Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, December 2003, p. 13182-13193, Vol. 77, No. 24
0022-538X/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.77.24.13182-13193.2003
Copyright © 2003, American
Society for
Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of PathologyLaboratory Medicine, University of Texas at Houston Medical School, Houston, Texas 77030,1 Myles H. Thaler Center for AIDS and Human Retrovirus Research, Department of Microbiology,2 Department of Internal Medicine, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 22908,5 Department of Microbiology and Immunology,3 Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 275994
Received 18 April 2003/ Accepted 14 July 2003
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Although they vary widely in the types of cells that they infect, rates of multiplication, genome sizes, specific proteins, and pathogenesis, the virions of alpha-, beta-, and gammaherpesviruses share a characteristic architecture in which the double-stranded DNA genome is surrounded by an icosahedral capsid, a thick tegument layer, and a lipid bilayer envelope (see references 38 and 47 for reviews). Structural studies on alphaherpesvirus (such as herpes simplex virus type 1 [HSV-1]) and betaherpesvirus (such as cytomegalovirus [CMV]) have demonstrated that the capsid, approximately 1,300 Å in diameter, is a T = 16 icosahedron with 12 pentons forming the vertices, 150 hexons forming the faces and edges, and 320 triplexes interconnecting the pentons and hexons. Central to pathogenesis and lytic HSV-1 infection is the well-coordinated assembly process leading to subviral particles (procapsids and A, B, and C capsids) and infectious virions. The A, B, and C capsids are stable enough to be readily isolated from the nuclei of HSV-1-infected cells or, alternatively, from the extracellular media after cell lysis.
Due to the lack of efficient cell culture systems, it remains difficult to obtain large quantities of purified capsids representative of different stages of viral assembly from KSHV and EBV; this problem has consequently hampered studies of the capsid assembly and structure of these viruses. Previously, KSHV A, B, and C capsids were isolated by chemical induction of latently infected BCBL-1 cells, a cell line derived from a primary effusion lymphoma (27). Three-dimensional (3D) reconstructions by electron cryomicroscopy (cryoEM) of KSHV capsids at a 24-Å resolution showed striking similarities to those of HSV-1 capsids, except for the small capsomer-interacting protein (SCIP or ORF65) (24, 51, 56). However, difficulties in obtaining adequate amounts of purified capsids for cryoEM analyses have prevented direct 3D structural comparisons of different capsid types. Reconstructions by cryoEM have been carried out only for either the "empty" A capsids or for a mixture of A, B, and C capsids, and the resolutions have been limited to 24 Å (51, 56). Consequently, knowledge about the assembly and maturation of KSHV and of the gammaherpesviruses in general remains limited and often can be inferred only from an understanding of the alphaherpesviruses.
KSHV and
rhesus monkey rhadinovirus (RRV) share a high degree of similarity with
respect to transcription programs, genomic organization, and sequences
(1,
15,
16,
45). Specifically, the
sequence similarities between their capsid proteins range between 49
and 84% (sequence identities in the range of 40 to 70%)
(35a).
Moreover, analyses of all sequences currently deposited at The Protein
Data Bank indicate that proteins with over 30% amino acid
sequence identities often possess nearly identical 3D structures,
sometimes up to the level of atomic resolution
(3). Thus, it is
reasonable to expect that the 3D structures of the RRV and KSHV capsids
are markedly similar, particularly at the molecular resolution level
(
10 to 20 Å). In contrast to KSHV, however, RRV grows to
high titers in rhesus fibroblasts after de novo infection in cultures,
facilitating the isolation of highly purified preparations of each of
the capsid species
(35a). As a result, RRV
provides an attractive system for systematic studies of
gammaherpesvirus structure and assembly.
In this study, we subjected purified RRV A, B, and C capsids to cryoEM structural analyses. Direct 3D structural comparisons of the A, B, and C capsids revealed differences in the penton channels and interiors of the capsids, suggested functional roles of the penton channels during capsid maturation, and indicated that gammaherpesvirus capsids mature in a pathway similar to that of capsids of HSV-1, the prototype of the alphaherpesvirus subfamily. In addition, we have determined the RRV A capsid structure to a 15-Å resolution, the highest to date for a gammaherpesvirus particle, and have found major structural variations in triplexes situated at quasi-equivalent positions. Moreover, the Ta triplex and structures located at the outer regions of the capsid, where SCIP binds, exhibit features significantly different from those observed in alpha- and betaherpesvirus capsids. This structural disparity suggests that SCIP and the triplex, together with tegument and envelope proteins, confer structural and potentially functional specificities to alpha-, beta-, and gammaherpesviruses.
|
|
|---|
CryoEM and 3D
reconstruction.
CryoEM
imaging of RRV capsids was performed as described previously
(56). Briefly, a
3-µl aliquot of purified RRV capsids was applied to a
Quantifoil R 2/1 grid (Quantifoil Micro Tools Gmbh, Jena, Germany),
quickly blotted with filter paper, and plunged into liquid
nitrogen-cooled ethane so that the capsid particles were embedded in a
thin layer of vitreous ice across the holes of the supporting film.
Images were recorded at a magnification of x30,000 and 100 kV
in a JEOL 1200 electron cryomicroscope equipped with a liquid
nitrogen-cooled cryospecimen holder (Gatan Inc., Pleasanton, Calif.) by
using an electron dose of
10
electrons/Å2/micrograph. Focal pairs of cryoEM
micrographs were recorded, with the first, close-to-focus micrograph
aimed at
1.0 µm under focus and the second,
far-from-focus micrograph aimed at
2 µm under
focus.
Selected micrographs in the proper defocus range and without apparent specimen drift and charging were digitized on a Zeiss SCAI microdensitometer (Z/I Imaging, Huntsville, Ala.) by using a step size equivalent to 4.67 Å/pixel on the specimen. Data processing and visualization were carried out with SGI Octane workstations and an Origin 300 server (Silicon Graphics, Inc.) by using Fourier common-lines-based procedures implemented in the IMIRS package as previously described (21, 62). The defocus values of the micrographs were determined by using the incoherently averaged Fourier transforms of particle images (61). The orientation and center estimation and refinement were based on the focal-pair method (58). In this method, the particles from the far-from-focus micrographs were used to determine the initial orientation parameters of the corresponding particles from the close-to-focus micrographs, which were subsequently refined. The final 3D reconstructions were generated by merging only the close-to-focus particles (defocus values ranging from 0.8 to 2.1 µm) by using the Fourier-Bessel synthesis method (13) with correction of the contrast transfer function (57). The effective resolution was based on the criterion of the Fourier shell correlation coefficient being larger than 0.5 between two independent reconstructions from arbitrarily split data sets. 3D visualization was carried out by using Iris Explorer (NAG Inc., Downers Grove, Ill.) with custom-designed modules (17). All structures were displayed at a contour level of 1 standard deviation above the average density.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Coomassie
blue-stained gel of purified RRV A, B, and C capsids. RRV A, B, and C
capsids were separated by velocity sedimentation (see Materials and
Methods). Fractions containing the purest populations of A, B, and C
capsids were subjected to SDS-PAGE and visualized by staining with
Simply Blue Safe Stain (Invitrogen). Arrows indicate the bands of the
five main capsid-associated proteins. The faint bands between MCP and
TRI-1 are contaminating cellular proteins because they were also
present in the density gradient fractions containing no capsids. The
stoichiometry of TRI-1 and TRI-2, as estimated from the stain densities
in the C capsid lane, was approximately
1:2.
|
600 Å (Fig.
2B). The interior of the C
capsids (Fig. 2C) is the
most electron opaque of the three types of capsids, with internal
densities completely obscuring the boundary of the internal capsid
shell that, in contrast, is readily apparent in both the A and the B
capsids. These electron-opaque internal densities inside the C capsids
had the characteristic "fingerprint" appearance when
the micrographs were recorded under close-to-focus conditions (Fig.
2C, insets), suggesting
the presence of densely packaged double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), as also
reported for HSV-1 C capsids
(5).
![]() View larger version (158K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. CryoEM
micrographs of RRV capsids. Purified RRV A capsids (A), B capsids (B),
and C capsids (C) were embedded in vitreous ice and
subsequently imaged in a JEOL 1200 electron cryomicroscope operated at
100 kV. The A capsid appears empty, the B capsid contains an inner
core, and the C capsid has a striated, fingerprint appearance that
results from the presence of the densely packaged dsDNA genome, which
can be readily recognized in the close-to-focus particle images shown
in the insets. All three capsid types have a polyhedral shape with
characteristic capsomer protrusions, similar to those seen in HSV-1 and
human
CMV.
|
![]() View larger version (86K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Structural
comparisons of RRV A, B, and C capsids at 27-Å resolution. The 3D
maps are colored according to particle radius, such that the capsid
floor is in aquamarine, the triplexes are in green, the middle domains
of the pentons and hexons are in yellow, and the upper domains of the
pentons and hexons are in purple. (A) Shaded surface
representations of RRV capsids viewed along an icosahedral threefold
axis. The A (left), B (middle), and C (right) capsids have almost
identical surface features, each composed of 12 pentons (denoted by 5),
150 hexons (denoted by H), and 320 triplexes (denoted by T) arranged on
a T=16 icosahedral lattice. (B) Cutaway views of RRV
capsids viewed along a threefold axis, revealing the density
differences inside the capsid shell. The A capsid is almost empty. The
B capsid contains a 600-Å-diameter core of disordered densities
arranged in three distinct radial regions: inner (I), middle (M), and
outer (O). The C capsid is full of densities attributed to the densely
packaged dsDNA genome. (C and D) Comparisons of penton channels. The
close-up top views along the fivefold axis (C) of the
computationally extracted pentons and the cutaway side views
(D) reveal that the penton channels in the A and C capsids
are open, while that in the B capsid is shut
(arrow).
|
![]() View larger version (67K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Packaging
of dsDNA inside the C capsid. (A) A 100-Å-thick central
slice extracted from the 21-Å resolution of the C capsid
reconstruction is shown along a twofold axis. The slice exhibits
high-density features organized as multiple spherical shells inside the
inner surface of the capsid floor. At least six concentric shells can
be distinguished before the pattern becomes indistinct toward the
center of the capsid. (B) Radial density
distribution of the C capsid obtained by spherically averaging the C
capsid reconstruction. It is evident that the distance between
neighboring peaks is about 25 Å. "2",
"3", and "5" represent icosahedral 2-,
3-, and 5-fold
axes.
|
22 Å in
diameter.
![]() View larger version (89K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. RRV
A capsid structure and subunit interactions at 15-Å resolution.
See the legend to Fig. 3
for an explanation of color coding. (A) Shaded surface
representation of the 3D map of the A capsid, reconstructed from 3,824
particles, as viewed along a twofold axis. Three pentons (5), three
structurally unique hexons (P, E, and C), and six triplexes (Ta, Tb,
Tc, Td, Te, and Tf, following the designations used for HSV-1) are
labeled. (B) Top, tilt, and side views of a penton, an E
hexon, and a Td triplex, computationally extracted from the A capsid
reconstruction shownin panel A. The subunits
of both the penton and the hexon have similar elongated shapes. The
three legs of the Td triplex are indicated by L1, L2, and L3. The three
legs of the triplex are anchored to the capsid floor and interact with
adjacent hexons and pentons with head (h) and tail (t) protrusions,
respectively. (C) Side views of regions containing one penton
subunit or one hexon subunit and its associated triplex (Ta or Td,
respectively), computationally extracted from the A capsid
reconstruction shown in panel A. The upper (u), middle (m), lower (l),
and floor (f) domains of the penton or hexon subunits are labeled. The
arrowheads indicate a density protrusion that forms a constriction
inside the hexon channel and a corresponding density protrusion that
does not form a constriction inside the penton channel. Triplex legs
(L1, L2, and L3) connected to the floor domain of MCP are indicated;
only L1 is connected in Ta. The red dotted lines on the lower and floor
domains illustrate the angles between the two domains. The
superposition of the penton (contour lines) and hexon (red
semitransparent) subunits reveals an extra density (arrow) attached to
the upper domain of each hexon subunit; this density could be
attributed to SCIP. This putative SCIP density is structurally distinct
from its homolog in HSV-1, the horn-shaped VP26
(52,
62,
64) (cf. this figure with
Fig. 5D and F in reference
56). "2"
and "5" indicate icosahedral 2- and 5-fold
axes.
|
Because icosahedral symmetry was imposed in our 3D reconstruction, the detailed structural features of the DNA densities revealed in our 3D reconstruction are difficult to interpret. However, the structural features of the DNA densities in the regions near the capsid floor may have some level of symmetry, at least at a low resolution, as a result of interactions with the capsid shell proteins. Consistent with this notion, we found that the DNA densities closer to the capsid floor are more ordered than those near the capsid center (Fig. 4A). The DNA layers are not perfectly spherical but rather are angular or polyhedral, adopting a shape that loosely parallels that of the surrounding capsid floor. Thus, it seems that the capsid floor may play an important structural role as a DNA packaging scaffold or constraint. This constraint maintains the energetically unfavorable organization of the linear dsDNA genome within the capsid. In this regard, it is relevant to point out that the outermost layer of dsDNA exhibits numerous interactions with the overlying floor domains of MCP molecules, including the strongest of these near the fivefold axes and the less prominent of these near the three- and twofold axes (Fig. 4A). It is conceivable that these interactions exert considerable constraints on the first shell of packaged DNA to adapt the same polyhedral shape as the inner floor of the capsid (Fig. 4A). The polyhedral contour continues within the second DNA shell and beyond and only gradually disappears within the sixth shell. This mirroring of the layers of DNA strands probably reflects the close packaging of the viral genome, which is constrained by the limited space of the rigid capsid (see Discussion).
Protein subunits on the capsid shell. Among our preparations, the A capsids were the most abundant capsid species and were thus reconstructed to the highest resolution among the three capsid forms. From 3,824 particles, the final effective resolution of the A capsid reconstruction reached 15 Å, the best resolution ever achieved for a gammaherpesvirus capsid (Fig. 5A). This 15-Å structure has allowed us to dissect individual structural components computationally for more detailed analyses (Fig. 5B) and comparisons with the capsid structures of other herpesviruses. Whereas subunits computationally extracted from a penton and an E hexon, together with its associated triplex, have similar elongated overall shapes, with upper, middle, lower, and floor domains, there were some minor differences between the penton and the hexon subunits (Fig. 5C). The most dramatic of these differences is that the angles between the floor domains and the long axes of the penton and hexon subunits are 110° and 90°, respectively. Consequently, the penton is slightly longer than the hexon (162 versus 156 Å) (Fig. 5C). These structural changes in the penton and the hexon in RRV MCP were also observed in HSV-1 (see Fig. 5D and F in reference 56), although notable differences between the MCP molecules of HSV-1 and RRV were also apparent (Fig. 6).
![]() View larger version (97K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Structural
differences between RRV and HSV-1 capsids. A region encompassing one
penton subunit and one triplex (Ta) was computationally extracted from
the RRV A capsid reconstruction at 15-Å resolution and from an
HSV-1 capsid reconstruction filtered to the same resolution from an
8.5-Å map (60). The
maps were rotated for display such that the fivefold axis is
approximately parallel to the longer edge of the page, and the views in
the top and bottom rows are related to each other by an
130° rotation about this axis. In the superposition
views (right), the HSV-1 map is shown as wire frames. In both RRV and
HSV-1, the Ta triplex interacts with MCP through the L1 leg connected
to the MCP floor domain and through a small link to the MCP middle
domain; these connections are indicated by asterisks. The major
differences between the RRV and HSV-1 structures are indicated,
including the interactions of triplex Ta with the middle domain of the
penton subunit (arrowhead) and with the floor of the capsid (arrows) in
HSV-1 and the absence of these interactions in RRV. The upper domain of
the RRV capsid is square shaped and has an extra density (thin arrow in
bottom row), while that of the HSV-1 penton subunit is diamond shaped
(open arrow in bottom row). The HSV-1 penton subunit appears tilted
slightly more toward the fivefold
axis.
|
Each triplex has a pyramidal shape with three legs pointing toward the capsid floor; each of the legs makes variable numbers of contacts with the capsid floor (Fig. 5B, right, and Fig. 5C). The three legs are positioned around a small hole on the capsid floor. One of these legs (L3 in Fig. 5B) extends to form the bulk of the upper domain of each triplex and remains continuous even when the map is displayed at a high density threshold (data not shown). The other two legs (L1 and L2 in Fig. 5B) resemble each other and intertwine under the upper domain of the triplex. Except for Tf, the upper domain of each triplex has two protrusions, one "head" and one "tail" (Fig. 5B, right), extending sideways to connect with the middle and the lower domains of adjacent capsomer subunits, respectively. Although the triplexes have similar overall structures, there are some minor differences among them because of their different (or quasi-equivalent) local environments. Triplex Tf is located at the threefold axis, thus having a perfect threefold symmetric shape. Ta differs from Tb, Tc, Td, and Te in that two of its three legs (L2 and L3) are completely disconnected from the capsid floor (Fig. 5A and C).
|
|
|---|
Whether gammaherpesviruses use a similar viral assembly mechanism and maturation pathway remained hitherto unaddressed, owing to difficulties in isolating adequate amounts of the different types of KSHV and EBV capsids for biochemical and structural characterization. The cryoEM images of the RRV A, B, and C capsids (Fig. 2) closely resemble those of HSV-1 (5, 44, 59, 64) and human CMV (8), members of the alpha- and betaherpesvirus subfamilies, respectively. As expected, the RRV capsids are also similar to those of KSHV in negative-stain electron microscopy (27) and cryoEM (51, 56) and in chemical compositions (35a). The similarity of RRV and alphaherpesvirus capsids in both structural organization and chemical compositions (35a) suggests that gammaherpesvirus capsid assembly and maturation probably proceed in a manner similar to that in alphaherpesviruses.
The hallmarks of the RRV B capsid reconstruction resemble those observed in the HSV-1 B capsid in many aspects. First, the RRV scaffolding core exhibits no significant icosahedral symmetry, as judged from the poor resolution of the core densities, but its radial density distribution suggests that it can be divided into three sublayers, similar to those of the scaffolding core in HSV-1 (50). Such a structure may have an extended and flexible conformation, which would account for the unresolved structure in our reconstructions of this region inside the capsid. This notion is consistent with the proposal that both the middle and N-terminal domains of SCAF promote self-aggregation within the B capsids to form the middle and inner scaffold layers, respectively, as suggested for the HSV-1 scaffolding protein (28, 31). The outer layer of the scaffold appears to have some disordered densities that directly extend from or are linked to the middle layer by a more flexible linker. The high flexibility and mobility of the outer layer may play a critical role in allowing the symmetrically arranged MCP to interact with the nonsymmetric scaffold to define the size and shape of the capsid during the early stages of capsid assembly.
In addition to presenting direct structural evidence demonstrating a similar capsid assembly pathway shared by gammaherpesvirus and alphaherpesvirus capsids, our study represents the first time that the 3D structures of all three types of herpesvirus capsids were systematically compared at identical resolutions. This work has allowed the distinction of subtle structural differences, such as penton channel configurations, which were not addressed previously. Moreover, the structure of the RRV A capsid at a 15-Å resolution is the highest-resolution structure achieved for a gammaherpesvirus capsid to date, and the data have allowed the identification of structural features unique to gammaherpesvirus capsids (see below) that could not be seen in the previously published 24-Å structures of KSHV capsids (51, 56).
Structural comparisons of capsid proteins of alpha-, beta-, and gammaherpesviruses. The 15-Å resolution of the RRV A capsid structure in the present study revealed that penton and hexon subunits have a nearly identical elongated shape that is dimensionally similar to those of HSV-1 and human CMV. The correlation of the biochemical and structural results suggests that the pentons and hexons of the RRV capsids are composed of five and six copies of MCP, respectively. In HSV-1 and KSHV, the smallest capsid protein has been shown to selectively bind to the hexon tips only (24, 52, 62, 64). Our reconstruction of the RRV A capsid suggests that RRV SCIP also binds to the hexon subunit but its presence or absence on pentons is less clear as illustrated in the comparison with HSV-1 and RRV penton subunit in Fig. 6 and its contour is much less prominent than its counterparts in HSV-1 and is almost unidentifiable at lower resolutions (cf. Fig. 5C and Fig. 5D and F in reference 56). This difference reinforces the observation that the most distinguishing structural characteristics of gammaherpesvirus capsids, compared with alpha- and betaherpesvirus capsids, lie at the distal ends of the pentons and hexons, the putative binding site(s) for SCIP, and the triplexes surrounding the pentons (i.e., Ta). This observation suggests possible differences in the association of the capsids with overlying tegument proteins and is reminiscent of such differences between human CMV and HSV-1 (11, 57). The reconstruction of the intact human CMV particles revealed a layer of highly organized filamentous densities of tegument proteins attached to the pentons, hexons, and triplexes of the underlying nucleocapsid (11). This extensive tegument-capsid association exhibited major differences from that of HSV-1, whose tegument proteins bind only to pentons and the surrounding triplexes (57). These structural disparities suggest that SCIP (or its homologs in other herpesvirus subfamilies) and some triplexes, together with tegument and glycoproteins, confer structural and functional specificities in alpha-, beta-, and gammaherpesviruses. Indeed, it has been shown that the human CMV UL48.5-encoded SCIP is essential for human CMV infection in vivo (6), but its HSV-1 counterpart, VP26, is dispensable for HSV-1 infection (10, 14).
In HSV-1, triplexes are heterotrimers composed of one copy of VP19C and two copies of VP23 (32, 34, 46, 64). SDS-PAGE revealed that the RRV capsids have two homologous proteins, TRI-1 and TRI-2, whose stain intensities on SDS-PAGE gels are consistent with a 1:2 molar ratio (Fig. 1) (35a). The 15-Å RRV A capsid reconstruction reveals that two of the three legs in each triplex are similar, except for Tf (Fig. 5A and C), which is located on the threefold axis; this organization is analogous to that of alpha- and betaherpesviruses, indicating that the overall structure of the triplexes is preserved across different herpesviruses. Thus, as with HSV-1, each RRV triplex is likely also composed of heterotrimers with one copy of TRI-1 and two copies of TRI-2, the homologs of VP19C and VP23, respectively. Except for the symmetric Tf and structurally unique Ta (see below), two (L1 and L2 in Fig. 5B) of the three legs are similar in each RRV triplex and can be attributed to be a TRI-2 dimer. The third leg (L3 in Fig. 5B) probably corresponds to a TRI-1 monomer. Similar heterotriplexes are present in KSHV (27, 56). In RRV, however, the six triplexes located at geometrically unique positions (and thus different environments) within an asymmetric unit of the capsid exhibit substantially more differences in their structures than those in HSV-1 capsids reported at similar resolution (59). In particular, RRV triplex Ta exhibits much less extensive interactions with its adjacent penton MCP than HSV-1 triplex Ta (Fig. 6).
Functional implications of the channels. The functional implications of the different states of the penton channels in the different capsid types are intriguing. During the process of gammaherpesvirus lytic replication, viral materials, such as viral DNA and the proteolytically cleaved scaffolding proteins, have to be transferred into and out of the preformed capsids, respectively, through existing channels or pores in the capsids. Our structure revealed that the RRV capsids have three types of channels or pores: the small hole underneath the triplex, the penton channel and the hexon channel. It is plausible that SCAF molecules exit through some of these channels after their cleavage. Our structures clearly show that the penton channel is closed in RRV B capsids but open in A and C capsids (Fig. 3C and D). Because of the lack of systematic comparisons of the structures of the A, B, and C capsids in alpha- and betaherpesviruses, as conducted in this study, a clear distinction between their channels has not been provided. The only published HSV-1 C capsid reconstruction did not resolve the penton channel, probably due to the relatively low resolution of the 3D reconstruction (5). However, the DNA-containing nucleocapsid in the intact HSV-1 virion has a closed penton channel (57).
Recent studies with HSV-1 have demonstrated that, as with many bacteriophages, the linear viral genome is likely to enter at a unique vertex known as the portal complex (33). Because our reconstructions of the RRV capsid structures do not take into account such asymmetry and, instead, treat all 12 vertices equally, we cannot rule out the possibility that the portal complex in the B capsid has an open channel for DNA entry, while the other 11 penton channels adopt a closed conformation, or that the closed penton channel may simply be an artifact arising from the averaging of 11 slightly open penton channels with a closed portal. Nevertheless, the functional significance of the closed penton channels in the B capsid reconstruction is probably related to retention of the scaffolding proteins rather than to the specific penton or portal complex used for packaging genome DNA. It is conceivable that if penton channels were indeed the release path of the cleaved scaffolding protein, they would be open to allow the completion of this process leading to the transformation from B to C capsid (after successful DNA encapsidation) or A capsid (after loss of DNA or a scaffolding protein). It is attractive to speculate that the encapsidation of DNA genome is coupled with the release of the scaffolding proteins. Thus, the functional role of a closed penton channel in the B capsid might be to prevent the premature release of the scaffolding proteins. Whether the penton channels in the nucleocapsid within the RRV virion remain open is yet to be seen. The nucleocapsid within the HSV-1 virion, however, has closed penton channels (57). Therefore, the open penton channels in the RRV C capsid indicate that any closure of the penton channels does not take place immediately after the completion of scaffolding proteins release and DNA encapsidation. After the completion of DNA packaging, closure of the open penton channels would protect the inner DNA from premature release. The mechanism for regulating the penton channel opening and closure is not known and is probably related to the differences in surface-charge properties, as reported recently for HSV-1 penton and hexon channels (7). In virions, it is also possible that this process of channel closing may involve one or more tegument proteins and may take place during the tegumentation period, when the C capsid further matures into the infectious virion. In addition, our 21-Å resolution C capsid reconstruction revealed that the outer layers of the packaged DNA have strongest connections with the inner face of the capsid floor around pentons.
Packaging of viral DNA in
different herpesviruses.
Previous studies of HSV-1 have shown
that the genomic DNA within the nucleocapsid inside a virion is closely
packaged into multiple shells of regularly spaced densities, with 26
Å between adjacent DNA duplexes
(57). The central slice
and radial density plot in Fig.
4 indicate that the RRV C
capsid has an almost identical pattern of DNA organization, although
slightly more compact, with a 25-Å interduplex distance. Although
RRV capsids, like KSHV capsids, have nearly the same diameter as HSV-1
capsids (1250 Å), RRV has a slightly larger genome size than
HSV-1,
165 and 153 kb, respectively
(1,
20,
37,
45). Therefore, the
smaller interduplex distance may merely reflect the need to compact
this greater amount of DNA into the same volume within the capsid.
Buttressing this interpretation, human CMV has the largest genome (225
kb) of all human herpesviruses but has a capsid that is only slightly
larger (1,300-Å diameter), and its DNA was shown to be packaged
with an interduplex distance of only 23 Å
(4). Based on the
interduplex spacing and the genome sizes, we estimated that the closely
packaged DNA genomes of HSV-1, RRV, and human CMV would occupy total
volumes of 3.52 x 108, 3.51 x
108, and 4.05 x 108Å3,
respectively (volume equals interstrand distance squared times the
length of DNA, where the length of DNA is the number of base pairs
times [3.4 Å/base pair]). These volumes would, in turn,
occupy approximately 92, 92, and 90% of the total available
spaces inside the HSV-1, RRV, and human CMV capsids, as estimated on
the basis of their inner diameters of 900, 900, and 950 Å,
respectively. The 23- to 26-Å packaging of strands of
herpesviruses dsDNA is very close to the 20-Å diameter of B-type
dsDNA, suggesting that herpesvirus genomes are packaged as
"naked" DNA without any bound histone-like basic
proteins. In this regard, SDS-PAGE analyses demonstrated that the A
capsids and C capsids of either HSV-1 or RRV have the same protein
compositions (5,
35a). In the absence of
histone-like proteins, close packaging of naked DNA would lead to a
potentially strong electrostatic repulsion between the juxtaposed
negatively charged DNA duplexes. This, in turn, would make the
packaging of DNA into B capsid energetically unfavorable, supporting
the need for an energy-dependent DNA packaging machinery, such as the
bacteriophage-like connector recently reported in HSV-1 capsids
(33). Even so, it is
conceivable that the negative charges of DNA may at least be partially
neutralized by binding spermidine or some other heretofore undiscovered
small basic molecules to reduce the strong electrostatic
repulsion.
We thank Wah Chiu and Frazer Rixon for the use of HSV-1 data and Pierrette Lo for careful reading of the manuscript.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»