Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, November 2003, p. 12011-12021, Vol. 77, No. 22
0022-538X/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.77.22.12011-12021.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Biochemistry, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Piscataway, New Jersey 08854
Received 1 July 2003/ Accepted 6 August 2003
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Murine leukemia viruses (MuLVs) have adopted various strategies to control virus-cell and cell-cell fusion. Several key elements within the envelope (Env) surface (SU) and transmembrane (TM) proteins have been identified. Mutation of SU N-terminal amino acid H41 (numbering from the signal peptide) in Moloney-MuLV (M-MuLV) or H36 (numbering from the signal peptide) in amphotropic 4070A MuLV abolishes virus-cell and cell-cell fusion events (2, 19, 48). Elements within the proline-rich region (PRR) mediate conformational changes in SU and TM after receptor binding and affect syncytium formation (17). The fusion peptide, which is inserted into the host cell membrane during viral entry, is located at the N terminus of TM. By analogy to the influenza virus protein hemagglutinin, this domain is presumed to be buried in early conformations of the viral envelope (Env) protein, suggesting that its exposure is a controlled event. The 16 C-terminal amino acids of TM, named the R-peptide, act as a negative regulator of fusion. Removal of the R-peptide by the viral-encoded protease (Pr) activates viral fusion (38, 39).
Variations in the interaction of the viral Env with the host-cell receptor affect viral infectivity and fusion. Low expression levels of hemagglutinin (8, 9) and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope proteins (20) have been shown to down-regulate fusion. For HIV-1, it has been proposed that threshold amounts of receptor and coreceptor molecules are required to initiate fusion (15, 37). In nonmurine cells with high levels of receptor, both wild-type (WT) ecotropic MuLV and a variant, TR1.3, are fusogenic. However, under conditions where receptor expression is limited, only the TR1.3 variant is fusogenic (7). This TR1.3 neuropathogenic MuLV encodes the point mutation W102G (30). W102 forms a receptor-binding pocket with S84 and D86 within the receptor-binding domain (RBD) of Fr57-MuLV (10). Thus, mutations affecting Env-receptor binding can alter cell-cell fusion.
In the present study, the role of a point mutation, G541R, in regulating fusion is analyzed. G541 is located within the TM ectodomain, N-terminal to the intramolecular cysteine bond. This position was found mutated in one WT 4070A and three independent populations of chimeric viruses (EA6 and EA7) (31). In chimeric Env proteins bearing the ecotropic RBD and an amphotropic TM protein, G541R suppressed syncytia with rat XC cells and syncytia induced by the absence of R-peptide in NIH 3T3 cells. Reconstruction of G541R within virus lacking R-peptide improved virus viability and virus titer. The G541R substitution in the TM ectodomain leads to decreased levels of amphotropic Env expression at the cell surface and on the virus. These studies provide insights into the mechanism utilized by MuLV to balance cytopathogenicity and virulence and preserve its intrinsic entry characteristics.
|
|
|---|
Plasmids and DNA manipulations. Chimeric proviral DNA clones (31) and plasmid pNCA-C (13) were as previously described. pNCA-C is an infectious provirus that expresses the gag, pol, and env gene products of the ecotropic Mo-MuLV. Plasmids pHIT 123, pHIT 456, and pHIT 111, expressing the Mo-MuLV Env, 4070A Env, and lacZ genes, respectively, were previously described (29, 44, 45). The pHIT 456/R- construct was generated by replacement of the 172-bp ClaI-NheI fragment from pHIT 123/R- (45).
Second-site changes detected in EA6 viral populations were reconstructed within the EA6 proviral backbone. The single mutations N261I and E311V and the double mutation N261I/E311V were each cloned as previously described (28). The double mutant N261I/G541R was generated by the ligation of the EA6 parental SfiI-ClaI 8,945-bp fragment with the 782-bp HindIII-ClaI and SfiI-HindIII 1,360-bp fragments from the appropriate EA6 populations. The single mutant G541R was generated by the ligation of the 782-bp HindIII-ClaI fragment from the N261I/G541R mutant with the 1,360-bp SfiI-HindIII and 8,945-bp SfiI-ClaI fragments from the EA6 parental DNA. The triple mutant N261I/E311V/G541R was generated by the ligation of the 782-bp HindIII-ClaI fragment from the N261I/G541R clone, the 1,360-bp SfiI-HindIII fragment from the N261I/E311V clone, and the 8,945-bp SfiI-ClaI fragment from parental EA6 DNA.
G541R was reconstructed into pHIT 456 by ligation of the 527-bp XhoI-HindIII fragment from 4070A-pNCA-Am (13), the 953-bp HindIII-NheI fragment from pNCA-C/EA6/G541R, and the 7,800-bp XhoI-NheI fragment from pHIT 456. The G541R/R-minus clone was constructed by the ligation of the 1,308-bp XhoI-ClaI fragment from pHIT 456/G541R with the ClaI-NheI R- fragment and the 7,800-bp XhoI-NheI fragment from pHIT 456. The parental EA6 and mutants were introduced into pHIT 123 by exchanging the Mo-MuLV 2,100-bp PmlI-NheI fragment. The corresponding R-minus constructs were made by combining the PmlI-ClaI fragment from each respective env clone with the 400-bp ClaI-NheI fragment derived from pHIT123/R- and the 2,160-bp PmlI-NheI fragment from pHIT123.
G552R was introduced into the Mo-MuLV envelope by an overlapping PCR mutagenesis scheme using 2.5 U of Pfu polymerase (Stratagene). The 650-bp HpaI-ClaI fragment from the G552R PCR product was substituted into pNCA-C (13) to generate pNCA-C/G552R. The 2,160-bp PmlI-NheI fragment of pNCA-C/G552R was substituted into pHIT 123 to generate pHIT 123/G552R. The 1,944-bp PmlI-ClaI fragment of the pNCA-C/G552R clone was substituted into pHIT 123 to generate the pHIT 123/G552/R- clone. The mutation N261I was introduced into the E311V/pNCA-C clone containing a SalI site at bp 6745 to 6750 (28) by replacement of the 927-bp PmlI-DraIII fragment with the same fragment from the EA6/N261I/pNCA-C clone (28). The triple combination N261I, E311V, and G552R was introduced into pHIT 123 by replacement of the 1,000-bp PmlI-SalI fragment of either the G552R/pHIT clone or the G552R/pHIT/R- clone with the same fragment from the N261I/E311V/pNCA-C clone. DNAs were purified by CsCl2 banding prior to use in transfections.
Transfections. Transfections of Env constructs, within the plasmid pHIT 123 backbone, into D17/gag-pol cells were performed as previously described for D17 cells using Lipofectamine reagents (Invitrogen) (29). For virus titers, pHIT 111 was cotransfected along with each env plasmid. NIH 3T3 cells were transfected using Lipofectamine in the presence of medium containing 10% serum and 0.1 mM nonessential amino acids (Invitrogen) per the manufacturer's directions. At 24 h posttransfection, cells were treated with 10 mM sodium butyrate for 6 to 8 h to enhance expression levels of Env (44). Sodium butyrate was subsequently replaced with cell maintenance medium.
Titer determinations of envelope proteins. Transiently expressed virus was collected overnight between 36 and 48 h posttransfection, passed through an acrodisc 0.45-µm-pore-size filter, applied to D17/pJET cells in the presence of 8 µg of Polybrene/ml for 2 h at 37°C, and subsequently replaced with cell maintenance medium. At 48 h postinfection, cells were stained for lacZ expression as previously described (31).
Syncytium assays. At 48 h posttransfection of Env expression plasmids (pHIT 123 based), D17-based env-expressing cells were UV irradiated for 30 s and overlaid with rat XC cells at 37°C as previously described (14). Syncytia containing 2 nuclei or >4 nuclei were quantitated in a microscopic field having an area of 13.86 mm2; data below in Tables 1 to 4 represent the mean ± standard deviation for syncytia in at least 10 fields for each independent assay.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Viral titers and 3T3 syncytium characteristics of EA6/R- Env
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 4. Viral titers and syncytium characteristics of M-MuLV Env's
|
Virus was alternatively purified by centrifugation of 1-ml aliquots of culture supernatants through 0.2 ml of 20% sucrose in 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.5), 1 mM EDTA, 50 mM NaCl (TEN) at 16,000 x g (46). Viral proteins were analyzed by Western blotting subsequent to SDS-PAGE analysis and visualized by chemiluminescence (Pierce). The resultant polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membranes were cut into two pieces, consisting of proteins migrating as 31 kDa and higher molecular masses and 31 kDa and lower molecular masses. PVDF membranes with viral proteins of 31 kDa and higher molecular masses were incubated with antibodies to the SU Env protein. Duplicate panels of the same viral preparations were generated on a single gel to allow for analysis using two independent SU-specific antibodies. Posttransfer, the PVDF filter was cut vertically to separate the two panels and horizontally using the 45-kDa protein standard for analysis of anti-SU versus anti-CA antibodies. Viral SU was either detected with SU monoclonal antibody 83A25 (11) and secondary antibody goat anti-rat immunoglobulin G (IgG; Pierce; diluted 1:100,000) or using SU polyclonal 80S-019 (Microbiological Associates) and secondary rabbit anti-goat IgG (Pierce; diluted 1:100,000). PVDF membranes with viral proteins of 31 kDa and lower were incubated with CA polyclonal antibody (079-287) and secondary antibody goat anti-rabbit IgG (Pierce; diluted 1:100,000).
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (19K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Schematic of viral populations isolated with the G541R TM mutation. Viral populations of 4070A and chimeric EA6 and EA7 were isolated with second-site changes in the TM ectodomain residue G541R after multiple passages through canine D17 and D17/pJET cells. Amino acid numbering begins with the initiation methionine. Chimeric junctions 6 and 7 are as previously described (31); amino acid junctions correspond to the ecotropic residue and amphotropic residue. Additional second-site changes isolated in these populations are noted. For comparison, a schematic of M-MuLV is shown at the top and denotes the arrangement of variable domains VRA, VRC, VRB, and the PRR within the SU protein, as well as the positions of the two cysteine residues which comprise the CWLC motif. The amino acid sequence in the ectodomain of TM in the vicinity of 4070A residue G541 is noted, and it is conserved between M-MuLV and 4070A MuLV.
|
G541R affects cell-cell fusion events. Removal of the R-peptide from the TM protein has been shown to activate fusion for both ecotropic and amphotropic MuLV envelope proteins (38, 39). Enhanced cell-cell fusion can be observed when R-minus Env proteins are directly expressed in NIH 3T3 cells. WT M-MuLV does not induce syncytia in NIH 3T3 cells (Fig. 2C), while very large syncytia are observed for the R-minus M-MuLV control (Fig. 2B). The expression of EA6 chimeric Env's bearing the G541R mutation within an R-minus backbone led to the visualization of a remarkable phenotype, the suppression of syncytia. EA6 Env bearing the N261I/E311V mutations within the R-minus backbone resulted in large multinucleated cells (Fig. 2E). In contrast, EA6/R- virus bearing N261I/E311V plus G541R resulted in no syncytia, even in the absence of R-peptide (Fig. 2F).
![]() View larger version (139K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Suppressive effects of G541R in the R-minus Env backbone. DNA corresponding to R- Env was transiently transfected in NIH 3T3 cells. At 48 h posttransfection, syncytia were visualized by hematoxylin staining. (A to C) Mock and WT M-MuLV controls. (D to F) Syncytia for Env mutants in the EA6/R- backbone. In all panels (A to F), virus titers (lacz+ IFU) of M-MuLV controls and R- Env's transiently expressed in D17/gag-pol cells, representative of one assay, are shown at the top of each syncytia panel.
|
The combination of E311V plus G541R within EA6/R- resulted in a modest titer (102 IFU/ml); the presence of G541R again decreased the size and number of the syncytia present compared to E311V alone.
G541R suppresses syncytia with rat XC cells. The EA6 chimera encodes the ecotropic RBD, a key determinant for formation of syncytia with XC cells (31). Chimeric viral Env's (R+) were transiently expressed in a D17/gag-pol cell line and analyzed for cell-cell fusion following coculturing with rat XC cells. Table 2 summarizes resultant virus titers (in IFU per milliliter) and quantification of syncytia. The control WT M-MuLV Env results in numerous large, multinucleated cells within each field (between 23.7 and 31.2). Parental EA6 exhibits a low number of syncytia, consistent with a lack of detectable virus titer.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Viral titers and XC syncytium characteristics of EA6/R+ Env's
|
G541R suppresses fusion for the WT 4070A amphotropic envelope. The mutation G541R was previously also isolated in a WT 4070A MuLV population passaged through D17 cells (29). Syncytium assays were performed with this WT variant in order to determine how universal the syncytium-suppressive effect might be. Syncytia are not normally observed for the WT amphotropic Env in an XC cocultivation assay, necessitating the analysis of this mutation in an R- backbone. Analyses of syncytia on XC and NIH 3T3 cells are summarized in Table 3. 4070A Env lacking the R-peptide produced syncytia with both XC as well as NIH 3T3 cells. Inclusion of G541R into 4070A Env/R- decreased the number of syncytia 6-fold when cocultivated with rat XC cells and 6- to 10-fold within NIH 3T3 cells. Control experiments of M-MuLV Env with XC cells yielded massive syncytia (data not shown). While G541R improved the titers of the chimeric EA6 (Tables 1 and 2) and EA7 viruses (1.7 x 103 [28]), substitution of G541R in the WT 4070A backbone decreased virus titers by two- to fourfold in two independent determinations (Table 3).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Viral titers and syncytium characteristics of 4070A Env's
|
Figure 3A represents the analysis of comparative fractions from the cell (left panel) and the cell surface (center panel). Envelopes within the chimeric EA6 series that were analyzed included the syncytium-positive N261I/E311V mutant and the syncytium-negative N261I/E311V/G541R mutant. In addition, the 4070A Env in the presence and absence of G541R as well as M-MuLV Env in the presence and absence of R-peptide were analyzed. The level of expression of precursor SU-TM for all the constructs was similar in the total cellular extract. Heterogeneity in the SU corresponding to proteolytic processing and glycosylation was visible with the WT controls M-MuLV and 4070A Env (lanes 6 and 8, respectively). This is supported by the presence of TM (p15E) coimmunoprecipitating in the fraction. For the M-MuLV/R- Env, the corresponding p12E protein was observed (lane 5). In comparison with the control samples, the level of TM protein associated with the EA6 virus (lane 4) as well as the 4070A/G541R virus (lane 7) was greatly decreased. An overexposure of the region containing the TM proteins from the total cellular protein was included on the bottom of the left panel. For the EA6/N261I/E311V virus, a low level of p15E TM protein was visible (lane 2). This correlates with the increased titer and syncytia associated with incorporating these two mutations within EA6. The level of TM was diminished in EA6/N261I/E311V/G541R, relative to that in the N261I/E311V double combination (lane 3). In the parental EA6, a protein product in between the p15E and p12E protein was visible (lane 4). This product is observed as a minor species in the control M-MuLV/R+ Env sample (lane 6).
![]() View larger version (46K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Levels of expression of Env's. DNA encoding different Env's was transiently expressed in D17/gag-pol cells. At 24 h posttransfection, cells were metabolically labeled overnight with Tran35S-label. (A) Cells were subsequently incubated with 1 ml of PBS containing 0.5 mg of EZ-Link NHS-SS-biotin for 30 min at room temperature. Biotinylation reactions were quenched by the addition of 10 ml of DMEM containing 10% calf serum. Cells were lysed in 1 ml of PLB and processed as described in Materials and Methods. The total cellular fraction (left) was immunoprecipitated with anti-SU antibody 80S-019. The cell surface fraction (middle) was immunoprecipitated with anti-SU antibody 80S-019, followed by purification on avidin-agarose beads. (B) The viral fraction was isolated following an overnight labeling with Tran35S-label. Culture supernatant was centrifuged at 35,000 rpm in an SW41 rotor for 4 h to concentrate viral particles. Viral particles were resuspended in PLB, and Env was immunoprecipitated with anti-SU antibody 80S-019. The sample corresponding to one-fourth of a 100-mm plate was analyzed by SDS-PAGE.
|
Viral SU was analyzed by immunoprecipitation using the same antibody (80S-019) as in the cell surface experiment (Fig. 3B). While appreciable amounts of virus-associated Env were present on the EA6 parental (lane 20) and the EA6/N261I/E311V (lane 18) isolates, little or no Env was detected in the EA6/N261I/E311V/G541R viral isolate (lane 19). Consistent with the lower detection of cell surface expression, there was a decreased level of virus-associated 4070A Env bearing G541R (lane 23) compared to that in the WT 4070A control (lane 24).
Several mechanisms can explain why a TM mutation decreases the level of virion and cell surface-associated SU protein. Processing of the SU-TM precursor protein may be inhibited. However, pulse-chase experiments of both the WT 4070A and the G541R-substituted 4070A Env's indicated the presence of SU 2 h postchase (data not shown). A blockage in the transport to the cell surface can occur. Alternatively, the G541R TM mutation can induce a conformation in SU that alters the recognition by the antibody utilized in the immunoprecipitation. It is possible that several of these pathways are working in concert. The question of differential antibody recognition was further analyzed below.
The TM mutation G541R abolishes recognition of the amphotropic SU C terminus by a C-terminal-specific monoclonal antibody. Altered cell surface and virus expression levels implied a possible alteration in SU-TM interactions. Figure 4 shows the results of probing Western blots of virus-associated G541R Env's with two different SU antibodies. In the top panel (A), viral preparations of M-MuLV and 4070A were compared to EA6/N261I/E311V/G541R. Samples from the same transient-expression experiment were replicated on a single PAGE, separated, and subsequently visualized with either the SU monoclonal 83A25 (11) or the SU polyclonal 80S-019 (Microbiological Associates). By Western blotting, antibody 83A25 did not recognize either the M-MuLV or EA6 viral SU. This is consistent with recent results in which reduced SU is not detectable on Western blotting using the SU antibody 83A25 (5). Viral SU was detected, however, in all Env's by the SU polyclonal 80S-019. The level of EA6/N261I/E311V/G541R Env detected on viral particles was lower than that of the control M-MuLV or 4070A-MuLV Env. Since the antibody reacted with both the ecotropic and amphotropic SU, these results indicate that the level of EA6 N261I/E311V/G541R on the virus is decreased.
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Effect of G541R on antibody recognition. Viral Env's were transiently expressed in D17/gag-pol cells. At 48 h posttransfection, viral supernatants were collected, filtered through an acrodisc 0.45-µm-pore-size filter, and centrifuged at 16,000 x g through a 20% sucrose cushion for 45 min. Viral pellets were resuspended in SDS-PAGE sample buffer with 2% ß-mercaptoethanol and separated on an SDS-10% PAGE. Proteins were transferred onto PVDF and subsequently visualized by immunostaining. (A) Analysis of N261I/E311V/G541R/EA6 compared to M-MuLV and 4070A-MuLV Env's. The upper left panel denotes immunostaining with SU primary antibody 83A25 (11) followed by secondary antibody goat anti-rat IgG-horseradish peroxidase (Pierce) and chemiluminescence (Pierce); the upper right panel represents immunostaining with SU polyclonal 80S-019 (Microbiological Associates), followed by secondary antibody rabbit anti-goat IgG (Pierce) and chemiluminescence. Lower panels represent analysis of CA protein using primary antibody 79S-287 (Microbiological Associates), secondary antibody rabbit anti-goat IgG (Pierce), and chemiluminescence. (B) Analysis of G541R- 4070A Env's in comparison to WT M-MuLV, R-minus Mo-MuLV, and 4070A-MuLV Env's. The left panel represents results following probing with SU monoclonal 83A25. The Western blot was then incubated with SDS and ß-mercaptoethanol in Tris-HCl (pH 6.8) buffer at 55°C for 30 min to remove bound antibodies. The blot was subsequently incubated with primary antibody 80S-019 (right panel). Secondary antibodies and visualization are as noted for panel A.
|
Analysis of G552 in M-MuLV. 4070A G541R is localized within a highly conserved region of the ectodomain of TM, three amino acids N-terminal to the first cysteine residue (Fig. 1). The homologous position within the ecotropic M-MuLV is G552. The ability of G552 to regulate syncytia within M-MuLV was investigated. The ecotropic M-MuLV TM protein (G552) was mutated to an arginine. Results of an XC cocultivation assay following transient expression are summarized in Table 4. Virus titer was determined by the transfer of the lacZ gene following infection into D17/pJET cells. No appreciable effect was observed on either the virus titer or production of syncytia for either the R+ or R- M-MuLV Env's bearing the G552R substitution in comparison to results with the wild-type M-MuLV counterparts. The assembly of the SU/TM complexes within amphotropic and ecotropic Env therefore displays subtle differences.
The effects of incorporating G552R were further analyzed within an M-MuLV backbone bearing the N261I and E311V mutations. The N261I and E311V mutations were located within the ecotropic domain of the EA6 chimera. The results presented in Fig. 3 indicated that the presence of these two mutations within EA6 increased the proteolytic processing of the TM protein and the association of SU and TM by coimmunoprecipitation. The two mutations acted cooperatively to increase virus titer (Table 1), kinetics of viral passage (data not shown), and induction of syncytia (Table 1). These mutations were selected in response to a chimeric junction in the SU C terminus. It was therefore of interest whether these stabilizing mutations in the first two-thirds of the ecotropic SU would respond in the presence of the equivalent G552R mutation in the context of an intact ecotropic SU C terminus and TM. M-MuLV Env bearing the substitutions N261V/E311V/G552R was generated and analyzed for expression for surface as well as viral protein expression (Fig. 5). Surprisingly, the presence of G552R within the M-MuLV N261V/E311V construct had the opposite effect as within an amphotropic TM/SU C terminus. The G552R mutation increased the surface expression of SU and stabilized the coimmunoprecipitation of TM (Fig. 5, Surface, lane 2). This cell surface-expressed SU/TM complex, however, was not efficiently packaged within virion particles (Fig. 5, Total Supernatant, lane 2). Analysis of viral proteins released into the medium indicated a small but detectable decrease in SU proteins. In addition, the level of TM protein that coimmunoprecipitated with SU was also decreased. Analysis of virus titers indicated that the virus titer of M-MuLV N261V/E311V/G552R was 3.7- to 12-fold decreased from that of the WT M-MuLV virus (Table 4).
![]() View larger version (46K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Effect of homologous substitution in the M-MuLV TM protein. DNA encoding different Env's was transiently expressed in D17/gag-pol cells. At 24 h posttransfection, cells were metabolically labeled overnight with Tran35S-label. Cells were subsequently incubated with 1 ml of PBS containing 0.5 mg of EZ-Link NHS-SS-biotin for 30 min at room temperature. Biotinylation reactions were quenched by the addition of 10 ml of DMEM containing 10% calf serum. Cells were lysed in 1 ml of PLB and processed as described in Materials and Methods. The total cellular fraction (left) was immunoprecipitated with anti-SU antibody 80S-019. The cell surface fraction (right) was immunoprecipitated with anti-SU antibody 80S-019, followed by purification on avidin-agarose beads. Molecular mass markers were obtained from Bio-Rad. Lane 1, mock; lane 2, M-MuLV N261I/E311V/G552R; lane 3, M-MuLV; lane 4, M-MuLV/R-.
|
|
|
|---|
Cell surface biotinylation experiments revealed that within EA6 and WT 4070A, G541R altered the levels of SU and TM present on the cell and viral surfaces. The low level of Env bearing the G541R substitution was not attributable to shedding into the culture medium. Comparison of total SU in the medium versus virus-associated SU after pelleting through a sucrose gradient did not reveal release of 4070A/G541R versus the WT 4070A Env (data not shown). Mutational studies of various amino acids within the homologous ectodomain regions of TM in HIV-1 and feline leukemia virus led to the phenotype of decreased levels of cell-cell fusion events (6, 26). For feline leukemia virus, this phenotype was attributed to inhibition of protein processing. For HIV, mutation of the equivalent position, W596, resulted in loss of gp120 association.
Cells with decreased levels of G541R-Env at the cell surface were limited for cell-cell fusion relative to the controls. The effect of Env density on cell-cell fusion was previously studied with influenza virus (8, 9), where low hemagglutinin cell surface density correlated with a longer lag period before the onset of cell-cell fusion. For HIV-1 (20), the level of cellular expression of the Env proteins (gp120/gp41) affects the efficiency of cell-cell fusion events (20) and suggests that a conserved mechanism to limit cell-cell fusion events among retroviruses is via the level of Env expression. Since syncytium formation results in host cell death, this strategy of limiting cell-cell fusion events would ultimately be beneficial for the virus in maintaining a symbiotic relationship with its host.
Although the number of cell-cell fusion events is dictated in part by the cell surface density of the Env protein, virus-cell fusion is not adversely affected. For M-MuLV, efficient infection requires only a minimal level of Env protein on the virus (1). Viral isolates such as EA6 N261I/E331V/G541R, with decreased cell-cell fusion, maintained high virus titer. G541R was additionally isolated in D17 cell-derived 4070A in combination with G100R within VRA. G100R enhances binding and entry kinetics of amphotropic 4070A viral particles to multiple cell types with varying levels of Pit2 receptor (21). If stronger binding signifies better signaling, one strategy to restore the spatial and temporal control of fusion would be to decrease the level of Env protein, through the acquisition of G541R. The net effect of decreased surface expression in response to stronger signaling has led to MuLV variants that preserve the intrinsic nature of the fusion process.
Residue G541 is the first glycine in a double-Gly motif conserved among retroviral TM proteins. Based on homology modeling with the M-MuLV TM ectodomain crystal structure, G541 is N-terminal to the TM intramolecular disulfide bond and helps to form a reverse turn between the coiled-coil motif and a short alpha helix (12). Covalent SU-TM interactions are mediated through a third TM cysteine with the C terminus of SU (35, 42). The TM disulfide-bonded loop-chain reversal region of HIV is a critical SU contact site (6, 26). Immunological data presented in this paper suggest that G541R interacts with the C terminus of SU near or at the epitope of the SU monoclonal antibody 83A25. Chimera and polymorphism mapping localize the 83A25 epitope to a position inclusive of SU C-terminal amino acids 416 to 449 (M-MuLV numbering, including the signal sequence) (5, 40), while saturation mutagenesis studies (40) further localize its epitope to M-MuLV Env amino acids 428 to 431. G541R was also isolated in chimeric EA7 Env viral populations (Fig. 1) that bear a C-terminal SU junction close in primary sequence to the proposed monoclonal antibody 83A25 epitope (5, 40). G541R restored viral viability compared to the parental EA7 virus and additionally suppressed a unique cold-sensitive phenotype when expressed in cis with changes in either the N or C terminus of SU (28). In total, these observations suggest amino acids within the ectodomain of TM, particularly glycine 541, are critical determinants of the stability of SU-TM interactions (14) and conformation of the SU C terminus.
The C terminus of SU plays an important role in the stability of SU-TM interactions (14, 33, 36) and the achievement of virus-cell fusion (3, 4, 16, 18, 42). Rearrangement of the SU-TM disulfide bond is proposed to facilitate structural conformational changes required for fusion (42). A viral entry model proposes that alternate contacts between SU and TM form upon receptor binding (3) which lead to fusion, such as that between the SU N terminus and a conserved disulfide loop in the C terminus of SU (16). By altering the conformation of the C terminus, the G541R mutation may alter the critical SU N- and C-terminal interactions and lead to delayed fusion kinetics.
Mutations to the cysteine-proximal region of the human T-cell leukemia virus type 1 TM protein resulted in either unchanged or increased levels of Env with a concomitant decreased level of cell-cell fusion (25) and led to a proposal that the double-Gly motif regulates the transition of TM from the prehairpin stage to the six-helix intermediate. In an analogous role, MuLV G541R could be acting as a control point for the amphotropic Env to regulate the conversion of TM from the prehairpin intermediate to the six-helix bundle.
Despite their C-terminal SU and TM homologies, the ecotropic and amphotropic MuLV Env's have adapted subtle distinct properties to bind their individual receptors and transmit the post-receptor-binding signals. Amphotropic MuLV transduction is dependent on high levels of receptor (24, 32), and the 4070A PRR has less fusogenic potential relative to that of M-MuLV (17). The substitution of the analogous G552R in the WT M-MuLV has no effect on cell-cell fusion events, suggesting the mutation was specifically adapted for viruses with the amphotropic C terminus. Interestingly, passage of a converse chimera containing the 4070A RBD and the ecotropic SU C terminus and TM (IVAE4 [22]) resulted in the selection of the G552E mutation in addition to G100R and L435I (23). The M-MuLV G552R substitution (G541R in 4070A), along with K550 and K558, generates a large positive surface area at the top of the hairpin structure within the TM ectodomain (12). The acidic G552E residue would disrupt the positive charge surface, suggesting that this charge cluster may play a regulatory role. The proximity of L435 to junction 7 and the proposed recognition site for SU monoclonal antibody 83A25 further supports the concept of an interaction between these localized regions of SU and TM. By mutagenesis and subsequent compensatory mutations acquired by in vivo evolution, the intrinsic Env characteristics required for optimal signal transmission (47) and entry of 4070A and M-MuLV were maintained.
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»