Journal of Virology, November 2004, p. 11988-12011, Vol. 78, No. 21
0022-538X/04/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.78.21.11988-12011.2004
Copyright © 2004, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Global Analysis of Host Cell Gene Expression Late during Cytomegalovirus Infection Reveals Extensive Dysregulation of Cell Cycle Gene Expression and Induction of Pseudomitosis Independent of US28 Function
Laura Hertel and
Edward S. Mocarski*
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California
Received 26 March 2004/
Accepted 24 May 2004
 |
ABSTRACT
|
|---|
Replication
of human cytomegalovirus (CMV) depends on host cell gene products
working in conjunction with viral functions and leads to a dramatic
dysregulation of cell cycle gene expression. Comprehensive
transcriptional profiling was used to identify pathways most
dramatically modulated by CMV at late times during infection and to
determine the extent to which expression of the viral chemokine
receptor US28 contributed to modulating cellular gene expression. Cells
infected with the AD169 strain of virus or a fully replication
competent US28-deficient derivative (RV101) were profiled throughout
the late phase of infection (50, 72, and 98 h postinfection).
Although sensitive statistical analysis showed striking global changes
in transcript levels in infected cells compared to uninfected cells,
the expression of US28 did not contribute to these alterations. CMV
infection resulted in lower levels of transcripts encoding
cytoskeletal, extracellular matrix, and adhesion proteins, together
with small GTPases and apoptosis regulators, and in higher
levels of transcripts encoding cell cycle, DNA replication, energy
production, and inflammation-related gene products. Surprisingly, a
large number of cellular transcripts encoding mitosis-related proteins
were upmodulated at late times in infection, and these were associated
with the formation of abnormal mitotic spindles and the appearance of
pseudomitotic cells. These data extend our understanding of how broadly
CMV alters the regulation of host cell cycle gene products and
highlight the establishment of a mitosis-like environment in the
absence of cellular DNA replication as important for viral replication
and
maturation.
 |
INTRODUCTION
|
|---|
Human cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection has a dramatic impact on the cell
that starts immediately after infection
(4) and continues through
late times (34,
67). The replication
cycle follows a temporal cascade of events that depends upon both viral
and host cell functions. Viral DNA replication begins between 14 and
24 h postinfection (hpi), and release of progeny starts
between 36 and 48 hpi, reaching maximal levels between 72 and 96 hpi
(67). This process causes
profound changes in host cell shape, metabolism, and gene
transcription, components of which are suspected to be critical for
efficient replication. Previous studies in primary fibroblasts have
revealed the global impact of viral infection on signaling and
transcriptional changes that start as early as 15 min and last as long
as 48 hpi (4,
16,
50,
51,
85,
112,
113). These studies have
largely focused on the immediate impact of the virus on cells and have
revealed a dramatic upmodulation of cellular inflammatory and immune
gene expression due to virus binding and penetration. Based on this
work, selected cellular signaling events
(51,
103) and cellular
proteins (13,
89,
114) have been
implicated as important regulators of infection. There has been a less
concerted effort to understand the global impact of CMV infection at
late times during infection
(16), despite the fact
that maximal modulation would be expected at late times. Also,
remarkably little information has been presented on the contribution of
virus-encoded signaling proteins that are expressed at late times, such
as the CMV chemokine receptor US28.
CMV encodes at least four
apparent seven transmembrane-spanning proteins
(21,
42), pUL33, pUL78, pUS27,
and pUS28, one of which (pUS28) is a G-protein-coupled receptor that
binds a wide range of CC chemokines
(9,
38,
56,
72,
100), as well as
fractalkine/CX3CL1
(55). pUS28-mediated
signaling is both chemokine ligand dependent
(38) and constitutive
(19,
101) and stimulates
mitogen-activated protein kinase extracellular-signal-regulated kinase
2, focal adhesion kinase 1, and Src
(9,
19,
91,
101). pUS28-mediated
signaling occurs in CMV-infected cells
(9,
98), as well as in
US28-transfected cells. US28 transcripts are readily detected by 24 hpi
and continue to rise through late times when pUS28 scavenges chemokines
from the infected cell culture fluid
(12,
98). Although many of the
US28 mutant viruses exhibit modest replication defects, US28 itself is
completely dispensable for replication in cultured fibroblasts
(12,
98), as shown through
studies on one viral mutant in particular, RV101
(12). The phenotypic
consequences of signaling through this receptor during infection in
fibroblasts have not been investigated.
CMV infection of resting
primary fibroblasts dysregulates expression of several genes encoding
cell cycle regulators
(34), such as the
G2/M cyclin B
(26); cell cycle
checkpoint proteins, such as p53 and pRb
(49); and DNA replication
effectors, including components and regulators of the prereplication
complex (10,
107).Through the induction of these changes, CMV has long appeared to
stimulate the generation of an intracellular environment similar to S
phase based initially on cellular activation
(4) while simultaneously
inhibiting cellular DNA synthesis in a manner analogous to a
G1/S block
(34,
67). The execution of
these strategies presumably allows the virus to maximize the
availability of cellular functions required for successful replication
of the viral genome, to eliminate the competition from the cellular
genome, and to avoid the onset of apoptosis.
We used cDNA
microarrays to evaluate the impact of CMV infection, as well as the
contribution of US28 expression, on cellular gene transcription in
fibroblasts at late times postinfection. We used a
replication-competent US28 mutant virus, RV101
(12), to avoid
contributions from adventitious mutations that are a common occurrence
in CMV mutants (67). The
levels of a large number of transcripts encoding functions involved in
a wide range of cellular pathways were altered by infection, but none
of these changes could be ascribed to US28 expression. The most
remarkable findings revealed a substantial increase in the expression
levels of mitochondrial genes, a considerable alteration in expression
levels of multiple GTPase family members, and an intense
dysregulation of cell cycle pathways that normally control mitosis.
These latter changes were linked to the appearance of pathological
mitosis in culture and were likely part of a virus-induced strategy to
enhance viral genome replication and virion maturation.
(These
results were presented at the 9th International Cytomegalovirus
Workshop and the First International Betaherpesvirus Workshop in
Maastricht, The Netherlands, on 20 to 25 May
2003.)
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS
|
|---|
Cells, viruses, and microarrays.
Primary human
foreskin fibroblasts (HFs) were cultured as described previously
(23) and used between
passage 15 and 17 postisolation. The human CMV strain AD169 obtained
from the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) has been denoted
AD169varATCC (AD) to distinguish it from other variants of
this strain in current use
(41,
87). The US27/US28
deletion mutant virus RV101 (RV) was made by using
AD169varATCC by T. R. Jones (Wyeth-Ayerst Research,
Pearl River, N.Y.) and exhibits growth characteristics
indistinguishable from parental virus
(12) that we
independently confirmed for the present study (data not shown).
Microarrays were purchased from the Stanford Functional Genomics
Facility
(http://www.microarray.org/sfgf/jsp/home.jsp).
About 85% of the spots printed on the polylysine-coated glass
microscope slides were from the I.M.A.G.E. consortium clones from the
Research Genetics Sequence Verified clone set, 10% were from the
Cancer Genome Anatomy Project clone set
(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ncicgap),
and 5% were from a set of Methanococcus jannaschii
controls. The batch of arrays (SHDB) used in the present study
contained 41,792 total spots (39,781 unique and 2,011 repeated spots)
representing 29,593 unique genes. After purchase, the microarrays were
postprocessed as described previously
(http://derisilab.ucsf.edu/).
Cell infections.
CMV was
propagated at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 0.01 in confluent
HFs and purified as described previously
(23). For microarray
analysis, HF monolayers plated at a density of 3 x
104 cells/cm2 in 850-cm2 roller
bottles were infected at confluency (day 5 postseeding) with purified
virions (23) at an MOI of
10. After virus adsorption for 1 h at 37°C in
5% CO2, the inoculum was removed, and the cells were
washed twice with culture medium prior to the addition of fresh medium.
At 50, 72, and 98 hpi, infected monolayers were harvested, snap-frozen,
and stored at 80°C until the time course was
completed. Uninfected confluent HF cultures were used as a reference.
For all other analyses described here, HF monolayers were plated at a
density of 5 x 104 cells/cm2 on
coverslips in 24-well plates 3 days before infection with purified AD
virions at an MOI of 10. After virus adsorption for 1 h,
cells were washed twice prior to the addition of fresh medium. For drug
treatment, medium plus 300 µg of phosphonoformic acid (PFA;
Sigma, St. Louis, Mo.)/ml or medium plus 1 mM or 10 mM hydroxyurea (HU;
Sigma) was added to the washed cells. Virus titers in the supernatant
of wells treated with each of the drugs were determined by plaque assay
and were consistent with previous reports
(6,
99).
RNA isolation and microarray hybridization.
mRNA was extracted by using the
FastTrack 2.0 mRNA Isolation Kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, Calif.). Only
RNA preparations reaching optical density at 260/280 nm
(OD260/280) ratio values of
2.0 were used. Labeled
cDNA populations were synthesized from 2 µg of mRNA per sample
by reverse transcription and simultaneous incorporation of Cy3-dUTP
(reference sample, green) or Cy5-dUTP (infected samples, red) (Amersham
Biosciences, Piscataway, N.J.) with an oligo-dT20 primer and
the Superscript II Reverse Transcriptase (Invitrogen). Reference and
sample cDNA populations were mixed, and unincorporated nucleotides were
removed by using a CyScribe GFX purification kit (Amersham
Biosciences). Then, 5 µg of human Cot-1 DNA (Invitrogen), 20
µg of poly(A) RNA (Sigma), 20 µg of yeast tRNA
(Invitrogen), 3.4x SSC (1x SSC is 0.15 M NaCl plus
0.015 M sodium citrate), and 0.3% sodium dodecyl sulfate were
added to the probe prior to denaturation by heating at 100°C
for 2 min and application on the arrays. Hybridization of two arrays
per virus per time point (total of 12 arrays) were performed at
65°C for 16 to 18 h in a custom slide chamber with
humidity maintained by a small reservoir of 3x SSC. The arrays
were then washed as described previously
(29) and scanned with a
Gene Pix 4000A Scanner (Axon Instruments, Foster City,
Calif.).
Microarray data analysis.
Array images were
analyzed with the Gene Pix Pro 4.0 software and unreliable spots
identified by visual inspection were marked with a
"flag." After submission to the Stanford Microarray
Database (SMD;
http://genome-www.stanford.edu/microarray/),
infected/uninfected ratio values were log2 transformed,
normalized by using the default normalization protocol of the SMD, and
retrieved by spot number (so that no averaging of the ratio values from
duplicate spots was performed). To eliminate spots of poor quality from
subsequent analyses, spot data were filtered by applying three
criteria: no flag, brightness (channel 1 [Cy-3] net mean and
channel 2 [Cy-5] normalized net mean intensities) of
150 fluorescence units, and even distribution of color
brightness across the whole spot area (regression correlation values of
0.6). Statistical analysis was performed by applying the one-
or two-class (unpaired) response type of Significance Analysis of
Microarrays (SAM), version 1.20
(http://www-stat.stanford.edu/
tibs/SAM/)
(96), to three sets of
four arrays each (at 50, 72, or 98 hpi) or one set of 10 arrays (50,
72, and 98 [50-72-98] hpi). The number of
permutations was set to 24 (4-array sets) or to 300 (10-array set), and
the random number seed was set to 94332998 (one class) or to 91797601
(two classes, unpaired). The lists of SAM significant spots generated
by the one-class analysis of the 50-, 72-, and 98-hpi array sets were
intersected with the list generated from the 50-72-98-hpi array set by
using the I.M.A.G.E. number as spot identifier. The identity of SAM
significant spots was obtained through the SOURCE database
(http://source.stanford.edu;
time of the analysis, April 2003)
(25), and gene grouping
in functional categories was performed according to information
retrieved from Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) and Medline
databases. Genes belonging to the same cellular subcompartments or
functional pathways were assigned to a specific class within each
category. This classification process brought genes having similar
roles into close proximity within each category's Excel
spreadsheet (see information file S6 in the supplemental material),
allowing us to immediately appreciate if they were part of extensive
cellular pathways. Functional maps were generated by either modifying
existing maps on the Gene Microarray Pathway Profiler
(GenMAPP) website
(http://www.genmapp.org/)
or by creating new maps by using GenMAPP software
(24) in combination with
the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes database (KEGG,
http://www.genome.ad.jp/kegg/)
and literature searches. Microarray images and raw data are available
on the SMD website, SAM analysis Excel files and functional grouping
Excel files are included as six information files in the supplemental
material.
Immunofluorescence analysis.
For
tubulin 1 (
tub1) and immediate-early protein 1 and 2 (IE1/IE2)
double staining, cells were fixed in cold methanol for 5 min at
20°C, permeabilized with 0.1% Triton X-100 in
phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) for 20 min on ice, incubated in
blocking buffer (1% fetal calf serum in PBS) for 10 min at room
temperature, and stained with an anti-
tub1 monoclonal antibody
(MAb; 1:10,000; clone GTU-88, Sigma), followed by a Texas
red-conjugated goat anti-mouse antibody (1:100; Vector Laboratories,
San Bruno, Calif.). After three washes with PBS, cells were incubated
with normal mouse immunoglobulin G (1:10; Caltag, Burlingame, Calif.)
for 30 min at room temperature before being stained with a fluorescein
isothiocyanate (FITC)-conjugated anti-IE1/IE2 antibody (1:800; MAB810F;
Chemicon, Temecula, Calif.). Cellular DNA was highlighted with Hoechst
44432 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, Oreg.). For ppUL44, pp150, and pUL43
staining, infected cells were fixed with 1% paraformaldehyde in
PBS for 15 min at room temperature, permeabilized, and blocked as
described above and then stained with MAbs to ppUL44 (1:500; Goodwin
Institute, Plantation, Fla.), pp150 (MAb 36-14), or pUL43 (MAb 20392),
followed by an FITC-conjugated goat anti-mouse antibody (1:100; Vector
Laboratories). Cellular DNA was highlighted with propidium iodide
(Molecular Probes). For
tub1 and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)
double staining, cells were labeled with 50 µM BrdU (Sigma) for
1 h at 37°C with 5% CO2, washed
with PBS, fixed with 1% paraformaldehyde for 30 min at room
temperature, and incubated with 2 M HCl for 1 h at
37°C. Cells were then washed twice with borate buffer (pH 8.5)
and three times with PBS, permeabilized, blocked, and stained with
anti-
tub1 and Texas red anti-mouse antibodies as before. After
being washed, the cells were labeled with a FITC-conjugated anti-BrdU
antibody (1:100; Molecular Probes) for 1 h at room
temperature. Coverslips were mounted with FluoroGuard Antifade Reagent
(Bio-Rad, Hercules, Calif.) before being analyzed on an Olympus BX60
epifluorescence microscope equipped with x60 or x100
phase-contrast objective lenses. Images were collected with a Hamamatsu
ORCA-100 digital camera and Image Pro Plus 4.0 software
(MediaCybernetics, Silver Spring, Md.). Digitized images were stored,
electronically colorized, and overlaid for evaluation of two- and
three-color experiments.
Transmission electron microscopy.
Cells
were fixed in 2% glutaraldehyde in PBS, postfixed with 1%
osmium tetroxide for 1 h, blocked with 1% aqueous
uranyl acetate, dehydrated through graded ethanol steps, and embedded
in Poly/Bed (Polysciences). Thin sections (70 nm) were then prepared,
stained with 1% uranyl acetate and 1% lead citrate, and
viewed on a Phillips CM12 microscope.
 |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
|
|---|
Trends in cellular gene expression at late times during CMV infection and impact of viral chemokine receptor expression.
To identify cellular genes modulated by
CMV at late times postinfection, we compared the transcriptional
profiles of HFs infected with either wild-type CMV strain
AD169varATCC (AD) or RV101 (RV), a mutant virus derived from
AD169varATCC exhibiting full replication potential
despite the complete absence of US27 and US28 expression
(12). We used this
particular mutant to avoid potential contribution of
adventitious mutations that appear to be carried in US28
mutants that exhibit growth defects. Transcriptional
profiling was performed according to the scheme outlined in Fig.
1A. Cy5-labeled cDNAs from HFs infected with either AD or RV for 50, 72, or
98 h were combined with Cy3-labeled cDNA from confluent
uninfected HFs used as a reference
(29) and hybridized to 12
replicate 42,000 spot human cDNA arrays. After normalization of the
spot ratio values, usable data were selected according to an
established set of filtering criteria
(84). The percentage of
qualified spots identified on each array ranged from 44 to 83%,
with a mean of 65% ± 11% (Table
1). The data from replicate arrays were organized into four groups to
facilitate analysis, three with the 4 arrays at 50, 72, or
98 hpi and one with the 12 arrays from the combined time points
(50-72-98 hpi). Each group contained a common set of spots that passed
filtering criteria on all arrays contained in that group. These sets
consisted of 20,123 spots from the 50-hpi time point (48% of
total spots), 14,856 (35%) spots from the 72-hpi time point,
21,940 (52%) spots from the 98 hpi-time point, and 11,942
(29%) spots from the combined 50-72-98-hpi time points. In order
to maximize the usable data in the analysis, two arrays containing
<50% qualified spots (AD 72 hpi 1 and RV 72 hpi 1) were
excluded from the combined time point group. In this way, 10 replicates
composed the 50-72-98-hpi group, and this group had 14,126 (34%
of total spots) qualified spots.

View larger version (37K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIG. 1. (A)
Flow chart of microarray data generation and analysis. Cy5-labeled cDNA
from infected HFs and Cy3-labeled cDNA from uninfected HFs were mixed
and hybridized to replicate 42,000 spot human cDNA arrays to generate
data that was normalized and filtered by the SMD and subjected to
statistical analysis by SAM software. (B) SAM one-class
analysis (left) and SAM two-class (unpaired) analysis (right) of the
14,126 data set from the combined 50-72-98-hpi time points. For each
spot, the observed SAM score is plotted against the expected SAM score.
The middle line intersecting the origin in each graph represents
observed equals expected score values, whereas the additional lines
define the upper and lower significance threshold specified by the
lowest allowed FDR parameter
(96). Significantly
regulated spots are shaded gray. Gray spots in the upper right quadrant
are upmodulated, and gray spots in the lower left panel are
downmodulated. (C) Functional categories (right column)
represented in the 1,983 SAM-significant upmodulated (white bars) and
3,675 SAM-significant downmodulated (gray bars) spots from the
50-72-98-hpi data set. The series of bars indicates the distribution of
total spots (All spots), unnamed (All unknown spots), and named (All
known genes), as well as the distribution of the named genes into
functional groups based on their principle role according to the
literature. Functional groups include soluble factors and cell surface
receptors (Factors Receptor), cytoskeleton-extracellular
matrix-adhesion (Cytosk-ECM-Adh), nucleic acid metabolism (Nucl Acid
metab), protein metabolism (Protein metab), vesicles and intracellular
transport (Vesicles transport), enzymes (Enzyme), transcription factors
(Transcr factor), intracellular signaling (Signaling), cell cycle (Cell
cycle), other (Other), GTPases (GTPase), lipid
metabolism (Lipid metab), immune system (Imm system), and apoptosis
(Apoptosis). The categories are ranked according to the
total number of spots or genes in each (left
column).
|
|
To identify genes significantly
regulated at late times of CMV infection, we applied SAM one-class
analysis to the set of array replicas spanning a 50- to 98-hpi time
course. This statistical procedure evaluates the consistency and
certainty of gene expression patterns and has eclipsed simple
fold-cutoff methods of analysis because it offers an assessment of
significance of microarray data
(96). Initially, SAM
analysis was used to evaluate the combined 50-72-98-hpi set of 14,126
spots with the aim of identifying genes that were consistently
modulated throughout late times of infection. Figure
1B (left) shows the plot
generated by this analysis. Each datum point in this graph represented
a comparison of the observed relative difference value (actual data)
plotted against the chance relative difference value (denoted as
"expected" in the figure and calculated by permuting
the data) for each spot in the set. The distribution of the data along
a sigmoidal curve revealed that the observed differences in the
expression levels of a large number of genes greatly exceeded the
differences expected by chance, with transcript levels showing the
strong impact of viral infection on host cells. We selected a
conservative false discovery rate (FDR) value of 0.0045 for the
combined 50-72-98-hpi data, which was the maximum stringency allowed
and indicated that >99.996% of the differences we
detected were authentic (see information file S1, FDR and delta
values). A total of 5,658 of 14,126 spots, >40% of the
data set, were altered at late times, with 1,983 (14%)
upmodulated and 3,675 (26%) downmodulated by viral infection
(see information file S1, significant spots, in the supplemental
material). This dramatic impact of virus infection was also observed
when individual time points were analyzed, showing that a wide range of
cellular genes were altered by CMV infection at late times during
infection no matter how the analysis was completed. The FDR value for
each set of arrays was always set to the most conservative value
available for the size of the data set, 0.03 for 50-hpi data, 0.01 for
72-hpi data, and 0.01 for 98-hpi data (see information files S2, S3,
and S4, FDR and delta values). This approach yielded a
>99.97% likelihood that 1,595 spots across the four
50-hpi arrays, 3,177 spots across the four 72-hpi arrays, and 3,596
spots across the four 98-hpi arrays represented authentic changes based
on maximally stringent analysis (see information files S2, S3 and S4,
significant spots, in the supplemental material). Due to fewer
replicates, the number of spots significantly altered by viral
infection corresponded to 8, 21, and 16% of the qualified spots
within the 50-, 72-, and 98-hpi data sets, respectively. More than
75% of the SAM-significant spots at any of the three late time
points were contained in the combined 50-72-98-hpi set and thus
exhibited similar levels of transcriptional change (increase or
decrease) across all time points. Few SAM-significant spots (1%
at 50 hpi, 3% at 72, and 3% at 98 hpi) showed altered
levels at only one time point, due mostly to poor spot quality at other
time points. Taken together, these statistical analyses all indicated
that large numbers of cellular genes were significantly modulated by
CMV infection over the period from 50 to 98 hpi.
Expression
levels of US28, a signaling G-protein-coupled receptor, have been shown
to be elevated at late times of infection
(12). To evaluate the
contribution of US28 signaling to the host cell response during the
time of maximal expression, we compared the transcriptional profiles of
AD and RV virus-infected cells by using SAM two-class (unpaired)
analysis. Given the consistency of changes at all late time points in
the combined data set, this method was initially applied to the 14,126
spot data set, comparing the results of the five replicate AD virus-
and five replicate RV virus-infected cell arrays where
>50% of spots were qualified. Figure
1B (right) shows the plot
generated by this analysis. The distribution of the data fell along a
line representing observed equals expected score values, with few
deviations. This analysis showed that genes were not expressed
differently in AD and RV virus-infected cells. No FDR values of
<43 were available for this analysis, indicating that even
spots appearing slightly outside the significance threshold had a
relatively high (43%) likelihood of being false (see information
file S5, FDR and delta values, in the supplemental material). Thus, we
concluded that these spots were unlikely to represent true positives
and that cellular gene expression was not perceptively influenced by
US27 or US28. A comparison of the transcriptional profiles generated by
each virus at each time point, conducted by using two arrays per virus
per time point, also failed to reveal any differences (data not shown).
It is important to consider that the viruses we compared exhibited
equivalent replication in HFs
(12) and that previous
studies (12,
90,
98) have used some US28
mutant viruses that exhibit a variety of growth defects that appear to
be unrelated to the disruption of the US28 gene and US28
signaling (12).
Growth defects may have been more important than US28 expression in
some of the reported differences ascribed to US28. No matter how our
data were analyzed, either with replicates from each time point or
total combined AD and RV virus-infected cell arrays, a US28 mutant
virus that retained normal growth properties did not impact the
cellular transcriptional profile any differently than control
virus.
Functional analysis of cellular gene expression at late times of infection.
Genes whose expression was
altered by viral infection in the combined 50-72-98-hpi data set
relative to uninfected HFs were categorized according to
functional activity, cellular localization site, or metabolic pathway.
According to the SOURCE database
(http://source.stanford.edu;
see Materials and Methods), 3,210 spots were found to represent 2,227
functionally characterized genes (983 spots were represented more than
once on each array), with 2,448 spots representing either expressed
sequence tags (ESTs) or genes that had not been annotated. Based on
known properties listed in SOURCE, as well as in literature searches,
each gene was assigned into one functional category shown in Fig.
1C (see information file
S6 in the supplemental material). The five categories with the greatest
numbers of genes, soluble factors and cell surface receptors
(14%), cytoskeleton-extracellular matrix-adhesion (13%),
nucleic acid metabolism (10%), protein metabolism (10%),
and vesicle and intracellular transport (9.6%) accounted for
more than half of the genes whose expression was altered by infection.
Of the 2,227 functionally characterized genes, a smaller percentage
(927; 42%) was upmodulated, and a greater percentage
(1,300; 58%) was downmodulated. Genes belonging to most of the
functional categories showed similar distributions; however, the
cytoskeleton-extracellular matrix-adhesion, vesicles and intracellular
transport, GTPase, and apoptosis categories contained even greater
percentages (
68%) of downmodulated genes, and the
nucleic acid metabolism, enzyme, cell cycle, and immune system
categories contained greater percentages of upmodulated genes (Fig.
1C). Our finding that
2,448 ESTs and 2,227 named genes out of a survey of ca. 14,000 host
genes were modulated by CMV infection contrasts with a previous
published analysis (16).
Although past work focused on early times of infection comparing
infectious virus and UV-inactivated virus particles, a dramatic drop in
numbers of modulated genes from 900 to 650 was reported to occur
between 24 and 48 hpi. Our preliminary analysis had revealed no such
drop (S. Watanabe, M. B. Eisen, P. O. Brown, and
E. S. Mocarski, Abstr. 24th International Herpesvirus
Workshop, Cambridge, abstr. 15.019, 1999). Comparison of previously
published 48 hpi data
(16) with the analysis
reported here is difficult due to differences in the application of
statistical analysis.
Relationships between the genes in a
category were queried by using OMIM and literature searches. Genes
within the same category showing similar transcriptional changes were
often found to encode proteins that were functionally related and could
be organized into classes within each category (see information file
S6, column class). Certain categories (cytoskeleton-extracellular
matrix-adhesion, GTPase, enzyme, cell cycle, and nucleic acid
metabolism) contained a large proportion of genes in functional
relationships that were diagrammed by using GenMAPP software in
combination with the KEGG database. Although most of the maps were
assembled by using the SAM-significant genes from the combined
50-72-98-hpi set, we added several SAM-significant genes from single
time points when they were excluded from the combined set because spots
representing the gene did not qualify at other time points. We found
that the pathways emerging from these analyses were more valuable than
a list of genes to illustrate the impact of the virus on the host cell
transcriptome during the late phase of infection. Gene maps are shown
in Fig. 2 to
5. Being
microarray-derived, all changes described in the present study refer
exclusively to transcript levels. In addition to transcriptional
changes, other cellular mechanisms affecting translation,
posttranslational modifications, protein stability, and activity affect
the amount and functionality of the products of the genes displayed on
the maps.

View larger version (35K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIG. 2. GenMAPP
of virus-induced gene expression changes affecting integrin subunits,
integrin-to-actin signaling pathways, and actin cytoskeleton. This map
was generated by using the "integrin-mediated cell
adhesion" KEGG pathway as a template. Genes (abbreviated names
based on SwissProt accession number) are shown in boxes (see Materials
and Methods for website and other information files). The map also
includes two genes from the signaling category (the
phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase subunits p110 [PI3K p110] and
p55 [PI3K p55]) and eight genes from the GTPase
category (rhoA, rac1, cdc42, rho-associated coiled-coil containing
protein kinase 1 [ROCK1], LIM motif-containing protein kinase
1 [LIMK1], and p21-activated kinases 2 [PAK 2], 3
[PAK 3], and 6 [PAK 6]). Genes represented by more
than one spot in the SAM-generated list are shown in a dashed
box. Genes consistently upmodulated are bright orange, genes
consistently downmodulated are green, genes not found in any of the
data sets are uncolored, and one gene, which scored as SAM
significantly upmodulated at one time (integrin ß4 was
upmodulated in the 98 hpi data set), is light orange. The mean fold
change (calculated by SAM) is noted to the right of each box, with
positive values indicating upmodulation and negative values indicating
downmodulation. The two dashed parallel lines indicate the plasma
membrane. Solid arrows denote proximal events, and dashed arrows denote
distal processes in the pathways shown. MLC, myosin light
chain.
|
|

View larger version (62K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIG. 5. GenMAPP
of virus-induced gene expression changes affecting cell cycle and DNA
synthesis. (A) Cell cycle phases G1, S,
G2, and M are depicted by blue arrows, with genes modulated
by infection listed underneath. (B) DNA synthesis functions
in the prereplication complex (left) and replication fork machinery
(right) regulated by infection. The same scheme as shown in Fig.
2 is used with the
addition of inhibitory relationships denoted by a . Ink 4 a/c
contains ink a, b, and c; HDAC 2/10 contains the histone deacetylases
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7A, 8, 9, and 10; E2F 2/6 contains E2F 2, 3, 4, 5,
and 6; and Apc 1/11 contains apc 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, and
11.
|
|
Cytoskeleton-, extracellular matrix-, and adhesion-related genes.
Expression of
cytoskeleton-extracellular matrix-adhesion transcripts showed the
greatest level of downmodulation of any category (Fig.
1 and Table
2). The 299 genes in this category
were assigned to four classes, with 110 genes (37%) encoding
major cytoskeletal fibers, 96 genes (32%) encoding extracellular
matrix components, 79 genes (26%) encoding cell adhesion
molecules, and 14 genes (5%) encoding miscellaneous
cytoskeletal gene products. A very high proportion (84%) of
transcripts encoding extracellular matrix-related gene products,
including 30 encoding collagens and collagen-altering enzymes, 20
encoding extracellular matrix-modifying enzymes, and 11 encoding matrix
metalloproteinases (MMP) or associated regulators, were consistently
downmodulated by viral infection, with seven types of collagens,
fibronectin 1, laminin
4 and
1, MMP2, MMP3, and two
tissue inhibitors of metalloproteinases (TIMP2 and 3) among the
transcripts reduced >10-fold (Table
2). Three-quarters of the
genes encoding cell adhesion molecules, including 28 mediators of
cell-cell and cell-matrix adhesion, 14 integrin subunits, and 15
components of various kinds of junctions, were suppressed by infection,
with two thrombospondins (THBS1 and -2), integrin ß1, and
integrin
2 among the transcripts reduced >5-fold
(Table 2). Two-thirds of
the genes in the major cytoskeletal fiber class, including 64
microfilament-related genes, 35 microtubule-related genes, and 11
intermediate filament-related genes, were also markedly reduced during
infection, with transgelin, caldesmon 1, vimentin,
and two tropomyosins (TPM2 and -4) among the transcripts reduced
>5-fold (Table
2).
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 2. Statistically
significant cytoskeleton-, extracellular matrix-, and adhesion-related
genes consistently upmodulated (positive fold change) or
downmodulated (negative fold change) across late times of infection
|
|
Forty-one genes
from this category were assembled in a gene map that depicts the
downmodulation of signaling pathways linking integrins to the actin
cytoskeleton by viral infection (Fig.
2). Expression levels of 6 of 18 (33%) known integrin
subunits (
1,
2,
3,
4,
E,
and
V) and of 4 of 8 (50%) known integrin ß
subunits (ß1, ß4, ß5, and ß8) were
altered by infection: eight subunits were consistently downmodulated,
whereas two (
E and ß4) were upmodulated. These data
revealed a major negative impact of infection on mediators of
cell-extracellular matrix attachment, a finding consistent with the
virus-induced decline in the substrate adhesion properties of the
infected cell (3,
104). In agreement with
this notion, several genes encoding integrin-binding partners, such as
fibronectin, laminins, and collagens, as well as genes encoding the
major focal adhesion-localized proteins vinculin,
-actinin 4,
talin 1, and paxillin, were strongly downmodulated. In addition, three
main members of the rho family of GTPases that control the
formation of stress fibers and focal adhesions (rhoA), lamellipodia
(rac1), and filopodia (cdc42), together with eight mediator proteins
linking these GTPases to the actin modifying proteins (PAK2
and PAK3, ROCK1, LIMK1, phosphatidylinositol-4-phosphate 5-kinase
[PI(4)P5K], WASP family verprolin-homologous protein 2
[WAVE2], and myosin light chain phosphatase [MYPT]
regulatory subunits 1 and 2), were also downmodulated. Thus, expression
of a broad range of integrin-to-actin bridging gene products appeared
to be negatively impacted by infection, a finding consistent with a
broad disruption of integrin binding and signaling responses during
infection. Most actin modifiers, which are the targets of integrin
signaling, including filamin A and C, gelsolin, transgelin, moesin, the
capping protein muscle Z line
1 (capZ
1), four of the
six subunits composing the actin-related protein 2/3 complex (arp1A,
-1B, -4, and -5), and the assembler of the spectrin-actin lattice,
adducin 3, were consistently downmodulated, together with the
regulatory type of myosin light chain (i.e., MLC2) controlling the
assembly of actin-myosin filaments, two calponin 1 homologs (calponins
2 and 3), and four actomyosin regulatory proteins (tropomyosins 2 and
4, tropomodulin 3, and caldesmon). Finally, transcripts for three of
the six known actin isoforms were also downmodulated by
infection.
These findings demonstrated that the genes encoding
proteins involved in the assembly and disassembly of actin fibers were
downmodulated by CMV at late times. Such changes, along with a similar
impact on all three major rho family GTPases and their
downstream effectors, are likely to disrupt the organization of the
cytoplasmic microfilaments and to strongly impair the formation of
stress fibers, filopodia, and lamellipodia, eventually leading to the
rounded, enlarged cell cytopathic effect observed at late times of
infection. The same alterations, combined with the reduction in
cellular adhesion transcript levels, would also predictably affect the
potential for infected cells to migrate, weakening
GTPase-mediated mechanisms on one hand and diminishing
adhesiveness on the other
hand.
GTPases and related genes.
Transcripts encoding
GTPase category gene products involved in vesicle transport
were also strongly downmodulated and extended beyond those functions
involved in integrin-to-actin signaling (Fig.
3). The 112 genes in this category were assigned to one of six classes,
with 32 genes (29%) encoding rho-related proteins, 26 genes
(23%) encoding rab-related proteins, 17 genes (15%)
encoding ras-related proteins, 16 genes (14%) encoding
G-protein-related proteins, 14 genes (12.5%) encoding
arf-related proteins, and seven genes (6%) encoding ran-related
proteins. Forty-nine of these were assembled in the map,
which depicts the main members of the six major GTPase
families. Expression levels of 11 main G-protein family members were
altered by infection, with eight subunits, including two G
subunits (G
i2 and -12), three Gß subunits
(Gß1, -4, and -2-like), and three G
subunits
(G
10, -11, and -12), consistently downmodulated. Three
G
subunits (G
olf, G
13, and G
14)
showed upmodulation. Heterotrimeric G proteins play an
important role in transducing signals derived from the activation of
cell surface receptors by various hormones, neurotransmitters,
chemokines, and sensory stimuli. Based on the observed downmodulation
of most G
and all Gß and G
transcripts that
scored in the analysis, we would predict that the sensitivity of
infected cells to signals conveyed via G-protein-coupled receptors
would be reduced. This downmodulation may contribute to the failure of
pUS28 to have a detectable impact on host gene expression at late times
of infection.

View larger version (38K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIG. 3. GenMAPP
of virus-induced gene expression changes affecting functions involved
in vesicular traffic, including members of the G protein, ras, rho,
rab, arf, and ran families of GTPases. Family names are typed
in red, and the principal subcellular system controlled by each family
is listed underneath. Members belonging to each family are grouped by
braces (}). The same scheme shown in Fig.
2 is used with the
addition of one gene, which scored as SAM significantly downmodulated
at one time (rhoI was downmodulated in the 98 hpi data set), is light
green.
|
|
Expression levels of nine ras family members were
altered: seven (R-ras2/TC21, R-ras3/M-ras, ralB, rap1A, ragA, ragB, and
GEM/KIR) were consistently downmodulated, and two (K-ras and rasD) were
consistently upmodulated (Fig.
3). Ras family proteins
are part of complex signaling networks, controlling cellular
proliferation and survival, vesicle trafficking, cytoskeletal
organization, and integrin function. The observed persistent
downmodulation of multiple ras family members would be predicted to
impair these cellular functions. In particular, the downmodulation of
R-ras2/TC21 and rap1A, which have been shown to be potent activators of
integrins in fibroblasts
(54), was consistent with
a broad inhibitory effect on integrin functions, in remarkable
agreement with the loss-of-adhesion phenotype observed with the
cytoskeleton-extracellular matrix-adhesion-related genes. The
expression levels of nine major representatives of the rho family were
modified during infection: eight (rhoA, rhoB, rhoC, rac1, cdc42,
TC10B/rhoJ, rhoI, and rnd3/rhoE) were downmodulated, and one
(rnd2/rhoN) was upmodulated. Although rhoB, rhoC, and TC10B/rhoJ
regulate the assembly of focal adhesions and actin stress fibers in a
way similar to rhoA, the rnd proteins rnd1, rnd2, and rnd3 control
rounding of cells by counteracting some of the rhoA-regulated responses
(74,
106). Consistent with
the results obtained from the analysis of the
cytoskeleton-extracellular matrix-adhesion category, the upmodulation
of rnd2, together with the downmodulation of rhoB, rhoC, and
TC10B/rhoJ, pointed toward the destabilization of adhesion structures
and the rounding of the infected cell. Expression levels of 25 genes
encoding main representatives of the two GTPase families
involved in intracellular control of vesicle trafficking, the arf and
the rab families, were also modified in infected cells (Fig.
3). Five of these genes
encoded arf family members: two (arf6 and arl1) were consistently
downmodulated, and three (arl3, arl4, and arl8) were upmodulated. Arl1
helps maintain normal Golgi body architecture
(61) and, together with
arl3, may interact with vesicle-tethering factors associated with the
Golgi apparatus (75). The
modification of arl1 and arl3 expression levels in the infected cell
could indicate a viral strategy to exploit Golgi function for
processing viral glycoproteins and for virion envelopment
(28,
47). The persistent
downmodulation of arf6, which is involved with macropinocytosis at the
cell periphery, as well as in cell migration and wound healing through
activation of rac1 (27),
may therefore have negative effects not only on endocytic pathways but
also on cell shape and motility. This alteration was consistent with
the observed negative impact of infection on the expression of several
actin cytoskeleton-related genes (Fig.
2). Transcript expression
levels of 20 of the 60 (33%) known human rab family members were
altered during infection: 13 (rab1a, -1b, -2a, -3a, -6a, -7, -13, -18,
-21, -23, -31, -34, and -40b) were consistently downmodulated, and
seven (ray/rab1C and rab2L, -8, -20, -27a, -32, and -38) were
upmodulated by infection. These data showed a strong impact of CMV
infection on this essential family of vesicle traffic regulators,
suggesting a possible role for several rabs in the final steps of
virion morphogenesis and egress. The apparent negative impact on rab7
(important for endosome transport and phagosome maturation)
(30,
45), rab18
(involved in apical endocytosis and recycling)
(63), and rab34 (required
for efficient macropinocytosis)
(92) suggested global
inhibition of the endocytic process. This hypothesis was
supported by the consistent downmodulation of arf6 (see above) and by
the expression pattern of five genes encoding interactors of rab5, an
essential regulator of membrane traffic kinetics in the early endocytic
pathway (17) (see
information file S6, GTPases, class Rab family, in the
supplemental material). Four of these genes were consistently
downmodulated and encoded proteins involved either in signal
transmission from the active rab5 to the membrane docking apparatus
(rabaptin-5, rabex-5, and RIN2) or in endosome fusion (early endosome
antigen 1). Interestingly, the fifth and only upmodulated gene encoded
the rab5 interactor tuberin, whose main function is to
negatively regulate rab5 activity in endocytosis
(109).
Transport mechanisms involving the Golgi apparatus
also seemed to be negatively affected, based on the
downmodulation of arl1 (see above) and of rab1a, rab1b, rab2a, and
rab6a, which are required to form and maintain normal Golgi cisternae
and to regulate standard and retrograde transport between the
endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the Golgi body
(64,
95,
108).
Three of the
six consistently upmodulated rabs transcripts encode proteins involved
in melanosome transport and morphogenesis (rab8a, rab38, and rab27a).
Although rab38 is necessary to target the melanin biosynthesis enzyme
tyrp1 to end-stage melanosomes
(60), rab8 plays a role
in melanosome trafficking
(20) and rab27a is
required for the recruitment of myosin Va to melanosomes, which then
stimulates the microtubule-mediated transport of melanosomes to the
tips of dendrites in melanocytes and their transfer to adjacent
keratinocytes (48). Since
fibroblasts do not possess melanosomes, it is tempting to speculate
that the observed transcriptional upmodulation of these genes might be
part of a virus-controlled strategy to promote its maturation and
release through the specific vesicle traffic mechanisms active in
melanocytes.
Lastly, the downmodulation of rab13, a structural
and functional regulator of tight junctions
(65), was in optimal
agreement with our results pointing to cell rounding, whereas the
upmodulation of rab32, which participates in synchronizing the
mitochondrial fission process
(5), was particularly
interesting in connection with the observed disruption of the reticular
mitochondrial network in CMV-infected HFs
(66). Altogether, these
data are the first to highlight GTPases and related genes as
major targets of transcriptional modulation at late times during CMV
infection.
Nuclear DNA-encoded mitochondrial genes.
The
enzyme category had the most broadly upmodulated transcript levels
(Fig. 1 and
4). The 146 genes in this category were assigned to one of five classes,
with 55 genes (38%) encoding mitochondrial functions, 39 genes
(27%) associated with carbohydrate metabolism, 11 genes
(7%) involved in detoxification, 8 genes (5%)
participating in the synthesis and/or utilization of glutathione, and
33 genes (23%) representing miscellaneous enzymes. Mitochondrial
functions stood out as being the largest class in this category and had
a remarkably high proportion of upmodulated genes (91%).
Fifty-one genes from this class and two genes from the carbohydrate
metabolism class were assembled in a map depicting the mitochondrial
oxidative phosphorylation (oxphos) and the related biochemical pathways
involved in oxidation of fatty acids (ß-oxidation cycle),
catabolism of amino acids, and transport of NADH, acetyl coenzyme A
(CoA), and ATP (Fig. 4).
Strikingly, all 24 genes encoding components of the electron transport
chain complexes I to IV, representing one-third of the known electron
transport chain subunits, were upmodulated by infection. Half of the 18
genes that are part of the ATP synthase complex and 8 genes involved in
the assembly, biosynthesis, or activity regulation of specific
components of the oxphos (coenzyme Q7 [COQ7], cytochrome
c synthase, ATPase inhibitory factor 1, chaperone ABC1, F1
complex assembly factor 1 and 2, and cytochrome c oxidase 15
[COX15] and COX17) were consistently upmodulated during
infection. Altogether, these data revealed a very strong positive
effect of CMV infection on the expression levels of multiple genes
related to ATP synthesis, which has not been observed previously. This
impact likely results in enhanced energy production that benefits
infection. Transcripts for four (short and medium chain acyl-CoA
dehydrogenases, 3-ketoacyl-CoA thiolase, and 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA
dehydrogenase) of the six standard enzymes in the ß-oxidation
cycle and one (enoyl-CoA isomerase) of the three auxiliary enzymes
involved in the oxidation of unsaturated fatty acids were also
upmodulated. Interestingly, the only downmodulated enzyme in
the ß-oxidation cycle was the short chain enoyl-CoA hydratase,
which reverses the direction of the cycle by catalyzing the opposite
reaction of the long chain enoyl-CoA hydratase. Both the electron
transfer flavoprotein (ETFP), which transfers the electrons generated
by the ß-oxidation cycle to complex II of the oxphos system,
and the glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase, which transfers electrons generated
from the degradation of the amino acids lysine, hydroxylysine, and
tryptophan to the ETFP, were upmodulated. These findings demonstrated
that the entire mitochondrial system involved in respiration, as well
as the degradation of fatty acids and the utilization of amino acid
catabolism products, was consistently upmodulated at late times of
infection, eventually leading to an increased exploitation of the fatty
acid deposits of the cell in order to produce ATP. Further support for
this hypothesis was provided by the consistent downmodulation of the
key mediators of the fatty acid neosynthetic pathway (citrate synthase,
citrate transporter, and ATP citrate lyase), which use the acetyl-CoA
produced by the ß-oxidation cycle to store energy for later use
instead of synthesizing ATP for immediate consumption. Expression
levels of nine genes belonging to four transport systems, one importing
NADH from the cytosol and three exporting ATP from the inner
mitochondrial matrix, were also modified by infection. The cytoplasmic
and mitochondrial isoforms of glutamate oxaloacetate (GOT1 and
GOT2, respectively) and the mitochondrial malate
dehydrogenase (part of the NADH transport system), the
fibroblast isoform of adenine nucleotide translocator (ANT2), and the
ubiquitous isoform of creatine kinase (part of the ATP transport
system) were upmodulated, whereas liver ANT3 and sarcomeric creatine
kinase were downmodulated. VDAC1, which forms voltage-gated pores in
the outer mitochondrial membrane to allow diffusion of small
hydrophilic molecules and adenine nucleotides in normal
situations and of cytochrome c during apoptosis was also
downmodulated, whereas the low-abundance VDAC2 isoform that
inhibits mitochondrion-mediated apoptosis when overexpressed
(22) was upmodulated.
Taken together, these data show that the vast majority of the
genes composing the two main mitochondrial energy production
systems and their associated substrate import and product export
mechanisms were consistently upmodulated. In contrast, the genes
mediating the first three steps of the pathway leading to the
reconstitution of the fatty acids pools were downmodulated. These
findings indicate that increased mitochondrial energy production is
important at late times during CMV infection and suggest that fatty
acid catabolism may dominate over neosynthesis, leading to the
depletion of cellular fat stores during
infection.

View larger version (59K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIG. 4. GenMAPP
of virus-induced gene expression changes affecting the mitochondrial
oxphos, fatty acid ß-oxidation, malate-aspartate transport, ATP
transport, and citrate transport systems. The oxphos system is depicted
in five large boxes showing subunits (sub; small boxes) of complexes I
to IV and ATP synthase. The dashed parallel lines to the left and right
of the large boxes represent the mitochondrial inner membrane. The map
also includes a gene from the amino acid metabolism category
(glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase), three genes from the vesicle and
intracellular transport category (citrate transporter and the
voltage-dependent anion channel 1 [VDAC1] and 2
[VDAC2]) and seven genes from the lipid metabolism category
(short and medium chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase, enoyl-CoA isomerase,
short chain enoyl-CoA hydratase, 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase,
3-ketoacyl-CoA thiolase, and ATP citrate lyase). The same scheme as
shown in Fig. 2 is used.
TCA, tricarboxylic acid cycle; catab, catabolism; synth, synthesis. In
complex I, Chain 1//6 contains chains 1, 2, 3, 4, 4L, 5, and
6; B14.5A//18 Sub contains the B14.5A, B14.5B, B15, B17,
B17.2, and B18 subunits; 9//24 kDa Sub contains the 9, 9.6, 13A, 13B,
15, 18, 19, 20, 23, and 24 kDa subunits; and 14//75 Sub contains the
14, 51, and 75 kDa subunits. In Complex IV, COX1//4 contains COX1, -2,
-3, and
-4.
|
|
CMV infection has been shown to increase the
mitochondrial size (71),
to disrupt the reticular mitochondrial networks
(66), to interfere with
the mitochondrial proapoptotic pathways
(40,
41,
66,
87), and to stimulate
mitochondrial DNA synthesis
(37). Our results reveal
that CMV infection dramatically and coordinately induces the expression
of most mitochondrial ATP-production system components, possibly
resulting in the intensification of high-energy phosphate production in
order to sustain elevated energy demands of viral
replication.
Cell cycle- and cellular DNA replication-related genes.
Consistent with data in the literature
(10,
32,
34,
52,
83,
107), both cell cycle
and nucleic acid metabolism categories were strongly and positively
affected by infection (Fig.
1 and
5). The functional genomics approach used here allowed us not only to
expand the number of known cell cycle- and cellular DNA
replication-related genes upmodulated by CMV but also to gain a better
understanding of how these functions may be linked and have a concerted
impact on the cell. The 113 genes in the cell cycle category were
assigned to one of five classes, with 42 genes (37%) associated
with the G2/M phase, 27 genes (24%) involved in
general growth control, 19 genes (17%) associated with the
G1 or G1/S phases, 13 genes (11%)
associated with the S phase, and 12 genes (11%) related to p53
or pRb activities. The 229 genes in the nucleic acid metabolism
category were divided into three classes: RNA metabolism (103 genes,
45%), DNA metabolism (101 genes, 44%), and nucleotide
metabolism (25 genes, 11%). In the cell cycle category, the
S-phase class contained the highest percentage of upmodulated genes
(85%), followed by the p53-pRb-related class (75%) and
the G2/M phase class (64%). In the nucleic acid
metabolism category, the DNA metabolism class stood out as having the
largest percentage of upmodulated genes (66%), followed by the
mostly downmodulated nucleotide metabolism (42% upregulated) and
RNA metabolism (38% upregulated) classes. These data revealed a
very strong positive effect of CMV infection on the expression of
multiple S-phase, G2/M-phase, and DNA activity
regulators, probably all of which are required for efficient
viral replication. Interestingly, DNA and RNA metabolism
gene transcript levels were affected in opposite ways by viral
infection, suggesting that genes involved in DNA metabolism might be
preferentially transcribed during viral infection. A total of 112 genes
from both categories were organized into the maps shown in Fig.
5A and B, which depict
cell cycle control and DNA synthesis functions, respectively. A total
of 78% of the genes present on the maps and altered by infection
were upmodulated. Expression levels of several G1/S- and
S-phase regulators were modified by infection: while both cyclin D1 and
the associated cyclin-dependent kinase 6 (CDK6) were strongly
downmodulated, the G1 and S cyclin-CDK complex inhibitors
ink4d, kip1, kip2, and cip2 were consistently upmodulated. Transition
through the G1/S boundary is normally promoted by the
activity of the cyclin D1-CDK4 or cyclin D1-CDK6 complexes and is
normally inhibited by members of the ink, kip, and cip families of
CDK inhibitors. The observed expression pattern of these key
regulators, therefore, was indicative of a virus-induced cell cycle
arrest in G1, as proposed elsewhere
(14,
26,
62). Thedownmodulation of the CDK2, -3, -4, and -6 inhibitor cip1 and of the
G0/S transition inhibitor growth arrest-specific 1 (GAS1),
together with the upmodulation of cyclin A, cyclin G2, the
cyclin E- and cyclin A-CDK2 complex activator cdc25A, the transcription
factor E2F1, and the E2F1 dimerization partner DP2, however, suggested
a transition to an S-phase-like environment, a possibility consistent
with earlier studies (49,
81,
86). The induction of
cyclin A transcript levels at late times of infection, in particular,
was reported previously
(49), although this
comparison must be made to nonstimulated confluent HFs and not to
serum-stimulated cells
(83). The upmodulation of
nine genes encoding core components of the prereplication complex (all
six minichromosome maintenance genes [MCM2 to -7] and three
of the six origin recognition complex genes [ORC1L, -3L, and
-4L]) and of 10 genes encoding core components of the DNA
replication system (DNA polymerase
[POLA],
primase 1 [PRIM1], the
processivity factor proliferating cell nuclear antigen
[PCNA], two of the three subunits of replication factor
A [RPA2 and RPA3], and four of the five subunits
of replication factor C [RFC1 to -4]) further supported this
hypothesis. Finally, the expression of several functions
that interact with the DNA synthesis complex was altered by infection:
the prereplication complex loading inhibitor geminin, the origin
activation stimulator cdc7, the POLA-recruiting factor cdc45L, the DNA
repair polymerases ß (POLB) and
(POLE), and the
E1A-binding protein p300 (EP300), which facilitates the DNA repair
functions of PCNA, were all upmodulated, whereas the inhibitor of the
initiation step in DNA replication deleted in oral cancer 1 (DOC1) and
four additional DNA polymerases (polymerase
2
[POLA2], the regulatory subunit of polymerase
[POLD2], and the two proofreading polymerases
[POLZ] and
[POLK]) were downmodulated. In
agreement with other reports
(10,
107), these data
indicate a broad enhancement in the expression of cellular DNA
synthesis machinery and related components, possibly reflecting a need
for their presence to support viral DNA replication. In this
regard, the twofold upmodulation of DNA topoisomerase II
(TOP2A), an enzyme that catalyzes the relaxation
of supercoiled DNA and the catenation and decatenation of circular DNA
and is essential for CMV replication
(8), may contribute to the
proposed directional rolling-circle model of CMV genome replication
(67). Altogether, these
results further extend and deepen our understanding of the
well-established dysregulation of multiple G1, S, and DNA
replication genes (34,
67), unveiling a complex
system of virus-induced events potentially aimed at optimizing viral
replication rates.
Multiple components of two fundamental cell
cycle control mechanisms, the pRb and p53 systems, were also affected
by infection. In addition to E2F1 and DP2, eight pRb interacting
partners were upmodulated: five pRb-binding proteins
(RBBP2, -4, -5, -6, and -8), two histone deacetylases (HDAC1
and -11) and prohibitin, which is a protein that represses E2F-mediated
transcription (102) and,
interestingly, also impacts the assembly of mitochondrial respiratory
chain complexes (73). Two
other genes encoding pRb-binding proteins, the Abelson murine leukemia
viral oncogene homolog 1 (ABL1) and the E2F1 partner DP1, were
downmodulated. Expression levels of six p53-related genes were
modified; four were upmodulated (p53 itself, tumor protein p53-binding
protein 2 [TP53BP2], apoptosis-stimulating protein of p53 1
[ASPP1], and protein phosphatase 2C
[PP2C
]), and two were downmodulated (mouse double
minute homolog 2 [mdm2] and ataxia telangiectasia mutated
[ATM]). p53-mediated transcription of proapoptotic genes is
activated by ATM as a result of DNA damage, is enhanced by TP53BP2 and
ASPP1, and is inhibited by mdm2 and PP2C
. Thus, the persistent
upmodulation of p53 and the activators TP53BP2 and ASPP1, coupled with
the downmodulation of the inhibitor mdm2, might result in the induction
of apoptosis were it not for the concurrent downmodulation of the
stimulator ATM and the upmodulation of the inhibitor PP2C
.
These results complement and extend data in previous reports
(49), revealing a
multifaceted effect of CMV infection on the expression of several pRb-
and p53-related genes and emphasizing the ability of this virus to
simultaneously induce an S-phase-like environment in cells, achieve
replication of the viral genome, and avoid the onset of apoptosis
triggered by the checkpoint effectors.
Quite surprisingly, the
majority (50 genes, 61%) of the 82 cell cycle genes whose
expression was modified by infection (Fig.
5A) were related to the
G2/M phase, highlighting the likely importance of functions
associated with this part of the cycle for CMV infection. Expression
levels of the G2/M transition regulators wee1, myt1, cyclin
B2, CDK1, cdc28 kinase regulatory subunit 2 (CKS2), polo-like kinase 1
(plk1), peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase NIMA-interacting 1
(pin1), protein phosphatase 1
(PP1A), and the PP1A regulatory
subunit 7 (PP1R7) were upmodulated. Entry into mitosis relies upon the
properly timed activation of the cyclin B-CDK1 complex. The activity of
this complex is controlled by the antagonistic actions of
wee1 and myt1 kinases, which suppress CDK1 activity, and the cdc25B and
cdc25C phosphatases, which promote CDK1 activation
(79). In turn, cdc25C
activation in prophase is mediated by phosphorylation
through the cyclin B-CDK1-mediated feed-forward loop, by the
PP1A-mediated removal of an inhibitory phosphate on serine 216, by a
pin1-catalyzed peptidyl-proline isomerization, and by the
plk1-mediated phosphorylation of serine 198, which induces the
translocation of cdc25C into the nucleus
(94). The consistent
upmodulation of all of these regulators revealed a very strong positive
effect of CMV infection on G2/M transition control
mechanisms, possibly leading to the stimulation of infected cell
progression toward a mitosis-like state. Additional evidence supporting
this hypothesis was provided by the observation that a large proportion
(41 genes, 82%) of the 50 altered G2/M-related genes
encoded proteins specifically involved in the implementation of M-phase
events. More than half (22 genes, 54%) of these genes encode
proteins implicated in the correct formation of the mitotic spindle and
of stable spindle-chromosome attachments. These included six genes
controlling the centromere and kinetochore creation process, 10 genes
required for centrosome and mitotic spindle functions, and six
components of the spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) (Fig.
5A). Five of the six
centromere and kinetochore genes were upmodulated and encoded proteins
involved in marking a chromosomal region for centromere formation
(centromere protein A [CENPA]), in the assembly of the
kinetochore complex (suppressor of G2 allele of SKP1
[SGT1]), in the attachment of the kinetochore to microtubules
(cdcA1), and in general centromere activation (centromere protein F
[CENPF] and ZW10 interactor [zwint]). The only
downmodulated gene in this group, centromere protein C1 (CENPC1),
encodes a protein required for the inactivation of one centromere and
the creation of a functionally monocentric chromosome. Eight of the ten
centrosome and mitotic spindle genes were upmodulated and encoded
proteins important for centrosome integrity (NIMA-related kinase 2
[NEK2]), duplication (centrin 3), and maturation into a
microtubule organizing center (centrosomal protein 1 [cep1]),
for the nucleation of microtubule assembly at the spindle poles
(
tub1), for the regulation of the number of microtubule ends
in the spindle (katanin p60 and p80), and for the positioning (kinesin
family member 4A [kif4a]) and segregation (mitotic
centromere-associated kinesin [MCAK]) of mitotic chromosomes.
The two downmodulated genes encoded nuclear mitotic apparatus protein 1
(numa1), which is essential for the organization and stabilization of
spindle poles and checkpoint with forkhead and ring finger domains
(CHFR), which monitors centrosome separation and retards entry into
mitosis in the absence of this event. The observed global upmodulation
of numerous genes encoding proteins that regulate the assembly and
functionality of the mitotic spindle was unexpected and prompted us to
consider the possible progression of the infected cells into a
metaphase-like state. The downmodulation of CENPC1, CHFR, and numa1
expression, however, suggested the presence of abnormalities in this
process, as did the consistent upmodulation of six genes encoding the
SAC components budding uninhibited by benzimidazoles 1
(bub1), mitotic arrest-deficient 2A and 2B (mad2A
and mad2B), monopolar spindle 1-like (mps1L/TTK),
aurora A, and CENPE. In cells containing disrupted or
mispositioned spindles, mps1L/TTK recruits active CENPE at the
kinetochores. This is followed by the association of mad1 and mad2 and
by the mad2-mediated inhibition of the anaphase promoting
complex/cyclosome (APC/C), which effectively blocks mitotic
cells in metaphase (1).
The upmodulation of these key genes hinted at the presence of an active
SAC-like process in infected cells. This change, along with the
upmodulation of aurora A, which is associated with centrosome
amplification and multipolar spindles
(111), and of NEK2,
which induces splitting of centrosomes and dispersal of centrosomal
material (36), suggested
a damaging effect of infection on centrosome structure. The expression
levels of three APC/C core components were modified in infected cells,
with one (cdc27/apc3) downmodulated and two (apc7 and cdc23/apc8)
upmodulated. Two APC/C regulatory factors, cdc20 and
snk/plk-akin kinase (sak), were also upmodulated. The APC/C ubiquitin
ligase complex is activated by cdc20 and controls exit from mitosis by
targeting B-type cyclins and securin (also called pituitary
tumor-transforming gene 1 [PPTG1]) for degradation. The
destruction of securin stimulates the activity of separase (also called
extra spindle poles-like 1 [espl1]), a caspase-like protease,
which triggers sister chromatid separation by cleaving the scc/rad21
subunit of the cohesin complex
(43). Both cohesin and
condensin complexes ensure the correct segregation of replicated
chromosomes by organizing chromosomes into highly compact
mitotic structures (condensin) and by keeping sister chromatids
together until they split at anaphase (cohesin).
Expression levels of securin, separase, two of the four
cohesin subunits (scc/rad21 and structural maintenance of
chromosomes 3 [SMC3]), and one of the five condensin
subunits (chromosome associated protein E
[CAPE]) were upmodulated, whereas the expression of
PTTG1-interacting protein (PTTG1-IP), which facilitates securin nuclear
translocation, was downmodulated. These data indicate a substantial
increase in transcript levels of chromosome management factors,
suggesting their importance during the late phase of infection,
possibly to properly organize the mass of newly replicated viral DNA,
which can reach 4,000 copies/infected cell
(69). Finally, four genes
encoding NIMA-related kinases (NEK4, -6, -7, and -9) and four genes
encoding septins (septin2/nedd5, septin4/pnutl2, septin7/cdc10, and
septin9/msf) were transcriptionally altered in infected cells and all
except septin4/pnutl2 were downmodulated. Elimination of NEK9 results
in spindle abnormalities and chromosomal misalignments
(80), whereas inhibition
of NEK6 arrests cells in M phase and triggers apoptosis
(110). The consistent
downmodulation of NEK9 could therefore negatively impact the process of
spindle assembly, in agreement with the observed
alterations in the expression of
spindle-morphogenesis-related genes. The downmodulation of
NEK6 and of septin2/nedd5 and septin9/msf, whose depletion results in
the accumulation of binucleated and cells arrested during cytokinesis
(93), also suggested that
exit from a mitosis-like environment might be
impaired.
Altogether, these results show a global and consistent
increase in the transcript levels of numerous cell cycle regulators and
DNA replication machinery components, indicating that the ability to
control cell cycle phases and functions is important for the successful
completion of CMV
replication.
Time-dependent induction of a mitosis-like state during CMV infection and association with CMV replication components.
The
persistent transcriptional upmodulation of a very large number of
M-phase genes suggested that CMV-infected cells might proceed through a
mitosis-like state even though cellular DNA replication is blocked. To
investigate this process further, uninfected or AD-infected HFs (MOI of
10) were subjected to immunofluorescence analysis for
tub1, a
protein known to localize at centrosomes, mitotic spindle microtubules,
and spindle poles (58)
and whose expression levels were consistently upmodulated by infection.
Cellular DNA was detected by Hoechst 44432 dye staining, and infected
cells were highlighted by immunolabeling with an MAb to the viral
nuclear antigens IE1/IE2. In uninfected interphase cells, the IE1/IE2
antigens were absent and
tub1 was diffusely cytoplasmic with a
concentration in one or two spots corresponding to the centrosomes
(Fig.
6A). In infected interphase-like cells, the IE1/IE2 antigens were confined
to nuclei bounded by an intact nuclear membrane (Fig.
6C), and
tub1 was
observed in both cytoplasm and at centrosomes (Fig.
6B). Unlike uninfected
interphase cells, however, several of these cells contained more than
two
tub1-labeled centrosomes, usually positioned adjacent to
the nucleus (Fig. 6B and
D). These supernumerary centrosomes likely originated from
aberrations in some or all of the mechanisms controlling centrosome
duplication, maturation, and separation. Thus, CMV infection appears to
be associated with centrosomal injuries, a finding consistent with
early observational reports
(18,
39,
71). The data obtained
from functional genomic analysis, however, allows us to understand how
the complex interplay between CMV and the cell cycle machinery may be
affecting the functioning of the centrosome and to speculate which
genes might be involved in the generation of the observed injuries. The
upmodulation of NEK2, aurora A, and mps1L/TTK in infected cells may be
directly related to this process, given that overexpression of these
gene products in mammalian cells results in aberrant centrosome
duplication (31,
36,
111). The product of the
upmodulated gene PP1A is also a good candidate as an effector function,
because this protein localizes at centrosomes during mitosis
(7) and modulates NEK2
kinase activity (46). The
microtubule organizing center, where centrosomes normally reside, is
where final steps of viral particle production occur, likely as the
ultimate site of virion tegumentation and envelopement
(82). Moreover, this
structure is visible as a cytoplasmic inclusion and functions as a
gathering site for cellular organelles, dense bodies, virions, and
other virus-like particles at late times postinfection
(88). Thus, the increased
expression levels of several genes whose products are involved in
governing the functionality of the microtubule organizing center, such
as centrin 3, cep1, plk1, and cdk1, might be part of a viral strategy
to gain control of this structure.
In uninfected mitotic cells,
tub1 was associated with the two spindle poles and the surface
of the aster microtubules (Fig.
7A), and chromosomal DNA was condensed into a highly ordered metaphase plate
(Fig. 7B and C), as
expected (58). In
infected nonnucleated cells, the localization of
tub1 revealed
the presence of two types of spindles: bipolar with
tub1
associated with each pole and with the aster microtubules (Fig.
7D, upper left cell) and
bipolar or multipolar with
tub1 localized at each pole, at
additional pole-like structures around the aster, and distributed along
the aster microtubules (Fig.
7D, lower right cell, L,
and M). In these cells, chromosomal DNA appeared condensed in bulks,
which were either concentrated in the same area occupied by the spindle
(Fig. 7F and I) or
dispersed throughout the entire cell volume (Fig.
7K). Consistent with the
loss of nuclear integrity during mitosis, the IE1/IE2 antigens were
dispersed throughout the cell body (Fig.
6G, L, and M). Depending
on the orientation of the cell on the coverslip, the previously
reported (57) association
of the IE1 protein with chromosomal DNA was more (Fig.
7J) or less evident (Fig.
7G). No matter the spindle
type, chromosomal DNA bulks were never correctly organized in a
metaphase plate typical of normal mitosis. Thus, the observed phenotype
of these nonnucleated cells and of uninfected mitotic cells were
similar in that both contained
tub1-labeled spindles and
condensed chromosomal DNA; however, the localization of
tub1,
the number of spindle poles, and the appearance and intracellular
distribution of the condensed DNA in the nonnucleated cells were
clearly different from those observed in normal mitosis. This phenotype
revealed that pathological events had occurred during their formation,
and therefore these infected cells were denoted
"pseudomitotic."
Pseudomitosis
has been previously noted in CMV-infected cultures
(11) but never subjected
to direct study in relation to viral gene expression during the late
phase of infection. The percentage of IE1/IE2-positive
pseudomitotic cells observed in AD-infected
HF cultures in three independent experiments peaked at 72 hpi
(33% of cells), increasing from ca. 2% at 24 hpi to
16% at 50 hpi (Fig.
8A). Interestingly, the proportion of
pseudomitotic cells appeared to decline to
20 to 29% (mean value, 25%) by 98 hpi. Background mitosis
in mock-infected confluent cultures was very low, i.e., 0.2% at
24 h, 0.05% at 50 h, 0.03% at
72 h, and <0.005% at 98 h (data not
shown), indicating that virus infection was modulating cell behavior.
The vast majority of the pseudomitotic cells
in infected cultures were IE1/IE2 positive (between 97% at 24
hpi and 100% at 98 hpi), indicating that the induction of the
pseudomitotic features was strictly
associated with infection. Pseudomitosis, therefore, developed in an
apparent transient fashion during the late phase of viral infection
with a peak at 72 hpi. Altogether, these results showed that, as
predicted from the microarray data, CMV infection was associated with
the initiation of mitotic events in the host cell and with the
generation of abnormalities in the processes of centrosome duplication,
spindle assembly, and chromosome condensation.
We next sought to
determine whether the appearance of
pseudomitotic cells was dependent upon
cellular or viral DNA replication. AD-infected HFs were either left
untreated or maintained in the presence of 1 mM HU (to block only
cellular DNA synthesis), 10 mM HU (to block cellular and viral DNA
synthesis) (6,
15,
59), or 300 µg of
PFA/ml (to block only viral DNA synthesis)
(97,
99) before the cells were
processed for immunofluorescence analysis with anti-
tub1 and
anti-IE1/IE2 antibodies. As expected, treatment with these drugs did
not have any effect on IE1/IE2 expression, and similar, almost-uniform
infection based on IE1/IE2 positive cells was observed in all cultures.
The percentage of IE1/IE2-positive
pseudomitotic cells observed at 72 hpi
ranged from a mean of 31% (six independent experiments) in
untreated cultures to a mean of 25% (three independent
experiments) in 1 mM HU-treated cultures to a mean value of 2%
(three independent experiments) in 10 mM HU-treated cultures to a mean
value of 2% (five independent experiments) in PFA-treated
cultures (Fig.
8B). The
strong reduction in the percentage of
pseudomitotic cells observed in conditions
in which viral DNA synthesis was inhibited but not where cellular DNA
synthesis alone was blocked demonstrated that the appearance of
pseudomitotic cells followed and was
dependent on initiation of viral DNA replication during
infection.
To determine whether the viral replication cycle
progressed normally in pseudomitotic cells,
infected cultures were subjected to immunofluorescence analysis for the
viral delayed early protein ppUL44
(68,
105), the early-late
protein pp150 (82),
and the true-late protein pUL43
(2). A