fig. 5).
![]() View larger version (25K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Analyses of viral DNA synthesis in 293T cells infected with viruses derived from wild-type or mutant gag-pol expression constructs. (A) Synthesis of early reverse transcription product R-U5. (B) Synthesis of late reverse transcription product U5- . Real-time PCR was performed using primer and probe sets specific to R-U5, U5- , or PBGD sequences. PBGD quantitation served as a standard to control for variation in DNA recovery. For direct comparison, the amount of viral DNA detected from wild-type MLV was set as 100%. Data from three independent experiments are summarized and shown as means ± standard errors.
|
DNA; Fig. 5B) resembled those from the early reverse transcription products (Fig. 5A). These data suggest that once R-U5 was synthesized, the continuing synthesis of the minus-strand DNA and plus-strand DNA transfer could proceed efficiently; therefore, the blocks were likely to be at the very early steps of infection prior to or during the initiation of reverse transcription. Mutation in the PPPY motif of p12 can interfere with the cleavage of MLV envelope transmembrane protein from p15E to the mature form p12E and can affect viral infectivity, most likely via blocks in virus entry (46). Because this cleavage defect can be rescued by inserting a functional late domain motif elsewhere in Gag (44), we do not expect our mutants to have defects in virus entry caused by p15E processing. To ensure that the reverse transcription defects in many mutant viruses were not due to blocks in virus entry, we also examined the efficiency of reverse transcription using viruses pseudotyped with vesicular stomatitis virus protein G (43). Results from real-time PCR analyses (data not shown) were similar to those shown in Fig. 5, suggesting that the step(s) of virus replication beyond entry were blocked.
pM/SCA-derived viruses exhibit a block in the formation of 2-LTR circle DNA. One of the p12 mutation phenotypes is a defect in the formation of integrated proviruses (46). Mutant viruses with this phenotype could synthesize full-length viral DNA relatively efficiently but failed to form provirus or 2-LTR circle DNA (46). Analyses of the reverse transcription products revealed that cells infected with pM/SCA-derived viruses had sufficient early and late reverse transcription products, although these viruses did not generate significant vector titers. These results were reminiscent of p12 mutants with provirus formation defects and led us to investigate whether pM/SCA-derived viruses also encountered blocks in the formation of 2-LTR circle DNA.
To investigate whether the reverse-transcribed DNA can form 2-LTR circles, we isolated total DNA 24 h postinfection. The amounts of viral DNA in these samples were determined by real-time PCR quantitation of the U5-
sequences. Unless specified, DNA containing the same copy number of U5-
sequences was used as the template in the PCR analyses to detect 2-LTR circle DNA with primers annealed to U5 (forward primer) or U3 (reverse primer). The resulting DNA products were analyzed by gel electrophoresis and visualization of ethidium bromide-stained DNA fragments. A representative analysis is shown in Fig. 6. PCR analyses of DNA isolated from cells infected with pWZH30-derived viruses are shown in Fig. 6A, with decreasing amounts of DNA as the template for PCR to illustrate the sensitivity of the assay, whereas PCR analyses of the wild-type and mutant viruses are shown in Fig. 6B. Similar to the studies by Yuan and colleagues (46), DNA from cells infected with pM
p12-derived viruses contained significantly reduced amounts of 2-LTR circle DNA. Not surprisingly, 2-LTR circle DNA was generated in cells infected with pM/SPC-derived viruses, which were able to generate significant viral titers, at efficiencies similar to those from pWZH30. PCR analyses revealed that DNA from cells infected with pM/SCA-derived viruses had significantly reduced 2-LTR circle DNA, approximately 80-fold less, compared with those from pWZH30. These data indicated that pM/SCA also had a block in the post-reverse transcription step, and this CA chimera shared a similar phenotype with the provirus formation-defective p12 mutants.
![]() View larger version (17K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Analyses of 2-LTR circle DNA in 293T cells infected with virions derived from wild-type (WT) (A) or wild-type or mutant gag-pol expression constructs (B). DNA was isolated from infected cells 24 h postinfection, and the amounts of viral DNA in these samples were quantified by detecting U5- sequences. Unless specified in the dilution (dil.) studies in panel A, samples containing equal amounts of viral DNA were used as the template for PCR analyses to detect 2-LTR circle DNA. nts, nucleotides.
|
![]() ![]() View larger version (239K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. EM analyses of wild-type and mutant MLV particles. Virions were derived from pWZH30 (A), pM p12 (B), pM p12/PY (C), pM p12/Hp6 (D), pM p12/Rp2b (E), pM p12/Sp18 (F), pM/SCA (G), pM/SPC (H), or pM/SPCN (I). The black bar in each electron micrograph indicates 100 nm. Tube-like structures are indicated by white arrows; elongated structures are indicated by solid arrows.
|
p12 mostly generated tube-like structures having an even width (Fig. 7B); these results were consistent with previous reports (44). Particles derived from pM
p12/MPY had various morphologies; some were spherical and others appeared to have several spherical structures fused together, creating elongated structures (Fig. 7C). The tube-like structure (Fig. 7B) had a mostly even width throughout the structure; in contrast, the elongated structure (Fig. 7C) often had indentations (or segmentations), creating the appearance of several spherical structures fused together (or structures that were unable to separate). Some elongated structures could be observed in pM
p12 samples. Particles derived from pM
p12/Hp6 often exhibited elongated structures or spherical structures tethered to one another (Fig. 7D). Particles generated by pM
p12/Rp2b also had varied phenotypes, some with a spherical morphology and others with elongated structures or tethered spherical structures (Fig. 7E). Particles generated by pM
p12/Sp18 had a spherical morphology (Fig. 7F); similarly, spherical structures were observed within virions derived from pM/SCA, pM/SPC, or pM/SPCN (Fig. 7G to I). These results indicated that the morphology of the virions generated from pM
p12, pM
p12/MPY, pM
p12/Hp6, or pM
p12/Rp2b is not similar to that of the wild-type viruses. Deletion of the MLV p12 domain caused assembly and release defects; these defects could not be completely corrected by placing the HIV-1 p6 or RSV p2b domain in the location of p12, although these two heterologous domains contained a functional PTAP or PPPY motif. |
|
|---|
Replacing MLV CA with SNV CA resulted in a chimera presenting a phenotype identical to that of the p12 mutant with provirus formation defects, with efficient viral DNA synthesis and severe reduction of 2-LTR circle DNA formation. At this time, we do not know the exact mechanisms of the block in either mutant; however, an interesting possibility is that the same defects caused the disruption of viral replication in both the CA chimera and the provirus formation-deficient p12 mutant, thereby generating the same phenotype. Studies by Yuan and colleagues elegantly demonstrated that the preintegration complexes generated by wild-type MLV and p12 mutants are comparable both biochemically and in their ability to carry out the integration reaction in vitro (45). These data strongly suggest that the p12 mutants have defects in the transport of preintegration complexes. It is possible that CA also plays a role in preintegration complex transport, because CA is part of the MLV preintegration complex (3). Furthermore, the restriction factor Fv-1 targets MLV CA and blocks virus replication at a stage after reverse transcription and before integration, similar to the p12 provirus formation-deficient mutants (37). Strikingly, the MLV preintegration complexes isolated from Fv-1-restricted cells were also functional in vitro, again similar to the p12 mutant (32).
One intriguing hypothesis is that both p12 and CA are important in the proper transport of the MLV preintegration complex, which can be blocked by interference with either protein. This hypothesis can explain why our pM/SCA mutant has a phenotype similar to that of MLV p12 provirus formation-deficient mutants. It is possible that p12 and CA from different viruses cannot properly direct preintegration complex transport. In this scenario, virions produced by both single chimeras (pM/SCA and pMSp18) would have low infectivity, and the virions from the double chimera (pM/SPC) would have fully restored infectivity. Although this hypothesis is attractive, further experiments are needed to better define the blocks in viral replication and the exact nature of the p12-CA cooperative effect. We do not know at this time whether p12 and CA directly interact or if both are required to form a functional preintegration complex. We also do not know whether either protein plays structural roles or more functional roles, such as recruitment of or interaction with host proteins, to direct the transport of the preintegration complex or other steps leading to provirus formation.
The roles of p12 in virion morphology, assembly, and release. It was previously shown that mutations of p12 resulted in two types of morphologically different defects in virions (44). Deletion of p12 resulted in the formation of tube-like structures, whereas destroying the PPPY motif but leaving most of p12 intact resulted in tethered particles similar to late-domain mutants from other viruses. In this report, we generated seven other mutants with modifications in p12 and/or other regions of gag. Preserving the MLV PPPY motif but deleting the rest of p12 or replacing p12 with HIV-1 p6 or RSV p2b rescued the virus production (Fig. 2), but it did not completely restore defects in virus assembly and release. Virions derived from these three constructs had mixed morphologies; some particles appeared to be spherical, and others appeared to be fused to one another in elongated structures (Fig. 7C to E). It was possible that some of the spherical particles we observed in these mutants were actually from the elongated structures. However, we observed far more spherical particles from these constructs than from p12 deletion mutants (Fig. 7B), suggesting that some of the particles were likely to be spherical in nature. These results suggest that the PPPY motif or heterologous domains can partially rescue but cannot restore the wild-type virion morphology. These results enforce the notion that, in addition to the PPPY motif, other parts of p12 play a role in shaping the virion morphology. Interestingly, when we replaced p12 with SNV p18, we observed almost all spherical particles, indicating that p18 can replace the roles of p12 in assembly better than HIV-1 p6 or RSV p2b. One possible interpretation of these results is that p18 is a larger domain than p6 or p2b, therefore it provides sufficient spacing in Gag to allow proper folding and Gag interaction. It is also possible that the particular folding of Gag, and not the size of p18, determines the virion morphology.
Interestingly, a so-called shape-determinant region has been observed in the RSV p10 domain of Gag, which is located between MA and CA and adjacent to p2. Deletion of RSV p10 results in the formation of tubular-shaped virus-like particles; further mapping revealed that the C-terminal region of p10 is responsible for the shape-determinant role during virus assembly (21, 30). It is unclear whether there are regions in MLV p12 and SNV p18 that play the same shape-determinant role during virus assembly. However, the C-terminal region of MLV p12 could not replace the function of RSV p10 during RSV assembly (21). Further experimentation will be needed to characterize whether there are defined regions in MLV p12 that possess the shape-determinant function.
In this report, we demonstrated that viruses generated by various mutants and chimeric MLV gag packaged MLV vector RNA efficiently. These results suggested that MLV p12 did not play a critical role in the specific viral RNA packaging. Interestingly, RSV p10 could affect RNA packaging; mutation in RSV p10 could rescue an RNA packaging-defective NC mutant. These results suggest that RSV p10 could interact with other domains of gag and affect RNA packaging specificity (25).
In summary, results from this study further revealed the multiple roles that p12 plays during MLV replication. The cooperative effect with CA in the early phase of viral replication suggests that p12, together with another viral protein(s), mediates proper transport of the preintegration complex for integration into the host genome. Furthermore, besides the known function of the PPPY motif, other regions of p12 play structural roles during virus assembly to ensure proper morphology of the virions. Future research is needed to further understand the precise roles of p12 in the transport of preintegration complex and virion assembly.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»