Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, December 2003, p. 13361-13375, Vol. 77, No. 24
0022-538X/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.77.24.13361-13375.2003
Copyright © 2003, American
Society for
Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Region of Outer-Capsid Protein µ1 Undergoes Conformational Change and Release from Reovirus Particles during Cell Entry
John S. L. Parker,1,
Marcelo Ehrlich,2,3 Tomas Kirchhausen,2,3 and Max L. Nibert1*
Departments of Microbiology and Molecular Genetics,1 Cell Biology,2 Center for Blood Research, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 021153
Received 6 June 2003/ Accepted 5 September 2003
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 remain particle
bound have been identified. Experiments with antibody reagents in this
study yielded new information about the steps in particle disassembly
during cell entry. Monoclonal antibodies specific for the
region of µ1 provided evidence for a conformational change in
µ1 and for release of the
proteolytic fragment from
entering particles. Antiserum raised against cores provided evidence
for entry-related changes in particle structure and identified entering
particles that largely lack the
fragment inside cells.
Antibodies specific for
1 showed that it is also largely shed
from entering particles. Limited coimmunostaining with markers for late
endosomes and lysosomes indicated the particles lacking
and
1 did not localize to those subcellular compartments, and
other observations suggested that both the particles and free
were released into the cytoplasm. Essentially equivalent findings were
obtained with native ISVPs and highly infectious recoated particles
containing wild-type proteins. Poorly infectious recoated particles
containing a hyperstable mutant form of µ1, however, showed no
evidence for the in vitro and intracellular changes in particle
structure normally detected by antibodies, and these particles instead
accumulated in late endosomes or lysosomes. Recoated particles with
hyperstable µ1 were also ineffective at mediating erythrocyte
lysis in vitro and promoting
-sarcin coentry and intoxication
of cells in cultures. Based on these and other findings, we propose
that ISVP* is a transient intermediate in cell entry which mediates
membrane penetration and is then further uncoated in the cytoplasm to
yield particles, resembling cores, that largely lack the
fragment of
µ1. | INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Reoviruses
belong to the family Reoviridae, an evolutionarily divergent
group of double-stranded RNA viruses whose human-infecting members also
include rota-, orbi-, colti-, and seadornaviruses (see references
52 and
68 for general reviews).
Reovirus virions are 85 nm wide and comprise a genome enclosed by two
concentric, icosahedral protein capsids
(25,
48). The genome,
inner-capsid proteins, and outer-capsid protein
2 constitute
the core particle (63),
which is competent for genome-dependent synthesis, capping, and export
of translatable viral mRNAs
(2,
31,
62). The surface-exposed
outer-capsid proteins
2, µ1,
3, and
1 affect survival in the environment
(24,
49) and mediate adherence
to cells and entry into the cytoplasm
(3,
13,
15,
16,
33,
35,
38,
43). The bulk of the
outer capsid consists of 200 heterohexameric complexes of putative
membrane penetration protein µ1 (76 kDa) and its protector
protein,
3 (41 kDa)
(25,
40), arranged in a
fenestrated T=13 (alevo) net
(48) over the T=1
inner capsid (57). This
lattice is substituted at the fivefold vertices by pentameric turrets
of the mRNA-capping protein
2 (144 kDa)
(20,
28,
45,
57,
72). At the center of
each turret is anchored a trimeric receptor-binding fiber of adhesin
1 (
50 kDa)
(16,
18,
30,
64). The µ1
protein is apparently autolytic and cleaves itself into 4-kDa
N-terminal fragment µ1N and 72-kDa C-terminal fragment
µ1C (40,
53).
Stepwise
remodeling and/or disassembly of the outer capsid is a feature of cell
entry by reoviruses and can be at least partly recapitulated in vitro.
Under some conditions, protease treatment of virions yields infectious
subvirion particles (ISVPs), which have lost
3 to degradation
and contain a cleaved form of µ1 (59-kDa N-terminal fragment
and 13-kDa C-terminal fragment
generated from
µ1C) as the major surface protein
(7,
22,
25,
36,
51,
57,
59). Under other
conditions, protease treatment of virions yields cores, which have
additionally lost the µ1 fragments and
1
(25,
36,
42,
51,
53,
57,
63). ISVP-like particles
are a required intermediate for cell entry
(1,
46,
65) and are generated
from virions either by extracellular proteolysis in the intestinal
lumen (4,
6) or by endosomal or
lysosomal proteolysis following endocytic uptake from the cell surface
(1,
26,
65). The capacity of
ISVPs, but not virions or cores, to induce membrane permeabilization
both in vitro and in cell cultures
(8,
13-15,
35,
43,
67) has been interpreted
as evidence that ISVP-like particles initiate membrane penetration,
resulting in cytoplasmic delivery of "transcriptase
particles" activated to synthesize viral mRNAs for translation
and packaging. However, ISVPs have hydrophilic surfaces
(7,
25,
30,
36), suggesting they must
undergo further changes before insertion into a lipid bilayer.
Furthermore, because the viral transcriptases are inhibited in virions
and ISVPs but activated in cores
(7,
9,
23,
27,
36,
73), entry must be
accompanied or followed by structural changes that result in
transcriptase activation. Transcriptase particles derived from
infecting virions or ISVPs have been isolated from cells by several
groups but have been variously reported to resemble ISVPs or cores in
protein composition (e.g., to contain or lack, respectively, large
amounts of the µ1 fragments)
(8,
9,
60,
61).
In an attempt
to understand the membrane penetration step in cell entry by
reoviruses, Chandran et al. recently examined the mechanism
by which ISVPs induce the permeabilization of erythrocyte membranes
(hemolysis) in vitro
(13). They found that
hemolysis is preceded by a suite of structural changes in the ISVP,
including a conformational change in µ1 that exposes
hydrophobic regions and increases the sensitivity of the
fragment to further proteolysis. The structural changes also include
the shedding of
1 and an inferred conformational change in
2 that promotes
1 release. In sum, these changes
convert the ISVP to a distinct particle form, the ISVP*, which is both
necessary and sufficient to mediate hemolysis and is activated for
viral mRNA synthesis. These results led to the proposal that the
ISVP
ISVP* transition must precede membrane penetration and
transcriptase activation in cells and that ISVP*s, rather than ISVPs or
cores, may most closely resemble the particles that penetrate the
cytoplasm and initiate mRNA synthesis
(13).
In the
present study, we used a combination of approaches to test whether the
ISVP
ISVP* transition must indeed accompany productive cell
entry by reoviruses. We found that a conformational change involving
the
region of µ1 precedes viral protein synthesis in
ISVP-infected cells and that
1 is shed from the particles
during entry, as predicted by the previous in vitro work. We also found
that particles resembling cores are efficiently generated inside cells
by the additional shedding of the
proteolytic fragment and
that both these particles and free
localize to the cytoplasm
early after infection. Recoated particles containing a mutant,
hyperstable form of µ1 were found to be defective in both the
ISVP
ISVP* change in vitro and infection of cells in cultures.
Results obtained with recoated particles furthermore established a
strong link between productive cell entry and the µ1
conformational change and disassembly events discovered in this and
previous work. We conclude that the ISVP* is a necessary but transient
intermediate in the disassembly cascade that accompanies cell entry by
reoviruses.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Virions, ISVPs, ISVP*s, and
cores.
Virions of reovirus
T1L were grown and purified by the standard protocol
(30) and stored in virion
buffer (150 mM NaCl, 10 mM MgCl2, 10 mM Tris [pH
7.5]). To generate virions containing
[35S]methionine-cysteine-labeled proteins,
Tran35S label (7 mCi) (ICN, Costa Mesa, Calif.) was added at
the onset of infection. Nonpurified ISVPs were used in all experiments
and were obtained by digesting virions in virion buffer at
concentrations of 5 x 1012 to 1 x
1013 particles/ml with
N
-p-tosyl-L-lysine
chloromethyl ketone-treated
-chymotrypsin (200
µg/ml) (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis. Mo.) for 10 to 20 min at 32
or 37°C. Digestion was stopped by the addition of ethanolic
phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (2 to 5 mM) (Sigma-Aldrich) at
4°C. Parallel ISVP and ISVP* samples (see Fig.
1 and
2) were obtained by
treatment of nonpurified ISVPs at a concentration of 4 x
1012 particles/ml with NaCl and CsCl (300 mM), respectively,
for 10 to 20 min at 32 or 37°C, followed by removal to
4°C. Purified cores were obtained from virions as described
previously (15,
54). Particle
concentrations were estimated by measuring the A260
(22). Infection of L929
cells and plaque assays to determine viral titers were carried out as
described previously (30,
49).
|
|
1 (5C6), and
2 (7F4) were grown and purified
as described previously
(70). Human
LAMP-2-specific MAb H4B4
(44) was purchased from
the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank (Department of Biological
Sciences, University of Iowa, Iowa City). Human LAMP-1-specific rabbit
polyclonal antiserum (11)
was a generous gift from M. Fukuda (The Burnham Institute, La Jolla,
Calif.). The production of µNS-specific rabbit polyclonal
antiserum has been described elsewhere
(10). Core- and
1-specific rabbit polyclonal antisera were produced by the
Polyclonal Antibody Service (Animal Care Unit, University of Wisconsin
Medical School, Madison) from purified T1L cores that had been heat
inactivated by incubation for 10 min at 70°C
(15) and from purified
glutathione S-transferase- T1L
1 fusion
protein (13),
respectively. In some cases, primary antibodies were directly
conjugated to Alexa 488 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, Oreg.) in accordance
with the manufacturer's instructions. All primary antibodies were
titrated to maximize the signal-to-noise ratio. Goat anti-mouse
immunoglobulin G (IgG) and goat anti-rabbit IgG conjugated to Alexa 488
or Alexa 594 were obtained from Molecular Probes and used at a dilution
of 1:500. Plasmid constructs encoding protein µ1-HS. Plasmid pBKS-M2L encoding T1L µ1 with the P344L and L359F mutations (15) was the template for site-directed mutagenesis by the QuikChange protocol (Stratagene, La Jolla, Calif.). Complementary mutagenic primers with the sequences 5'-GCCATTCCACCTAAGCCAGAAGACTATAATGTGCGTAC-3' and 5'-GTACGCACATTATAGTCTTCTGGCTTAGGTGGAATGGC-3' (nucleotide changes underlined) were used to change alanine 319 to glutamic acid (A319E) and to create a BbsI site for screening mutant clones. A Bsu36I-MluI restriction fragment encoding the desired amino acid changes (A319E, P344L, and L359F) was sequenced and subcloned into shuttle plasmid pFastbacDUAL-M2L-S4L (15) for recombinant baculovirus production (see below). The construct expressing µ1 with the A319E, P344L, and L359F mutations is henceforth referred to as µ1-HS.
Recombinant
µ1,
3, and
1.
A recombinant baculovirus
coexpressing T1L µ1-HS and
3 was generated in Sf21
cells by using the Bac-to-Bac system (Invitrogen) as previously
described for T1L with wild-type µ1 (µ1-WT) and
3 (15). A
recombinant baculovirus separately expressing T1L
1 has been
described elsewhere (17).
Tn High Five cells were infected with third- or fourth-passage
baculovirus stocks (5 to 10 PFU/cell) and harvested at 65 h
postinfection (p.i.). Cytoplasmic lysates of baculovirus-infected cells
expressing only µ1 and
3 or expressing µ1,
3, and
1 were prepared by lysis with Triton X-100 or
probe sonication, respectively, as described previously
(15,
16).
Recoated
cores.
Recoated cores
containing recombinant µ1 and
3 (r-cores) or
µ1,
3, and
1 (r-cores+
1)
were prepared by incubation of insect cell lysates containing these
proteins (see above) with purified T1L cores, followed by
repurification of particles on CsCl gradients as described previously
(15,
16). Nonpurified
ISVP-like and ISVP*-like particles derived from r-cores and
r-cores+
1 (pr-cores and pr-cores+
1,
respectively) were obtained as described above for
virions.
Immunoprecipitation.
Protein A-conjugated magnetic beads
(10 µl) (Dynal, Lake Success, N.Y.) were incubated with
antibody (15 µg of MAb or 35 µl of antiserum) for
2 h at room temperature and washed three times with
immunoprecipitation buffer (IP buffer) (10 mM Tris [pH 8.0],
150 mM NaCl, 1% NP-40). Viral particles (5 x
1010 per 10 µl) were added to the antibody-bound
beads with ice-cold IP buffer (180 µl). Samples were incubated
with rotary mixing for 1 h at 4°C, washed six times
with ice-cold IP buffer, and boiled in gel sample buffer
(30) for 3 to 5 min.
Proteins released from the beads were detected by liquid scintillation
counting or sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis (PAGE) followed by staining with Coomassie brilliant
blue R-250 (Sigma-Aldrich) or phosphorimaging with a Storm system
(Molecular Dynamics, Sunnyvale, Calif.). ISVP-infected Mv1Lu cells were
lysed by incubation with ice-cold IP buffer for 30 min at 4°C
in the presence of protease inhibitors (Roche, Indianapolis, Ind.) and
centrifuged at 8,000 x g for 10 min to remove nuclei
and cell debris (see Fig.
4). Viral particles and
proteins within the resulting cytoplasmic lysates were
immunoprecipitated essentially as described above, except that 20
µl of antibody-bound beads was used per reaction with a
cytoplasmic lysate generated from
2 x 106
cells.
|
2.5 x 104 particles/cell, unless
otherwise noted) were allowed to bind to cells on coverslips for
1 h at 4°C. Coverslips were then rinsed in PBS-MC and
fixed immediately or placed in DMEM containing CHX and returned to
37°C. Infected cells were fixed by incubation with 2%
paraformaldehyde for 10 to 15 min at room temperature and washed three
times with PBS. Fixed cells were permeabilized by incubation with
saponin (0.5%) in PBS supplemented with 0.5% bovine serum
albumin (PBSA) for immunostaining of LAMP-1 or LAMP-2 or with Triton
X-100 (0.1%) in PBSA for immunostaining of viral proteins.
Permeabilized cells were incubated with primary antibodies for 30 min
in PBSA, washed three times with PBS, and incubated with secondary
antibodies for 30 min in PBSA. After three more washes with PBS,
coverslips were mounted on glass slides with Prolong antifade reagent
(Molecular Probes) and examined by using a TE-300 inverted microscope
with fluorescence optics (Nikon, Melville, N.Y.). Wide-field
epifluorescence images were collected as described previously
(55) and prepared for
presentation by using Adobe Photoshop and Illustrator (Adobe Systems,
San Jose, Calif.). Confocal images were acquired with an Axiovert 200M
inverted microscope (Carl Zeiss, Inc., Thornwood, N.Y.) under the
control of SlideBook (Intelligent Imaging Innovations, Denver, Colo.).
The microscope was equipped with a motorized filter turret and lens
holder, a x63 lens (Pan Apochromat, 1.4 NA; Carl Zeiss), and a
spinning-disk confocal head (Perkin-Elmer, Wellesley, Mass.).
Three-dimensional image stacks were recorded by acquisition of
sequential sections recorded along the z axis by varying the
position of the objective lens holder (step size, 0.3 µm).
Images were processed with SlideBook (two-dimensional maximum-intensity
projections). Prior to quantitation, images were deconvolved with the
Near-Neighbors algorithm (SlideBook) by using calculated point spread
functions
(39).
Flow
cytometry.
Untreated or
CHX-pretreated Mv1Lu cells were suspended in PBS-MC at 2 x
107 cells/ml and incubated with ISVPs (
5 x
104 particles/cell, unless otherwise noted) for 1
h at 4°C. After being washed with PBS to remove unbound virus,
cells were suspended at a concentration of 106/ml in DMEM
containing CHX and returned to 37°C. Samples were agitated
every 10 to 15 min to keep cells in suspension and were removed to ice
at various times. Infected cells were pelleted at 500 x
g to remove growth medium and fixed, permeabilized, and
immunostained in suspension as described above for cell monolayers.
Immunostained cells were suspended in PBS, and data were collected with
a FACScalibur flow cytometer and analyzed with CellQuest software
(Beckton Dickinson, San Jose, Calif.). Isotype or preimmune serum
controls were used to determine background fluorescence with each
antibody.
-Sarcin coentry
assay.
The methods of
Liprandi and colleagues
(41) were used to measure
virus-induced intoxication of cells by
-sarcin,but with several changes. Confluent L929 cell monolayers in 48-well
microplates were preincubated in methionine-free DMEM (Invitrogen) for
2 h at 37°C and washed with ice-cold PBS-MC. Viral
particles (ISVPs,
5.0 x 104 particles/cell;
pr-cores+
1,
5.0 x
105 particles/cell) were allowed to bind to cells for
1 h at 4°C. After two washes with ice-cold PBS-MC to
remove unbound virus, prewarmed methionine-free DMEM supplemented with
[35S]methionine-cysteine (22 µCi/ml)
(Dupont NEN, Wilmington, Del.) and
-sarcin (50 µg/ml)
(Sigma-Aldrich) was added. After incubation for various times at
37°C, cells were lysed and proteins were precipitated with
ice-cold trichloroacetic acid (10%) for 1 h.
Precipitates were washed with acetone, air dried, and solubilized with
1% SDS in 0.1 M NaOH. Acid-precipitable counts were measured by
liquid scintillation counting to quantitate the incorporation of
35S-labeled amino acids into
proteins.
SDS-PAGE and immunoblotting. SDS-PAGE was performed with 10% acrylamide gels as described previously (51). Viral proteins were detected with Coomassie brilliant blue R-250. Gels loaded with radiolabeled proteins were dried on filter paper and visualized by phosphorimaging with the Storm system. For immunoblotting, proteins were transferred to nitrocellulose with a Mini-TransBlot system (Bio-Rad, Hercules, Calif.). µ1-specific mouse MAb 10F6 (1:1,000 dilution) and mouse-specific goat IgG conjugated to alkaline phosphatase (1:2,000 dilution) (Sigma-Aldrich) were used as primary and secondary antibodies, respectively. Antibody binding was detected with colorimetric reagents p-nitroblue tetrazolium chloride and 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolylphosphate p-toluidine salt (Bio-Rad).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ISVP* transition, we assessed the capacity
of four MAbs specific for the
region of µ1
(70) to immunoprecipitate
purified T1L ISVPs or ISVP*s in vitro. MAbs 10H2 and 8H6 precipitated
similar numbers of ISVPs and ISVP*s, suggesting that their epitopes are
similarly exposed and accessible in both particles (Fig.
1a). In contrast, MAbs 4A3 and 10F6 precipitated much smaller numbers of
ISVPs than of ISVP*s (only 1 in 100 to 1 in 50 as many) (Fig.
1a), suggesting that their
epitopes are accessible in ISVP*s but masked in ISVPs.
The
capacity of MAbs 4A3 and 10F6 to recognize the
region of
µ1 in ISVP*s but not in ISVPs in vitro led us to hypothesize
that they may be useful for detecting the µ1 conformational
change during cell entry. To test this hypothesis, we allowed T1L ISVPs
to adsorb to Mv1Lu cells at 4°C and later immunostained the
samples with 10H2, 8H6, 4A3, or 10F6 (Fig.
1b to e). Before
adsorption, we treated the cells with CHX to abolish protein synthesis
and to ensure that only proteins in infecting particles were later
detected by IF microscopy. When cells kept at 4°C after
adsorption were stained with 10H2 (Fig.
1b) or 8H6 (Fig.
1c), we observed punctate
staining concentrated at cell margins, suggesting that the MAbs were
bound to ISVPs at the cell surface. We obtained similar results with
1-specific MAb 5C6
(70) (data not shown). In
contrast, we observed little staining with 4A3 (Fig.
1d) or 10F6 (Fig.
1e). These findings are
consistent with the immunoprecipitation results (Fig.
1a) and provide further
evidence that 10H2 and 8H6 recognize the µ1 conformer in ISVPs,
whereas 4A3 and 10F6 do so only poorly.
When ISVP-adsorbed cells
were warmed to 37°C and immunostained with 10H2 (Fig.
1b) or 8H6 (Fig.
1c) at 2 h p.i.,
punctate staining was still observed, suggesting that the MAbs were
bound to the
region of µ1 in viral particles before
or after uptake from the cell surface. Interestingly, some diffuse
cytoplasmic and nuclear staining also was seen in many cells. More
striking was the dramatic induction of staining by 4A3 (Fig.
1d) or 10F6 (Fig.
1e) at 2 h p.i.
This staining was largely diffuse and distributed throughout the
cytoplasm and nucleus, although some punctate staining also was noted.
We conclude from these results that µ1 changes conformation at
early times p.i., such that a large proportion of its
region
can be newly recognized by 4A3 and 10F6. We also conclude that much of
this conformationally altered protein region is no longer particle
bound, since its staining is diffuse and not confined to punctate
spots. In addition, the presence of 4A3 and 10F6 staining in the
cytoplasm and nucleus strongly suggested that a substantial fraction of
the
fragment had successfully penetrated the cellular
membrane barrier.
Anticore serum detects
changes in particle structure in vitro and at early times
p.i.
In the course of the
present experiments, we found that a polyclonal antiserum raised
against reovirus cores
(15) also differs in its
capacity to recognize ISVPs and ISVP*s. This antiserum precipitated
similar numbers of ISVP*s and cores but only small numbers of ISVPs in
vitro (1 in 50 to 1 in 25 as many ISVPs as ISVP*s or cores) (Fig.
2a). These findings suggested that core epitopes are largely masked in
ISVPs but become more accessible upon changes in particle structure
during the ISVP
ISVP* and ISVP*
core transitions.
Anticore serum therefore may be another useful reagent for detecting
changes in particle structure during cell entry. To test this
possibility, we allowed T1L ISVPs to adsorb to CHX-treated Mv1Lu cells
as described above and later immunostained the samples with anticore
serum (Fig. 2b and
c). Little staining was observed in cells kept
at 4°C, confirming that anticore serum binds poorly to ISVPs at
the cell surface (Fig.
2b). When the cells were
warmed to 37°C and immunostained with anticore serum, however,
a dramatic induction of staining was seen. This staining was
exclusively punctate in nature (Fig.
2b and c) and colocalized
with staining for core protein
2 by
2-specific MAb
7F4 (Fig. 2c).
We conclude that infecting ISVPs undergo changes in particle structure
at early times p.i., such that they can be newly recognized by
antibodies in anticore serum.
Changes in
particle structure, including the µ1 conformational change,
precede viral protein synthesis.
We hypothesized that the structural
changes exhibited by ISVPs within 2 h p.i. may be linked to
productive cell entry. As a test, we compared the kinetics of changes
detected by MAb 4A3 or 10F6 or by anticore serum with those of a marker
for productive cell entry, the synthesis of viral nonstructural protein
µNS. T1L ISVPs were allowed to adsorb to CHX-treated or
untreated Mv1Lu cells at 4°C, and cells were prepared for
immunostaining either immediately or after incubation at 37°C
for various times. Untreated samples were immunostained with
anti-µNS serum
(10). All samples were
then analyzed by flow cytometry. Induction of staining with 4A3, 10F6,
or anticore serum in CHX-treated cells occurred rapidly and with
similar kinetics (0 to 10 min p.i.) (Fig.
3), suggesting that the µ1 conformational change and particle
disassembly are contemporaneous. The induction of µNS synthesis
in untreated cells lagged the structural changes by
20 min
(Fig. 3b), consistent with
the hypothesis that structural changes are associated with penetration
of viral particles into the cytoplasm and/or derepression of
transcriptase complexes within the
particles.
|
and
1 from viral particles during cell
entry.
To characterize the
particles detected by anticore serum at early times p.i. in the absence
of protein synthesis, we infected CHX-treated Mv1Lu cells with T1L
ISVPs and later immunostained the samples with anticore serum together
with MAbs specific for the
region of µ1 or
1. At 2 h p.i., we observed colocalization in only a
few punctate spots with anticore serum and
-specific MAb 10H2
(Fig.
4a), 4A3 (Fig. 4b), or 10F6
(data not shown), suggesting that most of the particles recognized by
anticore serum contained little
. In addition, the punctate
staining detected with anticore serum largely did not colocalize with
that detected with
1-specific MAb 5C6, suggesting that the
particles also contained little
1 (Fig.
4c). We considered it
possible that the particles resembling cores might have been generated
by proteolysis of ISVPs or ISVP*s that failed to penetrate the
cytoplasm and were instead trapped within hydrolytic compartments of
the endocytic pathway. To test this possibility, we coimmunostained
ISVP-infected cells with anticore serum and antibodies specific for the
late endosomal and lysosomal proteins LAMP-1 and LAMP-2
(11,
44). At 2 h
p.i., little colocalization was observed between the particles and
LAMP-1-positive (data not shown) or LAMP-2-positive (Fig.
4d) compartments, leading
us to conclude that particles that resemble cores and that are produced
during cell entry are not associated with late endosomes or lysosomes
and likely are localized to the cytoplasm (see Discussion for other
results).
Immunoprecipitation evidence for
the release of
and
1 from viral particles during
cell entry.
We used
immunoprecipitation as a further test of whether particles resembling
cores are generated from infecting ISVPs at early times p.i.
[35S]methionine-cysteine-labeled ISVPs were
allowed to adsorb to CHX-treated Mv1Lu cells at 4°C, and the
cells were lysed with nonionic detergent either immediately or after
incubation at 37°C for 2 h. Postnuclear cell extracts
were incubated with anticore serum or
2-specific MAb 7F4, and
antibody-protein complexes were affinity purified and analyzed by
SDS-PAGE. We found that anticore serum precipitated about 10-fold more
particles from the 2-h cell extract than from the 0-h cell extract
(Fig. 4e and data not shown), consistent with its increased
immunostaining of cells incubated for 2 h at 37°C
relative to those kept at 4°C (Fig.
2b). A more modest (about
twofold) increase was observed with 7F4 (Fig.
4e and data not shown).
Densitometric quantitation of core proteins and
(Fig.
4f) and visual comparison
of
1 levels in Fig.
4e further indicated that
particles precipitated from the 2-h cell extract by anticore serum or
7F4 contained much less
and
1 than purified ISVPs,
whereas particles precipitated from the 0-h cell extract resembled
ISVPs in protein composition (Fig.
4f). These results provide
additional evidence that both
and
1 are lost from
viral particles during cell
entry.
ISVP-like particles derived from
recoated cores containing mutant µ1-HS are defective in
hemolysis and do not undergo the ISVP
ISVP* transition at
37°C in vitro.
Having
observed structural changes that precede viral protein synthesis at
early times p.i. with ISVPs, we sought further evidence that these
changes are linked to productive cell entry. To this end, we obtained
and characterized hyperstable ISVPs that convert to ISVP*s only poorly
at physiological temperatures in vitro. Previous work provided clues
for engineering such particles. ISVPs derived from
ethanol-resistant viral clones containing mutations in µ1
(e.g., A319E) and ISVP-like particles derived from recoated cores
containing µ1 with the P344L and L359F mutations exhibit
quantitative defects in in vitro membrane permeabilization
(15,
35,
71; K. Chandran and
M. L. Nibert, unpublished data). Because
virus-induced permeabilization of erythrocytes requires ISVP*-like
particles (13), we
reasoned that these mutations may act by slowing the ISVP
ISVP*
transition and may cause a more severe defect if combined in the same
protein. Accordingly, we engineered µ1-HS together with
wild-type
1 and generated recoated cores containing
µ1-HS or µ1-WT [r-cores(µ1-HS) and
r-cores(µ1-WT), respectively). r-cores(µ1-HS) resembled
r-cores(µ1-WT) in protein composition (Fig.
5a), three-dimensional structure determined by scanning electron
cryomicroscopy (12) (data
not shown), and capacity to convert to ISVP-like particles
[pr-cores(µ1-HS)] upon chymotrypsin treatment (Fig.
5a), indicating that the
mutations in µ1-HS caused no gross defects in viral
structure.
|
µ1* change, as described
previously (13), and
provided evidence that pr-cores(µ1-HS) failed to induce
hemolysis because they did not undergo the
µ1
µ1* change under the conditions used (Fig.
5c and d).
We also
used µ1-specific MAbs to assess the capacity of
pr-cores(µ1-HS) to undergo the µ1
µ1*
change. pr-cores(µ1-WT) and pr-cores(µ1-HS) were
incubated under conditions that favored either the maintenance of ISVPs
or the conversion to ISVP*s. Samples were then immunoprecipitated with
MAb 10H2 or 10F6 and resolved by SDS-PAGE and Coomassie brilliant blue
R-250 staining. pr-cores(µ1-WT) preincubated with NaCl were
recognized by 10H2 but not by 10F6, whereas pr-cores(µ1-WT)
preincubated with CsCl were recognized by both MAbs, consistent with a
Cs+-accelerated µ1
µ1*
change in viral particles
(13) (Fig.
5e).
pr-cores(µ1-HS) preincubated with NaCl produced a pattern of
MAb recognition similar to that produced by pr-cores(µ1-WT),
providing additional evidence that particle-bound µ1-HS
resembles µ1-WT in overall protein conformation (Fig.
5f). In contrast to
pr-cores(µ1-WT), however, pr-cores(µ1-HS) preincubated
with CsCl were recognized by 10H2 but not by 10F6, supporting the
conclusion that they undergo the µ1
µ1* change
very slowly at 37°C (Fig.
5f).
In native
ISVPs, the µ1
µ1* change is accompanied by
1 release from particles
(13) (Fig.
5f). To test whether
recoated particles containing µ1-HS exhibited
1
release even in the absence of a detectable
µ1
µ1* change, we preincubated
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) and
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) with NaCl or CsCl,
immunoprecipitated the samples with
1-specific MAb 5C6, and
analyzed the precipitated proteins as described above (Fig.
5e and f).
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) preincubated with NaCl were
precipitated by 5C6, whereas pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT)
preincubated with CsCl were not, indicating the release of
1
in association with the µ1
µ1* change, as
expected (Fig. 5e). In
contrast, pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) preincubated with
either NaCl or CsCl were precipitated by 5C6, indicating that they had
not lost
1 and providing further evidence that
1
release from particles requires the µ1
µ1*
change (Fig.
5f).
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS)
are defective in cell entry.
Because
pr-cores±
1(µ1-HS) are defective in undergoing
the ISVP
ISVP* transition and in mediating membrane
permeabilization in vitro, we predicted that they also would be
defective in productive cell entry. To test this prediction, we allowed
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) or
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) to adsorb to Mv1Lu cells at
4°C and then fixed and immunostained the cells with
anti-µNS serum either immediately or after incubation at
37°C for 4 or 8 h. The stained cells were analyzed by
flow cytometry to measure viral protein synthesis. A large increase in
anti-µNS serum staining was seen in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) by 4 h p.i., with
an even larger increase by 8 h p.i. (Fig.
6a). In contrast, only low levels of µNS synthesis were apparent
by 4 or 8 h p.i. in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) (Fig.
6b). These results
demonstrated that the levels of productive cell entry and/or induction
of viral protein synthesis achieved by
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) were much lower than those
achieved by pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) at the same
times.
|
1(µ1-WT) and
pr-cores±
1(µ1-HS) to form plaques on L929 cell
monolayers. In each case, we normalized the infectivity value to
reflect the efficiency of plaque formation on a per-particle basis.
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) resembled native ISVPs in
relative infectivity, with an enhancement over parent cores in excess
of 100,000 (Fig. 6c). In
contrast, pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) were only 0.01
times as infectious as
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) (Fig.
6c). This difference was
also reproducible with r-cores lacking
1 (Fig.
6c). These findings
indicate that viral particles containing µ1-HS have greatly
reduced infectivity, likely because the mutations in µ1
compromise their capacity to mediate productive cell
entry.
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS)
do not undergo the µ1 conformational change and conversion to
particles resembling cores by 2 h p.i.
In an effort to pinpoint the defect of
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) in cell entry, we allowed
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) or
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) to adsorb to CHX-treated
Mv1Lu cells; later, we immunostained the cells with MAb 10H2 or 10F6 or
anticore serum and analyzed the staining patterns by IF microscopy
(Fig. 7a to
c) or flow cytometry (Fig. 7d and
e). In cells adsorbed to either particle type and then kept
at 4°C, we observed a pattern of staining with all three
antibodies similar to that in ISVP-adsorbed cells. Specifically, 10H2
showed punctate staining concentrated at cell margins, indicating that
both pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) and
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) were bound to Mv1Lu cells
and detected by 10H2 at the cell surface (Fig.
7a). The capacity of both
particle types to bind to cells was confirmed by flow cytometric
quantitation of cell-associated fluorescence following immunostaining
with 10H2 or a virion-specific antiserum (Fig.
7d and e). In contrast to
10H2, 10F6 (Fig. 7b, d, and
e) and anticore serum (Fig.
7c to e) showed little
staining, consistent with the limited capacities of these antibodies to
immunoprecipitate pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) and
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) in vitro (Fig.
5e and f and data not
shown for anticore serum).
|
1(µ1-WT) and
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) were observed in
particle-adsorbed cells warmed to 37°C and fixed at 2
h p.i. In cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT), 10H2 showed a combination
of punctate and diffuse staining (Fig.
7a) resembling that in
ISVP-infected cells (Fig.
1b). In contrast, 10H2
staining in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) was almost entirely punctate
and was markedly concentrated in perinuclear regions (Fig.
7a). Similar punctate
staining, concentrated in perinuclear regions, was observed with
1-specific MAb 5C6 as well (data not shown). These findings
suggested different intracellular fates for particles containing
µ1-WT and µ1-HS.
To test for the intracellular
µ1 conformational change, infected cells warmed to 37°C
and fixed at 2 h p.i. were immunostained with 10F6. A
dramatic induction of 10F6 staining was observed by both IF microscopy
(Fig. 7b) and flow
cytometry (Fig. 7d) in
cells infected with pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT),
indicating that these particles undergo the µ1 conformational
change shortly after infection, as was also found with ISVPs (Fig.
1e). In contrast, little
increase in 10F6 staining was seen in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS), suggesting that the latter
particles do not undergo the µ1 conformational change to an
appreciable degree by 2 h p.i. (Fig.
7b and e).
In cells
infected with pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT), 10F6 showed a
combination of diffuse and punctate staining (Fig.
7b), as was also found
with ISVPs (Fig. 1e). The
diffuse staining provided evidence for the disassembly of
from particles and suggested that particles resembling cores are
generated in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT). Two further observations
supported that conclusion. First, a large induction in immunostaining
with anticore serum was observed by both IF microscopy and flow
cytometry (Fig. 7c and d).
Second, coimmunostaining with
2-specific MAb 7F4 and either
µ1-specific MAb 10H2 or
1-specific polyclonal
antiserum showed many punctate spots containing core protein
2
but neither the
region of µ1 (Fig.
8a) nor
1 (data not shown). In contrast to the results obtained
with pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT), little induction of
immunostaining with anticore serum was seen in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) (Fig.
7c and e), and few
punctate spots containing core proteins but lacking
(Fig.
8b) or
1 (data
not shown) were seen. Taken together, these results provided evidence
that few pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) undergo the
µ1 conformational change or conversion to particles resembling
cores by 2 h p.i.
|
1(µ1-HS).
The marked concentration of
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) in perinuclear regions (Fig.
7a and 8b) led us to
suspect that these particles are defective in penetrating into the
cytoplasm and consequently are trapped within the endocytic pathway. To
test this possibility, we infected CHX-pretreated Mv1Lu cells with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) or
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) for 2 h at
37°C and later coimmunostained the samples with
µ-specific MAb 10H2 and LAMP-1-specific antiserum
(11) (Fig.
8c and d). Confocal
microscopy revealed limited colocalization between 10H2 staining and
anti-LAMP-1 staining in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) (Fig.
8c). Much more extensive
colocalization of 10H2 staining and anti-LAMP-1 staining was observed
in cells infected with pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) (Fig.
8d) [approximately
three times the area of colocalization for
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) as for
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT)]. Furthermore,
colocalization of staining for 10H2 and anti-
1 serum in
perinuclear regions was essentially complete in cells infected with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) (data not shown). In
summary, these findings strongly suggested that ISVP-like particles
containing µ1 and
1 accumulated within LAMP-positive
compartments (i.e., late endosomes and/or lysosomes) in infections with
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS).
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS)
are defective in cellular membrane permeabilization during
entry.
The behaviors of
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) described above consistently
suggested that they are defective in membrane penetration during cell
entry. As a further test of this conclusion, we assessed the capacity
of pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) to mediate cytoplasmic
delivery of the ribonucleotoxin
-sarcin in trans, a
property previously shown to be associated with productive entry by
reovirus and rotavirus particles
(41,
46). Inhibition of
protein synthesis was used to monitor the extent of
-sarcin
entry (41). In control
series, incubation of L929 cells with ISVPs alone or
-sarcin
alone had little effect on protein synthesis, even after 2 h
at 37°C (Fig.
9). However, incubation with ISVPs plus
-sarcin led to a shutoff
of protein synthesis within 30 to 60 min p.i. at 37°C,
consistent with the entry of toxin into the cytoplasm along with
penetrating viral particles (Fig.
9). As expected,
pr-cores+
1(µ1-WT) resembled ISVPs in their
capacity to potentiate
-sarcin intoxication of cells (Fig.
9). In contrast,
pr-cores+
1(µ1-HS) caused little increase in
cellular intoxication by 2 h p.i. (Fig.
9), supporting the
conclusion that they are defective in membrane penetration during cell
entry.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ISVP* transition in vitro.
This article is a follow-up to an
earlier report on structural changes in ISVPs that precede membrane
permeabilization in vitro
(13). To the published
data, we added new in vitro evidence from immunoprecipitations with
purified particles, corroborating the conformational change in putative
membrane penetration protein µ1 and the release of adhesin
1 that accompany the ISVP
ISVP* transition.
Immunoprecipitations also revealed an increase in the exposure of core
epitopes in ISVP*s. We made use of the core recoating approach
(15,
16) to show that
particles containing a hyperstable mutant form of µ1 exhibit
none of the structural and functional changes that characterize the
ISVP
ISVP* transition in vitro. The broad in vitro effects of
this single type of mutant µ1 provided new genetic evidence
that µ1 plays a key role in the cascade of programmed
disassembly events and their functional
consequences.
Changes in ISVPs that
accompany cell entry.
In this
study, we demonstrated that features of the ISVP
ISVP*
transition in vitro attend cell entry. Structural features included the
conformational change in µ1, exposure of core epitopes, and
shedding of
1. A further structural change, release of the
fragment of µ1, is discussed below. Functional
features of the ISVP
ISVP* transitionmembrane
permeabilization and transcriptase activationwere also shown
to accompany cell entry. Membrane permeabilization was indicated by the
cytoplasmic localization of both particles resembling cores and free
in CHX-treated cells, as well as by cellular intoxication
following
-sarcin coentry in the absence of CHX. Recent
demonstrations of entering particles, resembling cores, being recruited
to cytoplasmic inclusions of reovirus nonstructural protein µNS
have provided further evidence for the cytoplasmic localization of
these particles (T. J. Broering, J. Kim, C. L.
Miller, M. L. Nibert, and J. S. L.
Parker, submitted for publication). Transcriptase activation was
indicated by the onset of viral protein synthesis in cells not treated
with CHX. As in the in vitro experiments, the consistently
"inert" behavior of recoated particles containing
hyperstable µ1 established a genetic link between the
structural and functional changes that accompanied cell entry by
particles containing
µ1-WT.
Hypothesis that ISVP*-like
particles are a transient cell entry intermediate.
We detected few particles that
corresponded directly to ISVP*s inside infected cells. Nevertheless,
previous and present findings indicated that ISVP*s are generated and
are a necessary entry intermediate (Fig.
10). (i) Conversion of ISVPs to cores in vitro, with the attendant
disassembly of
1 and µ1, must proceed through an ISVP*
intermediate (13). (ii)
ISVP*s, but not ISVPs or cores, can permeabilize erythrocyte membranes
in vitro (13). (iii)
Recoated particles containing mutant µ1 defective in
ISVP
ISVP* conversion in vitro undergo intracellular changes in
particle structure only at low levels and are defective in membrane
penetration and productive cell entry (Fig.
5 to
9) (K. Chandran,
A. L. Odegard, M. A. Agosto, K. S. Myers,
and M. L. Nibert, unpublished data). A probable explanation
for the absence of large numbers of ISVP*-like particles in infected
cells is that they are quickly converted to a
"downstream" particle form, i.e., cores, and therefore
do not accumulate (Fig.
10) (see below for
further discussion). This hypothesis suggests that
ISVP
ISVP* conversion is a rate-limiting step in cell entry by
wild-type ISVPs.
|
ISVP* transition or productive cell entry were not
observed, and ISVP-like particles localized extensively to
LAMP-positive vacuoles. We postulate that because these particles
failed to penetrate from the plasma membrane or an early endocytic
compartment, they were passed along the endocytic pathway to later,
LAMP-containing compartments, i.e., late endosomes or lysosomes
(11,
44) (Fig.
10). Alternatively, the
particles may normally penetrate from a LAMP-positive vacuole and
accumulate there if defective in penetration. Yet another possibility
is that one or more of the mutations in hyperstable µ1 affects
trafficking of the particles to particular subcellular locations. For
example, some of the entry-linked structural changes may signal
specific trafficking events within cells. Work with other mutant forms
of µ1 is needed to address these possibilities, but the present
study suggests that analysis of the subcellular localization of
particles may be a key element in future studies of membrane
penetration by reoviruses.
Nature of the
µ1 conformational change during the ISVP
ISVP*
transition.
The in vitro
immunoprecipitation results identified new reagents for tracking the
µ1 conformational change both in vitro and in cells. MAbs 4A3
and 10F6 displayed a greater affinity for µ1* (in ISVP*s) than
for µ1 (in ISVPs), whereas MAbs 10H2 and 8H6 bound to the two
conformers with similar affinities (Fig.
1). Immunoblotting and
competition ELISA experiments previously indicated that all four MAbs
bind to the
region of µ1 (residues 43 to 581) and
that 4A3, 10H2, and 8H6 specifically bind to the ß-barrel
upper domain (residues 312 to 506)
(34,
70). In contrast, the
10F6 epitope is contained within more C-terminal sequences of
that form part of an
-helical "neck" region
(residues 507 to 581)
(34,
70). We postulate that
4A3 and 10F6 detect refolding and/or exposure of sequences in the upper
parts of the µ1 trimer during the
µ1
µ1* change. Such refolded or exposed
sequences may participate directly in membrane permeabilization or may
form part of a cascade of conformational changes that mobilize
membrane-seeking regions from other parts of µ1 (see
below).
The inert behavior of recoated particles containing
hyperstable µ1 also provided clues to the nature of the
µ1
µ1* change. µ1-HS contains mutations
at two positions in the upper domain (residues 319 and 359) that, when
separately present in native or recoated particles, confer mildly
enhanced thermostability and reduced propensity to undergo the
ISVP
ISVP* transition
(35,
71; K. S. Myers
and M. L. Nibert, unpublished data). Analysis of µ1
sequence changes in panels of thermostable viral mutants revealed that
many of these changes are located in the
region at intra- or
intertrimer interfaces between the upper domains, suggesting that the
µ1
µ1* change involves some degree of trimer
dissociation (35,
71; J. K.
Middleton, M. A. Agosto, K. S. Myers, J. Yin, and
M. L. Nibert, unpublished data). A recent study suggested
that such dissociation in upper portions of the trimer may precede
wider rearrangements in µ1 involved in membrane
permeabilization, including release of the N-myristoylated
N-terminal peptide µ1N (A. L. Odegard, K. Chandran,
M. Ehrlich, T. Kirchhausen, and M. L. Nibert, unpublished
data).
Properties of the
fragment released from entering particles.
We observed by IF microscopy that the
fragment of µ1 shed from entering particles localized
to the cytoplasm and nucleus of cells at early times p.i. (Fig.
1). Immunoprecipitations
of particles from cytoplasmic lysates revealed that a large proportion
of
within the lysates remained intact but was indeed no
longer particle bound (Fig.
4). The shed form of
may resemble that in the µ1* conformer because it is
strongly recognized by MAbs 4A3 and 10F6 (Fig.
1). At odds with that
hypothesis, however, is the finding that the released form of
is less strongly recognized by MAbs 10H2 and 8H6, which
immunoprecipitate similar numbers of ISVPs and ISVP*s in vitro (Fig.
1). Thus, the released
might represent a novel conformer. To investigate this
possibility, we will isolate
from extracts of CHX-treated
cells for further analyses. We will also attempt to identify cellular
factors that may be involved in the removal and potential refolding of
µ1 regions during cell entry. A related question is whether any
proportion or region of the
fragment is embedded in the lipid
bilayer during membrane penetration and, if so, how it may be induced
to exit the bilayer to assume the diffusely distributed form seen by IF
microscopy. The postentry fates of the µ1N and
fragments of µ1
(51,
53) will also be critical
to ascertain.
The accumulation of large amounts of free
within the cytoplasm and nucleus and its persistence for several hours
p.i. suggest that this protein may have some postentry function(s) or
effect(s). One possibility is that it needs simply to be removed from
particles for subsequent steps in replication to proceed efficiently.
For example, the removal of
may permit more efficient
targeting of the resulting core to a µNS inclusion in which RNA
synthesis and assembly of new particles can occur (Broering et al.,
submitted). Another possibility is that the µ1* conformer in
entering particles is toxic, perhaps due to its enhanced hydrophobicity
(13), and must be
refolded or degraded to prevent cell injury. In fact, several studies
have indicated that the M2 genome segment encoding µ1 is a
genetic determinant of strain differences in virus-induced apoptosis
(58,
69) and that the
generation of ISVP-like particles, but not viral protein synthesis, is
required for apoptosis in some cell lines
(19,
21). Thus, an interesting
hypothesis is that a µ1 conformer either present in or released
from infecting particles may play a positive or negative role in
apoptosis. The released
1 protein may also have some postentry
function(s) or effect(s), but its predominant localization was not
extensively analyzed in this
study.
Membrane penetration mechanism. Passage of large nonenveloped particles across the cellular membrane barrier during entry is commonly thought to require localized disruption of the pl