Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, June 2005, p. 7868-7876, Vol. 79, No. 12
0022-538X/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JVI.79.12.7868-7876.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
and
Abraham Pinter*
Laboratory of Retroviral Biology, Public Health Research Institute, Newark, New Jersey 07103
Received 11 November 2004/ Accepted 15 February 2005
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
We have recently identified two neutralization targets in SU, one in the receptor binding pocket of the RBD, and one involving a small region that includes the most C-terminal disulfide-bonded loop of the CTD (designated loop 10) (7). The two CTD-specific rat monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) used in that study, 35/56 (23) and 83A25 (11), have distinct strain specificities. Both of these MAbs neutralize MuLV infectivity by blocking a step prior to viral fusion but after receptor binding (7), and additional definition of these epitopes and characterization of the structure and function of this region were therefore expected to provide new insight into the functions of the CTD during viral infection. In the present study, residues within loop 10 that determined the specificities of these MAbs were identified, a requirement was demonstrated for additional residues outside of loop 10 for reactivity with these MAbs, and mutations at specific sites in loop 10 were identified that differentially affected MuLV Env processing, virion association, and viral fusion.
|
|
|---|
Viruses and viral neutralization assays. NIH 3T3 cells chronically infected with MuLVs bearing Env substitution mutations were prepared by transfection of cDNA clones of these MuLVs into NIH 3T3 cells and passage of the cells until infection approached 90% as assayed by immunofluorescence (7, 18). These cells were then used as a source of virions for immunofluorescence-based neutralization assays, which were performed as described previously (7, 18). Percent neutralization was calculated as follows: [1 (percent infection/percent infection of control wells)] x 100. The 50% neutralization dose (ND50) is defined as the concentration of MAb that reduced the number of infected cells by 50% relative to a control infection in the absence of antibodies.
The functional activities of insertion and deletion mutants in Env were quantitated by luciferase assays using luc-expressing virions pseudotyped with mutant Env proteins. These pseudotypes were produced by transfecting 293 cells with a mixture of three plasmids (a retroviral vector plasmid expressing luciferase, an expression plasmid for Friend FB29 MuLV Gag/Pol, and an expression vector for the Env protein) using Fugene reagent (Roche Biochemicals) essentially as described previously (7, 35). Forty-eight hours posttransfection, the cell supernatant was harvested and clarified by filtration through a 0.45-µm syringe filter and used in infectivity assays versus NIH 3T3 cells. The MuLV pseudotypes were normalized by Western blotting (for CA levels) and by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (for SU levels) on pellets of pseudotyped particles. Unless specifically stated, all pseudotypes produced from transfected 293 cells contained similar SU and CA concentrations, and therefore, any phenotypic differences observed in the functional assays accurately reflected differences in Env function.
Construction of loop 10 mutations. Mutations were introduced into the Friend MuLV clone 57 or Friend/AKR 393-426 chimeric Env (7) by QuikChange site-directed mutagenesis (Stratagene). All mutations were initially introduced into the EcoRV-PstI fragments of the indicated SU sequence in pSP72 as described previously (7). After the presence of the desired mutation was verified by sequencing, the mutated fragments were used to replace the homologous region in a two-long terminal repeat MuLV genomic plasmid, and/or a pcDNA3/1 Zeo() (Invitrogen) expression plasmid for Env (7). During the construction of the NLV mutant, a variant containing an extraneous serine residue adjacent to the natural serine at position 405 in the loop 10 sequence was generated as a PCR artifact. The convention used in this paper is to consider the second serine the inserted residue and to refer to this mutant as NLV S405+S. Subsequently, variants of this mutant in which one or both of these serines was converted to threonine were generated by mutagenesis of the NLV S405+S Env.
Cell surface-expressed forms of loop 10-related protein fragments were constructed in pDisplay (Invitrogen), which provided a signal peptide and HA epitope N terminal to the loop 10 sequences and a myc epitope and transmembrane domain C terminal to the insert. Gene fragments incorporating flanking SfiI and SalI restriction sites and encoding AKR residues 397 to 420 (in the Friend MuLV-based numbering system used throughout this report), consisting of loop 10 and flanking residues, or residues 397 to 445, consisting of loop 10 and all SU sequence C terminal to it, were generated by PCR and cloned into the same restriction sites in pDisplay. Plasmids for the expression of full-length SU (Env truncated after R445) or SU truncated after E420 were constructed by generating gene fragments containing stop codons following the indicated codons and a HindIII site by PCR on the Friend/AKR 393-426 chimeric Env, and cloning sequenced EcoRV-HindIII fragments into the expression plasmid for the Friend/AKR 393-426 chimeric Env.
Metabolic labeling and immunoassays. MuLV proteins were radiolabeled by exposing cells to labeling medium (cysteine-free DMEM plus 10% dialyzed fetal bovine serum and 50 µCi/ml of [35S]cysteine) for 12 to 14 h as previously described (29); for pulse-chase experiments, labeling medium was added for 0.5 h and then replaced with cold complete DMEM for the period described. Labeled cell culture supernatants were filtered through 0.45-µm syringe filters to remove cellular debris before use. Cell-associated samples were collected by washing cells once with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and then lysing with radioimmunoprecipitation buffer (29). Radioimmunoprecipitation (29) and Western blotting assays (30) were performed as previously described.
Intersubunit disulfide bond isomerization was induced for wild-type (NLV) and mutant (S405T+S) virions either by solubilization with 1% NP-40 or treatment with 2 M urea for 30 min at 30°C and inhibited by treating with 20 mM N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) for 1 h at room temperature as described previously (37). The effects of pretreatment with MAb 83A25 (20 µg/ml for 1 h at 4°C) on isomerization of wild-type virions and the ability of the S405+T mutant to isomerize were examined.
Cell binding and fusion assays. Fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) assays to detect MuLV binding were performed as previously described (7, 40). Briefly, 293.mCAT cells were detached with trypsin-EDTA, and a total of 5 x 105 cells were incubated with 1 ml of pseudotype MuLV particles at 4°C for 2 h with gentle agitation. Cells were washed with 1 ml of ice-cold 10% fetal bovine serum in PBS (FACS buffer) and resuspended in polyclonal goat anti-Rauscher MuLV SU serum diluted 1:250 in FACS buffer. Cells were incubated for an additional 1 h at 4°C, washed again, and incubated with fluorescein isothiocyanate-conjugated anti-goat immunoglobulin G (Zymed) at 5 µg/ml in FACS buffer. After a 0.5-h incubation at 4°C, cells were washed again, fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS, and analyzed by flow cytometry using a FacsCalibur flow cytometer (Becton Dickinson) and associated software.
Syncytium formation by MuLV pseudotypes on XC cells was assayed as previously described (26). Briefly, XC cell monolayers were incubated with cell culture supernatants containing pseudotyped MuLV particles for 2.5 h of incubation at 37°C. After the cells were washed, fixed with methanol, and stained with cresyl violet, the extent of fusion was quantitated by counting the total number of nuclei present in syncytia containing more than four nuclei under the microscope.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (19K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. (Top) Diagram of the Friend/AKR (393-426) chimeric SU (7). Friend MuLV clone 57 sequences (shaded areas) and AKR.623 sequences (white areas) are indicated. (Bottom) Sequence alignment of residues 393 to 426 of Friend MuLV and AKR MuLV SU, corresponding to the AKR fragment exchanged into Friend MuLV clone 57 to generate the Fr/AKR (393-426) chimera. Conserved residues are indicated by dashes, while polymorphic residues are listed.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Analysis of contributions of polymorphic residues in MuLV SU C-terminal domain to epitope expression
|
The 83A25 MAb has been reported to recognize two MuLV isolates, Moloney ecotropic and 4070A amphotropic viruses, which both contain an N at position 410 (8, 11, 16). Consistent with this, MAb 83A25 possessed weak reactivity in both neutralization and immunofluorescence assays for these two Env proteins (Table 1), similar to its level of reactivity with the D410N mutant of the Fr/AKR(393-426) chimera. As previously reported (31), MAb 35/56 showed no reactivity with these Env proteins, also consistent with the lack of reactivity of this MAb to the D410N mutant of the Fr/AKR chimera.
Sequences N terminal to loop 10 are required for expression of the MAb 35/56 and 83A25 epitopes. The studies described above map determinants for both epitopes to sites in loop 10 but do not rule out the involvement of additional residues, including positions outside of this region, in their expression. The loss of both epitopes upon reduction of disulfide bonds (7) might indicate a dependence on the disulfide at the base of loop 10 but could also be due to a requirement for disulfides at distal sites in SU. These possibilities were examined by studying the reactivities of these MAbs to several recombinant proteins expressing loop 10, with and without additional gp70-derived sequences.
The loop 10 region was expressed in the absence of other SU sequences as a fusion protein in which this loop and a few adjoining residues were flanked by HA and myc epitope tags, and it was expressed as a cell surface protein by linking to a C-terminal transmembrane domain (construct 1 in Fig. 2A). After immunoprecipitation of lysates of cells expressing this construct with an antibody to the myc epitope, a band of the expected size was detected in Western blots by probing with an antibody to the HA epitope tag (Fig. 2B, left panel). The mobility of this band was slightly higher when the sample was analyzed under nonreducing conditions than under reducing conditions, suggesting the presence of the disulfide bond at the base of loop 10. When the anti-myc immunoprecipitate was probed with the 83A25 and 35/56 MAbs, no reactivity was observed (Fig. 2B, right panel), consistent with the lack of immunofluorescent staining of these cells when probed with these MAbs (not shown). These results suggested that loop 10 and the immediate adjoining sequences expressed in this fusion protein were not sufficient for expression of these epitopes. A similar lack of reactivity was observed for a related protein that also contained the additional SU sequences C terminal to loop 10 (not shown), suggesting that residues N terminal to position 397 were required for expression of these epitopes.
![]() View larger version (32K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Analysis of immunoreactivity of SU fragments containing loop 10. A. Representations of constructs used for this analysis. Construct 1 is the fragment expressing isolated AKR loop 10 together with six N-terminal and four C-terminal flanking residues (residues 397 to 420), surrounded by HA and myc epitope tags followed by a C-terminal PDGRF TM domain tag. Construct 2 is secreted Friend/AKR (393-426) SU (SU-sec) generated by inserting a stop codon after the codon for residue 445 at the C terminus of SU. Construct 3 is the secreted fragment of chimeric Friend/AKR (328-420) SU generated by inserting a stop codon after the codon for residue 420. B. Western blot analysis of immunoreactivity of isolated loop 10 (construct 1 in panel A). (Left) Cells expressing this construct were lysed, immunoprecipitated with antibody to the N-terminal HA tag ( HA), separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) both before and after reduction and probed with antibody to the C-terminal myc epitope tag. The larger band in the reduced sample is a minor contaminant that may represent an alternatively processed form of the fusion protein. ()DTT and (+)DTT, absence and presence of dithiothreitol, respectively. (Right) The same protein was immunoprecipitated with anti-myc antibody and probed after blotting under nonreducing conditions with anti-HA antibody ( HA) and MAbs 83A25 and 35/56. C. Analysis of expression of conformational epitopes in secreted SU (construct 2 in panel A) and a secreted SU fragment truncated after loop 10 at residue E420 (construct 3 in panel A). Cell supernatants containing labeled full-length (SU-sec) or truncated (E420-stop) proteins were immunoprecipitated two times sequentially with the indicated MAbs at 15 µg/ml (lanes 1 and 2), and any remaining Env protein was then detected by precipitation with polyclonal anti-gp70 serum (lanes PC). Immunoprecipitated proteins were analyzed by SDS-PAGE and detected by autoradiography.
|
Effects of loop 10 mutations on Env function.
The potent neutralizing activity and fusion-blocking activity of MAbs 35/56 and 83A25 suggested a role for loop 10 and/or adjacent regions in a postbinding function of Env. In an attempt to confirm such a role for this domain and to localize the residues involved, mutations in loop 10 were generated and their effects on infectivity determined using luciferase-encoding viral pseudotypes (Table 2). The general requirement of this loop for Env function was first examined by replacing the 10 central residues of the 12-residue loop of the Fr/AKR(393-426) chimera (positions 405 to 414) with a glycine-alanine-glycine (GAG) tripeptide (
loop 10). This mutant was completely defective in the MuLV/luciferase pseudotype assay (Fig. 3A). An analysis of the levels of SU incorporated into virions by radioimmunoprecipitation of labeled virions showed that this lack of infectivity of
loop 10 was due to the absence of SU from viral particles (Fig. 3B). The basis of this defect was examined by a pulse-chase analysis (Fig. 3C). After a 30-min pulse, the Env protein of wild-type Fr/AKR(393-426) existed mostly in the form of the gPr80 precursor, with some mature SU also present, while after the 1-h chase period, almost all of the gPr80 was converted to SU, which remained cell associated. In contrast to this, cells producing
loop 10 Env contained only unprocessed Env precursor even at the latest time points. The absence of any intermediate gPr90 product typically formed upon transport into the Golgi bodies (18) suggested that this mutant Env was defective in transport from the endoplasmic reticulum, presumably due to improper folding.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Characterization of immunoreactivity of neutralization sensitivity of loop 10 substitutions and deletions
|
![]() View larger version (72K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Titration of infectivity and SU and CA levels of wild-type and loop 10 mutant MuLV pseudotypes. (A) Dilutions of MuLV/luciferase pseudotypes bearing the indicated SUs were used to infect NIH 3T3 target cells and assayed for luciferase expression at 2 (left panel) or 3 days postinfection (right panel). Black columns, 1:2 dilution; grey columns, 1:6 dilution. All samples were assayed in triplicate, and infectivity is expressed as relative light unit (RLU) output. (B) Transfected 293 cells used to produce the MuLV/luciferase pseudotypes analyzed in Fig. 2A were labeled with [35S]cysteine, and the secreted virions were pelleted by centrifugation and assayed for SU and CA content by precipitating with polyclonal sera specific for these viral proteins, separation by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), and visualized by autoradiography. (C) Pulse-chase analysis of wild-type and defective Fr/AKR (393-426) Env loop 10 mutants. 293 cells transfected with plasmids expressing the indicated env genes were pulse-labeled at 24 h with [35S]cysteine for 30 min and chased for the indicated time points in hours, and cell lysates were precipitated with anti-SU polyclonal serum followed by SDS-PAGE. Pre, Env precursor.
|
loop 10 mutant in that no SU protein was associated with virions (Fig. 3B) and lysates of transfected cells contained only the unprocessed Env precursor (Fig. 3C). This suggested that the loss of residues 404, 405, and/or 406 accounted for the defectiveness of
loop 10. To further pinpoint the contribution of these residues to the defectiveness of these mutants, individual substitutions were prepared at each of the first three positions of the loop. 404G is found in other natural sequences, and 404L and 406A are present in the Friend MuLV Env, and thus, it was presumed that these substitutions would retain function. I404A, S405A, and T406G mutants were generated and the resulting pseudovirions analyzed for Env incorporation levels and functional activity (Table 2 and Fig. 3). The I404A mutant possessed wild-type levels of infectivity and a normal level of SU in virions. The T406G mutant also possessed the normal amount of SU but was slightly attenuated for infectivity, with luciferase levels three- to eightfold below that of the wild-type control. In contrast, the S405A Env was strongly attenuated (>200-fold less luciferase activity than the control) (Fig. 3A). There was a significantly decreased level of S405A SU present in virions (Fig. 3B), which presumably accounted for the attenuation. While this mutant did undergo proteolytic processing with only slightly lower than normal efficiency, there was little accumulation of mature SU in the cell lysates (Fig. 3C). Additional experiments showed that the processed SU was released from cells much more rapidly than wild-type SU (not shown), consistent with increased shedding of SU due to destabilization of the SU-TM interaction. These results suggested that residue S405 played a role in the stable association between SU and TM and that additive effects of changes at residues 405 and 406 accounted for the defectiveness of the GAG 404-406 mutant.
Effects of loop 10 mutations on epitope expression.
The effects of the mutations in loop 10 described above on the expression of the epitopes recognized by MAb 35/56 and 83A25 were examined by immunofluorescence assays on transfected cells and, for infectious mutants, by neutralization assays (Table 2). The
loop 10 mutant and the first three GAG substitutions, encompassing residues 404 to 412, were not reactive with either MAb 35/56 or 83A25. This was consistent with the contributions of residues in the region of positions 404 to 411 to these epitopes (Table 1). The GAG(413-415) substitution mutant retained reactivity with both MAbs and was considerably more sensitive to neutralization by these two MAbs, with ND50s 35- to 45-fold lower than that for the wild-type Env. The sensitivity of this mutant to neutralization by the RBD-specific MAb 59C9 was similar to that of wild-type Env, suggesting that the substitution of these residues did not cause a general hypersensitivity to neutralization but rather induced an increased affinity or accessibility specifically for MAbs 83A25 and 35/56. The S405A mutation possessed the same (for MAb 35/56) or slightly higher (for MAb 83A25) neutralization sensitivity as the wild type, indicating that despite the functional defects of this mutation, it did not affect the structure or accessibility of these epitopes. However, in contrast to the natural I404L polymorphism, the I404A mutation resulted in a significant decrease (three- to eightfold) in neutralization sensitivity to both MAbs, and the T406G substitution resulted in a complete loss of neutralization by both MAbs, again in contrast to the natural T406A polymorphism that had only a small effect on neutralization (Table 1). These results indicated subtle contributions of these positions to the formation of these epitopes.
Effects of insertions in the N-terminal region of loop 10 on Env function. There is a stretch of three Ser/Thr residues at positions 405 to 407 near the N terminus of AKR loop 10. In the course of producing the NLV variant (Table 1), an extraneous serine residue was serendipitously introduced adjacent to Ser405, resulting in the NLV S405+S insertion mutant. This mutant Env was partially attenuated in the luc transduction assay, with a fourfold reduction in activity (Fig. 3A and Table 3). Pseudoviral particles generated with this Env mutant contained a normal amount of SU (Fig. 3B), indicating that the decreased activity was not due to defects in expression, processing, or association of SU with particles. In contrast to the NLV Env, the NLV S405+S mutant was not recognized by MAb 83A25 (Table 3), consistent with the sensitivity of this epitope to other changes near the N terminus of loop 10.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Properties of position 405/406 insertions/substitutions in loop 10 region of MuLV Env
|
![]() View larger version (55K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. A. Analysis of binding and fusion activity of MuLV pseudotypes containing Friend MuLV clone 57 (Friend 57) wild-type, Fr/AKR(NLV), and Fr/AKR(NLV)S405+S Env proteins. (Left panels) Pseudotyped particles were incubated at the indicated serial dilutions with 293.mCAT cells, and the extent of binding of virions was quantitated by flow cytometry. (Right panels) XC cells were overlaid with the indicated MuLV pseudotypes, and syncytium formation was analyzed by microscopy (photographed at a magnification of x400). B. Measurement of receptor binding and envelope expression of the highly defective S405T+T loop 10 mutant. (Left) Flow cytometric measurement of binding of MuLV pseudotypes bearing Fr/AKR(NLV) wild-type and Fr/AKR(NLV) S405T+T mutant Env proteins to 293.mCAT cells. Particles without any Env proteins [() Env] were included as controls. (Right) Analysis of virion protein content for mutant S405T+T Env and wild-type Fr/AKR(NLV) pseudotypes. Particles in supernatant medium were pelleted through 20% sucrose, lysed, and analyzed for SU and CA content by Western blotting. Fivefold serial dilutions of the samples were probed by polyclonal anti-SU serum and anti-CA serum.
|
Neither mutation of loop 10 nor its binding by neutralizing MAb prevented denaturation-induced isomerization of the intersubunit disulfide bond. SU and TM are present in virions as a disulfide-bonded heterodimer that dissociates into its subunits by isomerization of the intersubunit disulfide bond upon solubilization of virions or treatment with denaturants (24, 32, 33, 36, 37). This isomerization is blocked by prior treatment with the thiol alkylating agent NEM (33) and involves a cysteine present in the CWLC motif at positions 312 to 315 of the CTD domain (32). The possibility that the functional effects seen upon antibody binding or mutagenesis of loop 10 were related to this disulfide bond rearrangement was investigated for the Friend MuLV NLV Env and its fusion-defective derivative bearing the S405T+S mutation (Fig. 5). As expected, solubilization with NP-40 induced isomerization of essentially all of the NLV SU to free SU, and this isomerization was blocked by pretreatment with NEM. A similar effect was seen upon denaturation with urea, although in this case isomerization was less complete. Prebinding of MAb 83A25 to NLV virions at neutralizing concentrations did not inhibit dissociation to SU under either condition, indicating that binding of this MAb did not interfere with isomerization of the disulfide bond. Similarly, for the defective S405T+S Env mutant, the SU-TM disulfide-bonded complex was also present after treatment with NEM, and the dissociation of this complex to free SU occurred as efficiently following treatment with either NP-40 or urea for this mutant as for the parental NLV Env. These results did not support a role for interference with isomerization of the intersubunit disulfide bond for either the neutralizing activity of 83A25 or the lack of function of the S405T+S Env mutant.
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Denaturation-induced isomerization of the intersubunit disulfide bond. [35S]cysteine-labeled NLV virions with (+) and without () pretreatment with MAb 83A25 (left gels) and NLV S504T+S virus (right gels) were exposed to 1% NP-40 or 2 M urea with (+) and without () prior treatment with NEM. All samples were treated with NEM prior to immunoprecipitation with polyclonal anti-SU serum and analyzed by nonreducing sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The film exposure time shown for the NLV S504T+S samples was four times longer than for the NLV samples to adjust for lower incorporation of [35S]cysteine.
|
|
|
|---|
The most critical determinants in loop 10 for the epitope specificity of MAbs 35/56 and 83A25 were positions 410 and 411. Substituting Arg411 in the AKR sequence by Leu resulted in the complete loss of reactivity with both MAbs, while conversion of Asp410 to Asn resulted in complete loss of reactivity with MAb 35/56 and a significant reduction in the affinity and neutralizing activity of MAb 83A25. An Asn at position 410 introduces a signal for N-linked glycosylation (13, 18), and the presence of this glycan may contribute to the inhibition of binding of these MAbs. Earlier studies have reported that MAb 35/56 was highly type specific for endogenous MuLV isolates represented by the AKR strain (23, 25, 31), while MAb 83A25 was more broadly reactive with MuLVs, including ecotropic Moloney MuLV and amphotropic 4070A MuLV (8, 11, 16). Asp410 is present in the Akv provirus locus and in endogenous MuLVs produced from expression of this locus, while Asn410 is in the consensus sequence for exogenous MuLV Env proteins. The weak reactivity of MAb 83A25 with the Asn410 substitution mutant in the AKR-derived loop 10 was consistent with its relatively low reactivity with Moloney MuLV and 4070A Env proteins in both immunofluorescence and neutralization assays (Table 1).
Additional positions in the N-terminal half of the loop also contributed to the reactivity of these epitopes but in more subtle ways. The reactivity of both MAbs was completely lost upon replacement of the Thr406 by Gly, while substituting an Ala at this position or mutating the Ile at position 404 to Ala resulted in relatively small increases in ND50s for these MAbs (Tables 1 and 2). Mutations of other polymorphic residues in this region (Ser 397 to Asn, Ile404 to Leu, and Ile408 to Val) had little or no effect on either MAb when introduced individually but had a significant impact on the activity of MAb 35/56, but not 83A25, when combined (the NLV substitution in Table 1). Adding the Thr406-to-Ala substitution to the other three changes resulted in complete loss of MAb 35/56 reactivity and strongly attenuated the neutralization activity of MAb 83A25. Thus, the greater strain specificity of MAb 35/56 over 83A25 can be accounted for by its higher sensitivity to the Asn at position 410, along with the greater sensitivity of this MAb to combinations of several other substitutions in the N-terminal region of loop 10.
While these studies localized determinants of both epitopes to loop 10 and accounted for the type specificities of these MAbs, they did not fully define these epitopes. A role for residues outside of loop 10 in the expression of these epitopes was indicated by the lack of immunoreactivity of a fusion protein expressing the isolated loop 10 with either of these MAbs (Fig. 2B), and the localization of these residues to N-terminal sequences was suggested by the efficient reactivity of these MAbs with a fraction of a secreted SU truncation mutant that terminated shortly after loop 10 (Fig. 2C). The absence of these epitopes on the majority of the truncated molecules may be due to an alternate disulfide bond pattern for those molecules. All of the truncated molecules were efficiently precipitated by 59C9, a MAb that reacts with a disulfide bond-dependent epitope located in the N-terminal receptor-binding domain, indicating that the folding defects of this protein were limited to the CTD, and secreted full-length SU was completely precipitated by MAbs 35/56 and 83A25, indicating that improper folding of the CTD was not due to the absence of the TM domain. This suggested that the presence of SU sequences C terminal to loop 10 facilitated proper folding of the CTD.
The critical role of loop 10 in Env function is consistent with a previous mutational analysis of Moloney MuLV Env based on five-residue insertions throughout SU and TM, including seven mutations within loop 10 (34). Mutants containing inserts after the first, second, and third residues of the loop, in the same region as the serine/threonine insertions described in this study, were expressed on the cell surface but were noninfectious, while mutants with insertions in the middle of the loop, after residues 408, 411, and 413, remained infectious. An insertion at the C-terminal end of loop 10 abrogated cell surface expression of Env, presumably because of misfolding. Cell surface binding activity was assayed for two of the N-terminal insertions and was not detected. However, binding was measured by flow cytometry using MAb 83A25, and the results described above suggest that the observed result was due to the loss of the MAb 83A25 epitope, rather than an inability of these mutants to bind to the receptor.
How does modification of loop 10 by antibody binding or mutagenesis lead to the inhibition of fusion? Denaturation-induced isomerization of the intersubunit disulfide bond between SU and TM was not inhibited either by MAb 83A25 binding to wild-type Env or by a Thr insertion after position 405 that blocked fusion activity (Fig. 5). This suggested that loop 10 function is either independent of this isomerization or that it occurs subsequent to the rearrangement. However, it is also possible that the normal stimulus for isomerization may depend on loop 10 function but that the denaturation conditions used to experimentally induce isomerization bypass this requirement.
Previous studies demonstrated an interaction between sites near the N terminus of the RBD and the CTD of SU that mediate postattachment steps required for infection by MuLV (3, 4, 21). For virions bearing amphotropic/ecotropic chimeric Env proteins, an incompatibility was detected between the amphotropic RBD and a region of the ecotropic CTD that encompassed disulfide-bonded loops 8 and 9 of SU, but not loop 10 (20). This incompatibility was attributed to a defect in a putative interaction between the amphotropic RBD and the ecotropic CTD, suggesting a role for loops 8 and 9, but not loop 10, in these interactions. There are several possible ways to reconcile these results with a role for loop 10 in a postattachment step required for fusion. One possibility is that the key CTD structure is a complex of loops 8, 9, and 10 that together interacts with the RBD, mediating a conformational change of Env following receptor binding that is required for membrane fusion. Such a complex may contain the remaining determinants for the epitopes of MAbs 35/56 and 83A25. It is also possible that loop 10 mediates a distinct step required for fusion in addition to the interaction of loops 8 and 9 with the RBD, such as an interaction with the TM subunit that leads to the exposure of the fusion peptide of TM. In either scenario, either the Ser/Thr insertions near the N terminus of loop 10 or the binding of MAbs to this region presumably interferes with the necessary interaction and thereby inhibits fusion. It is also possible that loop 10 may not be directly involved in fusion, but by virtue of its close location to a fusion-critical structure (e.g., loops 8 and 9), changing the size and/or shape of this loop or binding of an antibody to this region indirectly disrupts the function of the proximal structure.
Areas for further study that can help distinguish these possibilities include additional identification of determinants within and outside of loop 10 that mediate its effects on fusion, including the identification of regions in SU and/or TM that interact with this region, and more complete determination of the structures of the MAb 35/56 and 83A25 epitopes. A powerful way of obtaining such information would be by determining the crystal structure of complexes between SU and loop 10-directed MAbs. Isolation and characterization of mutants that are resistant to loop 10-directed MAbs and functional revertants of defective loop 10 mutants would also provide useful insights into these questions.
We thank Beverly Barton of the University of Medicine and Dentistry, Newark, N.J., for assistance with the cell sorting assays.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»