Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, May 2005, p. 5996-6004, Vol. 79, No. 10
0022-538X/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JVI.79.10.5996-6004.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Pathology,1 Division of Molecular Genetics, National Institute of Infectious Diseases, Tokyo 162-8640,2 Department of Virology, Research Institute for Microbial Diseases, Osaka University, Osaka 565-0871, Japan3
Received 29 October 2004/ Accepted 6 January 2005
|
|
|---|
D in a primary-isolate-derived Env decreased syncytium-forming activity and infectivity. The assays for cell-cell fusion and viral binding suggested that the enhanced fusion mediated by the 36D
G mutation is not due to increased binding efficiency but is directly due to actual enhancement of viral fusion activity. Interestingly, this amino acid position is exactly equivalent to that at which the mutation of HIV-1 isolates that have escaped from a fusion inhibitor, enfuvirtide (T-20), has been frequently observed. The correlation between these previous findings and our findings was suggested by structural analysis. Our finding, therefore, has implications for a molecular basis of the viral escape from this drug. |
|
|---|
The fusion inhibitor enfuvirtide (also known as T-20), a peptide based on the sequence of the C-peptide helix in gp41, blocks formation of the six-helix bundle and thus prevents membrane fusion (8, 27, 45). A mutation in the N-peptide helix of gp41, specifically, an aspartic acid substitution for glycine at position 36, which was selected both in vitro (24, 35, 40) and in vivo (42), affects viral sensitivity to T-20, presumably by altering the affinity of T-20 for the N-peptide helix.
We have previously reported that an established cell line, L-2, derived from MT-4 cells surviving after in vitro acute-phase infection with an MT-4/MOLT-4 cell-propagated LAI strain, produces highly fusogenic but replication-defective HIV-1 particles (20). The L-2-produced viruses are peculiar, as the morphology of the viral particles is doughnut shaped since the protease gene is mutated and in that the virions harbor a robust activity to induce syncytia despite lacking infectivity (16, 32). To characterize the L-2-derived viruses, we generated a full-length infectious DNA clone, pL2, using proviral DNA extracted from L-2 cells. By performing a chimeric analysis between pL2 and pNL4-3, we found that pL2-derived regions, including env, induce enhanced syncytium formation as expected (21).
In this study, we further sought to determine the region that conferred the fusogenic activity at the amino acid level, by creating env recombinants between pL2 (or its parent pLAI) and pNL4-3, and several point mutants based on pNL4-3. The results demonstrate that amino acid 36 of gp41 is a key determinant of the fusion activity and infectivity enhancement and that glycine 36 of gp41, commonly seen in pL2 and the parental pLAI, is conserved in nearly all HIV-1 isolates except for pNL4-3 (and, surprisingly, T-20 escape mutants), which carry aspartic acid at this position (36D). By exploiting structural modeling of gp41, we were able to predict the cause of the fusogenic difference between L2/LAI and NL4-3 viruses. Together with the finding that escape mutants from the T-20 fusion inhibitor harbor the same 36D mutation (24, 27, 35, 40, 42), these results imply a molecular basis for the emergence of viruses resistant to this drug.
|
|
|---|
Ala, 22Thr
Arg, 36Asp
Gly, 22Thr
Ala, or 91Leu
Phe, QuikChange mutagenesis (Stratagene) was performed by using pGL3NL-N/X-Blp as a template DNA. The resultant BlpI and NotI fragments were inserted into pNL-envCT, and the constructs were designated pNL-gp41-C21A, pNL-gp41-T22R, pNL-gp41-T22A, pNL-gp41-D36G, and pNL-gp41-L91F, respectively. Similarly, an amino acid change of 36Gly
Asp was introduced into pNL-1549 harboring a primary isolate (QH1549)-derived Env protein (37) to create pNL-1549-G36D. To quantify the infectivity, the PCR-amplified NotI-XhoI fragment of the luciferase (Luc) gene was inserted into NotI-XhoI region of pNL-envCT, pNL-gp41-D36G, pNL-1549, or pNL-1549-G36D and designated pNL-Luc-envCT, pNL-Luc-gp41-D36G, pNL-Luc-1549, or pNL-Luc-1549-G36D, respectively. Env expression plasmids pNLn
Bs (NL-Env expression plasmid) and pNLn
Bs-Nh (
Env control plasmid) were previously described (38). pNLn
Bs-D36G was constructed by replacement of the NheI-BamHI region of pNL-gp41-D36G in the corresponding sites of pNLn
Bs. To generate pLTR-hLucP+, the 5' long terminal repeat (LTR) sequence of pNL4-3 was PCR amplified and inserted into pGL3(R2.1)-Basic vector carrying the Rapid Response luciferase gene (Promega). To generate a Tat expression plasmid, pLTR-Tat, the tat sequence of pNL4-3 was PCR amplified and replaced with the humanized Luc gene from pLTR-hLucP+. To generate pNL-
env, an envelope-defective control vector, a frameshift mutation was introduced into the NdeI site within env gene of pNL4-3. Cell maintenance and transfection. MOLT-4, M8166, CEMx174, H9, 293T, and MAGIC5A cells were maintained as described elsewhere (30, 32, 38). To prepare viral supernatants, 7 x 105 293T cells were transfected with 2 µg of each proviral expression plasmid by using FuGENE 6 (Roche). Sixteen hours later, cells were washed with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), and then 2 ml of fresh complete medium was added. Twenty-four hours later, supernatants were filtered through 0.45-µm-pore-size filters. Levels of virion production were quantitated by HIV-1 p24 antigen capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (Retro-Tek).
Syncytium formation assay. MOLT-4, M8166, CEMx174, or H9 cells (5 x 104) were incubated with 200 ng of p24 antigen of each virus at 37°C. After incubation for 48 h, the cells were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS, and the formation of syncytia was observed under a light microscope.
Viral infectivity assay. MAGIC5A cells (5 x 105) were incubated with viral supernatants containing 10 ng of p24 antigen. Forty-eight hours after infection, cells were lysed in 100 µl of lysis buffer (Promega), and Luc activities were measured by MicroLumat LB 96V (Berthold).
Viral binding assay.
One hundred nanograms of p24 of NL-
env (control), NL-envCT (wild type [WT]), or NL-gp41-D36G (D36G mutant) virus was added to 1.5 x 106 MAGIC5A cells at 4°C. After 3 h of incubation, cells were washed three times with PBS and then lysed in 100 µl of lysis buffer. The p24 antigen content of the lysates was measured by ELISA. The background obtained with control viruses was subtracted from sample values.
Cell-cell fusion assay.
293T cells as effector cells and MAGIC5A cells as target cells were transfected with pNLn
Bs (WT-env), pNLn
Bs-D36G (D36G-env), or pNLn
Bs-Nh (control env), plus pLTR-Tat, and with pLTR-hLucP+, respectively. After 48 h, both cell types were washed, trypsinized, and cocultured in a 12-well plate. After 5 h of incubation, cells were lysed in 200 µl of lysis buffer, and Luc activities were measured with a MicroLumat LB 96V. Transfection efficiency was normalized by cotransfection of 293T with phRL-CMV (Promega), which expresses a renilla luciferase.
Molecular modeling of the HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain trimer.
To construct three-dimensional (3-D) structures of intact ectodomain trimers, we used the crystal structure of the simian immunodeficiency virus gp41 ectodomain trimer at a high resolution at 1.47 Å (Protein Data Bank code 1QBZ) (48) as a template for homology modeling. Although several other crystallographic structures of the HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain are available from the Protein Data Bank, those structures are either monomers or trimers lacking a majority of the N helix, C helix, and loop connecting the helices. 1QBZ has a sequence similarity of 52.5% to the target NL4-3 gp41 ectodomain, which is high enough to construct high-accuracy models with a root mean square distance (RMSD) of
1 Å for the main chain between the predicted and actual structures (2). Monomer chains termed A, B, and C in the trimer structure 1QBZ lack 21, 9, and 3 amino acid residues, respectively. To minimize effects of the missing residues on the modeling, 1QBZ was modified by superimposing the chain C residues, which carry the fewest missing residues, on the chain A and chain B residues, and the modified 1QBZ structure was used as a template structure for modeling. 3-D models of HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain trimers of NL4-3 and the D36G mutant were constructed independently by the homology modeling technique using MOE-Align and MOE-Homology in the Molecular Operating Environment (MOE) (Chemical Computing Group Inc.). The 3-D structures were thermodynamically optimized by energy minimization using the MOE and a CHARMm22 force field. Physically unacceptable local structures of the optimized 3-D models were further refined on the basis of evaluation by Ramachandran plot and chi plot using programs packaged in MOE. We also tested distinct procedure for the modeling. In this case, we first made the NL4-3 gp41 model alone from the simian immunodeficiency virus template structure and then substituted the amino acid at position 36 from D to G, followed by energy minimization. This procedure generated a structure indistinguishable from the D36G structure obtained by the first procedure. Thus, we used structures made by the first procedure in the present study.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (64K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Construction of gp120 and gp41 chimeric full-length proviral DNAs and their syncytium-forming activities. An HIV-1 envelope cassette vector, pNL-envCT (WT), harbors MroI, BlpI, and NotI restriction enzyme sites immediately upstream of the gp120, gp41, and nef genes of pNL4-3, respectively. The envelope gp160, gp120, and gp41 genes of pLAI and pL2 were replaced with the corresponding regions of pNL-envCT. MOLT-4, M8166, CEMx174, or H9 cells (5 x 104) were incubated with 200 ng of p24 antigen of each virus. After 48 h, cells were fixed and observed by microscopy. Arrows indicate the formation of syncytia.
|
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Construction of gp41 recombinants and point mutants and their syncytium-forming activities and infectivities. (A) Chimeric viruses carrying three different regions of gp41 derived from pLAI or pL2 were constructed by utilizing the restriction enzyme sites BlpI, HindIII, BamHI and NotI. (B) Amino acid substitutions (21C A, 22T R, 22T A, 36D G, or 91L F) were introduced within the BlpI-HindIII region of gp41 by site-directed mutagenesis. Asterisks show mutant constructs harboring a mutation commonly seen in both pLAI and pL2. The syncytium-formation assay (A and B) was performed as described for Fig. 1. Arrows indicate the formation of syncytia. (C) To determine infectivity, 5 x 105 MAGIC5A cells were infected with 10 ng of NL-Luc-envCT (WT) or NL-Luc-D36G (D36G), harboring the Luc gene in place of nef. After 48 h, cells were lysed and subjected to Luc assay. Averages from three independent experiments with standard deviations are indicated. RLU, relative light units.
|
A (common in pLAI and pL2), 22T
R (pLAI type), 22T
A (pL2), 36D
G (common in pLAI and pL2), and 91L
F (pL2) of gp41; the constructs were designated pNL-gp41-C21A, -T22R, -T22A, -D36G, and -L91F, respectively. As shown in Fig. 2B, only the D36G mutation, which is common between L2 and LAI, led to syncytium formation. No significant difference in the Env gp120 and gp41 protein expression was observed among all viruses tested here (data not shown). Importantly, this activity was correlated with enhancement of viral infectivity (
5.5-fold [Fig. 2C]). We therefore conclude that the single amino acid substitution 36D
G is sufficient for the altered syncytium formation activity. This was surprising since we originally sought to identify the determinants of L2-specific fusion activity. Instead, we found that 36G of gp41 is well conserved among nearly all HIV-1 isolates according to the HIV-1 sequence database and that NL4-3 is rather exceptional in that gp41 harbors 36D, as reported in the T-20 studies (24, 35, 40, 42). The implications of this result are considered in Discussion.
Effect of the 36G
D mutation in a primary-isolate-derived Env.
To further investigate whether these phenomena could be observed in a primary isolate, we utilized pNL-1549, encoding a primary-isolate-derived Env, in which amino acid position 36 of gp41 is glycine. We constructed the 36D version of this clone, termed pNL-1549-G36D. As shown in Fig. 3A, the mutant virus totally lost its syncytium-forming activity, while the WT virus displayed robust syncytium formation activity. Consistently, infectivity of the mutant virus showed an
3.5-fold reduction (Fig. 3B). We therefore conclude that the effects of amino acid substitution at position 36 on syncytium formation and viral infectivity are reproduced in the primary isolate.
![]() View larger version (48K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Effect of the amino acid change at position 36 in gp41 in a primary-isolate-derived Env. (A) A syncytium formation assay was performed with MOLT-4 cells inoculated with NL-1549 (1549-WT) viruses carrying a primary-isolate (QH1549)-derived Env or with NL-1549-G36D (1549-G36D) viruses harboring the amino acid change 36G D in 1549 gp41. Arrows indicate the formation of syncytia. (B) Infectivities of NL-Luc-1549 (1549-WT) and NL-Luc-1549-G36D (1549-G36D) viruses were measured by Luc assay as described for Fig. 2C. Averages from three independent experiments with standard deviations are indicated. RLU, relative light units.
|
5-fold more than WT Env, consistent with microscopic observation of the fusion activity shown in Fig. 2B. In the viral binding assay, MAGIC5A cells were incubated with WT Env- and D36G Env-encoding viruses at 4°C, which is a temperature permissive for virus binding but not internalization. After 3 h, unbound virions were removed by extensive washing, and cells were lysed and subjected to p24 ELISA. Background activity of the control virus (env defective), which showed
30% of the binding activity of WT Env, was subtracted from the activity obtained for WT and D36G Envs. As shown in Fig. 4B, WT and D36G mutant viruses displayed equivalent levels of viral binding ability. We therefore conclude that the effect of the D36G amino acid substitution on syncytium formation results from an enhancement in fusogenic activity and not from enhanced virus binding due to an altered interaction between gp41 and gp120.
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Comparisons of cell-cell fusion (A) and viral binding (B) between WT and D36G mutant Envs. (A) 293T cells as the effector cells were transfected with pNLn Bs (WT) or pNLn Bs-D36G (D36G) and Tat expression plasmids, while MAGIC5A cells as the target cells were transfected with pLTR-hLucP+. Forty-eight hours later, both cell types were washed, trypsinized, and cocultured. After 5 h, cells were lysed and subjected to Luc assay. Averages from three independent experiments with standard deviations are indicated. RLU, relative light units. (B) MAGIC5A cells (1.5 x 106) were incubated with medium containing 100 ng of NL- env, NL-envCT (WT), or NL-gp41-D36G (36G) viruses at 4°C. After 3 h, cells were extensively washed with ice-cold PBS three times and lysed with lysis buffer. Cell lysates were analyzed for p24 levels by ELISA. The background obtained with NL- env viruses was subtracted from sample values. Averages from three independent experiments with standard deviations are indicated.
|
![]() View larger version (51K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Molecular modeling of HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain trimer. The 3-D model of an HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain trimer was constructed by the homology modeling technique using the MOE. HIV-1 gp41 ectodomain trimers of D36G (upper left) and NL4-3 (upper right) are displayed. Target portions of each trimer around amino acid position 36 are shown with side chains of position 36 in the N-peptide region and related amino acids within the C-peptide region. Arrows indicate the side chains of N and C helices of D36G (lower left) and NL4-3 gp41 (lower right).
|
|
|
|---|
It is somewhat surprising that we could not determine any other key amino acid change which could display high fusion activity, since 36G of the gp41 ectodomain is conserved not only in pL2/pLAI but also in most other HIV-1 isolates (even in LAI/IIIB derivatives) and since one of the most widely used HIV-1 clones, pNL4-3, consisting of LAI/BRU at the 3'half, is rather exceptional, as first shown in the reports on T-20 (24, 35, 40, 42) (see below). Besides, one discrepancy remains in that although both L2 and LAI Envs harbor 36G in the ectodomain of gp41, L2 viruses are derived from the past virus stock of MT-4
MOLT-4-propagated strain LAI, which was not able to induce syncytium formation efficiently (32). It seems likely, however, that the majority of these polyclonal LAI preparations from MT-4/MOLT-4 cells might have carried 36D of gp41, which confers considerably less fusogenicity. We hypothesize that viruses carrying D36 in gp41 would take advantage of reduced fusogenic activity to lead to higher levels of viral propagation, since low-level cytopathic activity as a result of weak fusogenicity in D36 viruses might allow infected cells to survive longer than would G36 viruses. In terms of viral infectivity, D36 viruses should retain low but sufficient infectivity, as NL4-3 does. We therefore assume that D36 viruses might have dominated polyclonal LAI preparations from MT-4/MOLT-4 during the establishment of persistently infected cells. On the other hand, the reason why, despite the acquisition of high fusogenicity, L2-producing cells could survive after the in vitro acute phase of infection (20) might be that produced virions are replication defective because of the mutation in the protease gene and that the virus-producing cells have down-regulated CD4 from the cell surface, not allowing L2 virions to superinfect the cells.
The accuracy of the homology modeling is highly dependent on resolution of template structure for the modeling, as well as the degree of sequence similarity between the template and target proteins (2, 39). To obtain a high-quality gp41 ectodomain model, we used the 1QBZ structure, which was determined by X-ray crystallography analysis to have the best resolution (1.47 Å) and is the most accurate and complete structure of a retroviral gp41 ectodomain determined to date (48). Furthermore, 1QBZ has a sequence similarity of 52.5% to the target NL4-3 gp41 ectodomain, which is high enough to construct high-accuracy models with RMSDs of
1 Å for the main chain between predicted and actual structures (2). Therefore, the gp41 ectodomain models presented here are likely to be highly accurate, predicting the six-helix bundle structure of each strain with an RSMD of
1 Å for the main chain.
The comparison of the six-helix bundle models of NL4-3 and the D36G mutant revealed notable structural differences around amino acid position 36, which potentially the affect ability of the ectodomain to induce conformational change (Fig. 5). The models suggest that the NL4-3 ectodomain can be more refractory to the conformational changes than the D36G mutant ectodomain, because of more efficient steric clash and coulomb interaction between the N and C helix side chains (Fig. 5). This prediction is consistent with the experimental data indicating that the NL4-3 gp41 is less fusogenic than the gp41 with the D36G substitution (Fig. 1 to 4). Together, our data suggest that the amino acid at position 36 in the N helix is a critical regulator for the structural changes of the ectodomain.
Figure 6 shows a model of HIV-1 membrane fusion and the difference in fusion efficiency between 36D and 36G Envs. Binding of gp120 to CD4 and a chemokine receptor (not shown) leads to a conformational change in gp120 that alters the interactions of gp120 with gp41. This allows the gp41 fusion peptide to be exposed and to insert into the target cell membrane (Fig. 6, upper left) and allows the N-peptide region to form an exposed trimeric coiled coil and the C-peptide region to be exposed as well (prehairpin intermediate shown in Fig. 6, upper middle and right). This intermediate is relatively long-lived and is vulnerable to C-peptide inhibitors such as T-20. When the C-peptide region is brought into close proximity to the N-peptide coiled coil and adopts a helical conformation, the prehairpin intermediate resolves to the fusion-active hairpin structure, which is a coiled coil composed of internal triple-stranded N-peptide helices paired with antiparallel outer C-peptide helices packed along hydrophobic grooves, forming a six-helix bundle. This rearrangement results in membrane apposition (Fig. 6, lower left). As shown in the lower right panel of Fig. 6, while the D36G mutant, which can be considered a consensus gp41, undergoes the normal six-helix bundle formation, NL4-3 carrying 36D in gp41 faces physical impediments to this formation since the protrusion of the negatively charged 36D residue in the N helix toward the C helix would induce a steric clash between the N and C helices, a salt bridge with 36D and K144 in the C helix, and an extended distance between the main-chain backbones of the N and C helices.
![]() View larger version (40K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. A model of the HIV-1 Env-mediated fusion mechanism and a putative difference in hairpin formation between D36G and NL4-3 Envs. This model is adapted from that of Koshiba and Chan (22). Binding of gp120 to CD4 and a coreceptor (not shown) induces a conformational change in gp120 that allows exposure of gp41 fusion peptide (red) and its penetration into the target cellular membrane and allows the formation of the prehairpin intermediate (upper panel). As shown in the lower left panel, hairpin (six-helix bundle) formation occurs between trimeric N-peptide (gray) and C-peptide (blue) regions. Enlargements of putative six-helix bundles of D36G and NL4-3 gp41 ectodomains are displayed in the lower right panel.
|
Considerable work on gp41 through mutagenesis studies and escape variants arising from T-20 selective pressure with the alterations in virus replication kinetics has indicated that other positions of gp41 also regulate the fusogenicity. Among gp41 mutants reported so far, many of the gp41 mutations leading to reduced fusion activity are located within or in the proximity of the "deep pocket" (6), such as L54, L55, L57, V59, W60, G61, I62, W117, W120, and I124 (4, 9, 11, 14, 25, 34, 41, 44). Since the mutations of these conserved residues required for the six-helix bundle formation abolish viral replication (29), this pocket could be a good target for T-1249, the second fusion inhibitor, whose binding region extends into the deep pocket (13). The W85M mutation, located in the side of disulfide-bonded loop, confers impaired fusogenicity but wild-type infectivity (4). Among several mutations which have been reported to impair the fusogenicity and are located in the T-20 target region, such as I37, Q40, L45, and I48 (4, 8, 14, 25), naturally occurring mutations in the presence of T-20 are found in I37 and L45 in addition to G36 (whose phenotype was first described in this study). Fusion phenotypes of other mutants seen in T-20 resistance in vivo and in vitro (Q32, V38, and Q39) are undetermined (27, 28, 35, 42).
In conclusion, our data indicate that amino acid 36 in the gp41 ectodomain, which is conserved in nearly all HIV-1 isolates except for NL4-3 and T-20 escape viruses, controls the fusogenic activity and that structural impediment in the gp41 ectodomain of NL4-3 and T-20 escape viruses may lead to the inefficient membrane fusion. Further studies will be required to fully understand the mechanism by which viruses acquire resistance to the T-20 fusion inhibitor.
This work was supported in part by a grant from the Ministry of Education, Science, Technology, Sports and Culture of Japan and by a grant from the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare of Japan.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»