Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, October 2003, p. 10623-10629, Vol. 77, No. 19
0022-538X/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.77.19.10623-10629.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Sir Albert Sakzewski Virus Research Centre, Royal Children's Hospital,1 Clinical Medical Virology Centre, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia,2 University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 537063
Received 14 April 2003/ Accepted 3 July 2003
|
|
|---|
6 bacteriophage, which also replicates efficiently using a dsRNA template with conserved 3'-penultimate cytidines and a 3'-terminal pyrimidine. A previously untested substitution of the conserved pentanucleotide at the top of the 3'-terminal stem-loop of all Flavivirus species also blocked detectable in vivo replication of the Kunjin virus replicon RNA. |
|
|---|
The Flavivirus RNA replication strategy has been established with Kunjin virus (KUN) (11, 12, 24, 49-51). The genomic or RNA positive strand is translated, a replication complex is formed cotranslationally on the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of the template RNA, and it transcribes an RNA negative strand that remains base paired with the RNA positive strand as a replicative form (RF). We found no evidence for the presence of a free RNA negative strand in KUN replicon-transfected cells (22). We have defined the consensus composition of the KUN replication complex (RC) as NS1, NS3, NS5, and hydrophobic nonstructural proteins NS2A and NS4A plus the RF (24, 34, 50, 51). The RF functions as a recycling template (shown by the kinetics of pulse-chase labeling) for asymmetric and semiconservative replication of progeny RNA positive strands by the viral replicase, and no subgenomic RNA is synthesized (11). Purified 32P-labeled KUN RF was converted to a replicative intermediate (RI) when presented as a substrate to a lysate of KUN-infected cells (2). The Pestivirus Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) (15, 47) and Hepacivirus Hepatitis C virus (HCV) (1) appear to use a similar strategy.
It has recently become apparent that a cytidine residue is present as the penultimate and/or terminal base at the 3' end of many non-polyadenylated viral RNA positive strands. In Flavivirus species, the conserved 5'- and 3'-terminal nucleotides end as 5'AGU/A-G/A/UCUOH3', and the RNA positive strand terminates as A/UCUOH3' (7, 8, 21, 36, 41, 43, 48). Their roles in Flavivirus replication have not been explored, in contrast to the numerous in vitro studies using recombinant HCV NS5B and a variety of single-stranded RNA templates (e.g., references 20, 27, 37, 40, and 54). We decided to investigate the role in Flavivirus replication of the 3'-terminal dinucleotide by an in vivo approach because relevant experiments with recombinant NS5/NS5B assays in vitro were shown to be relatively inefficient and primer dependent but not template specific; furthermore RNA synthesis mostly occurred by "copyback" on the single-stranded template rather than by production of a de novo RNA transcript (44). Other examples of similar RdRp assays are those done with HCV recombinant NS5B (described above), recombinant Flavivirus NS5 of Dengue 1 virus (45) and KUN (16), and recombinant NS5B of the Pestivirus BVDV (19). In contrast, experiments with infectious Flavivirus RNA would retain the native forms of the templates for synthesis of both polarities of RNA, and all cellular components of the RC would be available. Therefore, we elected to use the self-amplifying KUN replicon or subgenomic RNA (22) (KUN RNA GenBank accession no. D00246, L24511, and L24512). The KUN replicon appears to replicate by the same strategy as full-length genomic RNA (23-25, 33). In this report, we show that the penultimate C at the 3' terminus of KUN RNA positive and negative strands was essential for KUN RNA replication. In addition, mutations that changed the 3'-terminal nucleotide (uridine) of either strand blocked or restricted replication.
Structure and conformation of the KUN replicon RNA. The replicon RNA has had all of the structural genes (C, prM, and E) deleted except for the first 20 codons of the core (or C) gene, which are required for replication, but otherwise it is identical to KUN genomic RNA (22). In addition to the conserved Flavivirus 5'- and 3'-terminal trinucleotides, there are conserved complementary sequences within the KUN core coding region and 3' UTR (5' nucleotides 137 to 144 and 3' nucleotides -97 to -104, respectively) that are able to base pair and cause cyclization of the viral RNA (26). We also showed that mutations in these cyclization sequences (CS) blocked the RNA synthesis in vivo unless they were compensatory mutations that could base pair in the same way as the original CS (26).
A computer-generated secondary structure of KUN replicon RNA (7.5 kb) in a characteristic minimum free energy configuration is shown in Fig. 1; it represents the longest secondary structure presented for a Flavivirus RNA. The low pairing numbers (P-num values) (38) of the bases in the area of interest shown in Fig. 1B suggest that the secondary structure as drawn is actually in the preferred configuration and is of high biological significance. The salient features in the 5'- and 3'-terminal sequences are the base pairing of CS, the presence of 5'- and 3'-terminal stem-loops each within the last 100 nucleotides and their spatial proximity to each other, retention of the Flavivirus conserved non-base-paired pentanucleotide 5'CACAG3' at the top of the 3'-terminal stem-loop (48), and the non-base-paired terminal nucleotide. Notably, the 3'-stem-loop retains the base of the stem required to form a conserved pseudoknot (43).
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG.1. Computer-predicted model showing the topology of the RNA of the KUN replicon C20DXrep, prepared by using the mfold program and presented as the global MinE structure with bases colored according to their P-num values (38). (A) Model of the complete genome. (B) Enlargement of the inset region in panel A that represents only the 5'-terminal 146 nucleotides (nts) (numbering from 5' is 1 to 146) and the 3'-terminal 106 nucleotides (numbering -1 to -106 from the terminus). The stem-loop structures in the enlarged inset region are slightly rearranged so the structures of the 5'- and 3'-terminal regions are more clearly depicted. CS identifies the base-paired cyclization sequence (see text). Bases indicated as A, C, G, or U are shown for the terminal nucleotides, the AUG translation initiation codon (at positions 97 to 99), the base-paired region in the lower portion of the 3'-terminal stem-loop, the Flavivirus-conserved pentanucleotide at the top of this loop, and the proposed pseudoknot sequences. Low P-num values (<3%) are represented by red bases, while increasing P-num values are represented by the colors orange, yellow, green (medium), and blue through black (high).
|
![]() View larger version (39K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Analysis of RNA copied from 3'-mutated KUN replicon RNA by Northern blotting. Approximately 10 µg of total cell RNA was extracted from BHK cells at 45 and 69 h after transfection with 5 µg of KUN replicon RNAs mutated in the penultimate cytidine or the 3'-terminal uridine and subjected to Northern blot hybridization with 32P-labeled cDNA probes detecting replicon RNA and ß-actin mRNA as previously described (31). The mutated nucleotides are shown in boldface and underlined. Densitometry analysis of the blots is shown in Table 1.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Effect on replication of mutations in the 5'- and 3'-terminal dinucleotides of KUN replicon RNA
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Effect on replication of mutations in the 3' pentanucleotide loop of KUN replicon RNA
|
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Analysis of RNA copied from 5'-mutated replicon RNA. (A) Northern blot analysis with KUN replicon-specific 32P-labeled cDNA probe of 10 µg of total cell RNA extracted from BHK cells at 45 and 69 h after transfection with replicon RNAs containing native (wild type [wt]) and mutated 5'-terminal ribonucleotides. (B) Detection of KUN replicon RNA negative-strand synthesis in BHK cells at 48 h after transfection with plasmid DNAs containing KUN replicon cDNA with native and mutated 5'-terminal nucleotides. The probe was a 32P-labeled 274-nucleotide (nts) positive-sense RNA from the NS4A region transcribed in vitro, and the RNase protection assay was performed with an RPA-III kit, essentially as described by the manufacturer (Ambion, Inc., Austin, Tex.).
|
The scenarios presented above implied that RNA negative-strand synthesis could occur on the electroporated 5'-mutated replicon RNA, but these mutant RNA negative strands could not function as templates for synthesis of progeny replicon RNA. Thus, only a very small number of RNA negative strands could be synthesized (one per 5'-mutated replicon template), and these would not be detected in the Northern blot assays, as shown (Fig. 3A). Therefore, a different strategy was devised to allow synthesis and accumulation of multiple copies of replicon RNA per cell, with either wild-type (5'AGU) or mutated (5'AUU, 5'GGU) 5'-terminal sequences. This was achieved by constructing plasmids containing replicon cDNA inserts preceded by a cytomegalovirus promoter (46) so that the replicon RNA with the 5' mutations could be transcribed in cells from the transfected plasmid DNA into multiple RNA positive strands. Each multiply transcribed RNA could be translated, forming an RC (24), and be copied into an RNA negative strand if the 5' mutations blocked only RNA positive-strand synthesis in accord with the projected scenarios. This accumulation of RNA negative strands in each plasmid DNA-transfected cell would increase the sensitivity of detection. After incubation of these cells for 48 h, the total RNA was extracted for RNase protection assays to detect any accumulation of newly synthesized RNA negative strands (Fig. 3B). These were readily detected in cells transfected with plasmids transcribing both wild-type and 5' mutant replicons, thus establishing that the block in amplification of the transfected 5' mutant replicons must be due to their inability to be copied from their newly synthesized daughter strands as templates. Note that the positive-strand probe used for Fig. 3B could detect as little as 10 ng of RNA negative strand (lane 3), but no labeled band was detected in a sample containing a large excess (100 ng) of RNA positive strand (lane 7), thus demonstrating the specificity of the assay. The results (summarized in Table 1) thus show that both of the conserved bases in the 3'-terminal dinucleotide -CUOH of RNA positive and negative strands are required for replication of the KUN replicon. The significance of these observed effects is discussed later. Note in Fig. 3B that that there was less synthesis of RNA negative strands in cells transfected with the plasmid DNA for the wild-type replicon, presumably because of the normal undefined control mechanisms that limit late flavivirus RNA negative-strand synthesis in the presence of as much as a 1,000-fold excess of accumulated positive strands of replicon RNA (42), whereas the transcribed 5' mutant replicons that were copied into RNA negative strands were not amplified as in the normal replicative cycle.
Mutations in the conserved pentanucleotide loop of the 3'-terminal stem-loop of KUN replicon RNA affecting replication. A role in Flavivivirus replication of the conserved pentanucleotide loop 5'CACAG3' (48) in the 3'-terminal stem-loop has not been previously reported. We have suggested that it might provide a "landing pad" for assembly of components of the RC during their translation to facilitate initiation and transcription into RNA negative strands (24, 51), similar to the in vitro binding to the 3'-terminal stem-loop that occurs with NS3 and NS5 specified by Japanese encephalitis virus (10). We therefore tested any requirement for the conserved pentanucleotide by introducing mutations in KUN replicon repPACß-gal as described above, changing the conserved sequence to 5'UCUAG3' (data not shown). Replicon RNA transcribed from the mutated cDNA was electroporated into BHK cells that were then incubated for 69 h. When the cells were assayed for evidence of replicon replication by immunofluorescence with anti-KUN NS3 antibodies (50) or by X-Gal staining, no positively stained cells were detected (Table 2). Hence, although the M-fold structure of the long stem remained, as shown in Fig. 1B, mutations in the conserved pentanucleotide loop blocked replication. The results directly implicate this loop in Flavivirus replication.
Comparisons of conservation in the 5'- and 3'-terminal structures and nucleotide sequences among the Flaviviridae. As in the Flavivirus species, conservation of terminal nucleotides is found in all genera. The genomic terminal sequences 5'GUAU/CCCC3' and the internal ribosomal entry site are conserved in RNA of Pestivirus species BVDV (3, 13, 53; GenBank accession no. AF220247 and NC_002514) and hog cholera virus RNA (13; GenBank accession no. J04358 and AF091661). Results of experiments with synthetic templates and the recombinant NS5B RdRp of BVDV (19), with mutations in the conserved 5'GUAU of the BVDV replicon (3), or with 5'GUAU added to a substituted HCV 5' UTR in a chimeric BVDV genome (14) are all compatible with a role in replication for a 3'-penultimate or -terminal cytidine in either RNA strand as a template. HCV genomic RNA (infectious in chimpanzees) and HCV replicon RNA (self-amplifying in Huh-7 cells) have conserved terminal sequences 5'GCCAG//CAA/U GU3' (28, 32; GenBank accession no. AF009606 and AJ242654); hence only the RNA negative strand terminates with a 3' cytidine residue and it is a more efficient template in vitro than the RNA positive strand (40). The failure by HCV to normally employ a penultimate or terminal 3' cytidine in genomic RNA so as to improve efficiency of RNA negative-strand synthesis may represent a strategy to restrict the level of virus replication to below the required level for immunosurveillance during some persistent infections.
In summary, these comparisons indicate a strong preference either for a 3'-penultimate cytidine followed by a pyrimidine or for a 3'-terminal cytidine for efficient replication of both RNA positive and negative strands of all of the species of Flaviviridae: e.g., RNA positive strand, -CU3', -CC3'; and RNA negative strand, -CU3', -CC3', -AC3', or -GC3'.
Is the model for initiation of RNA synthesis by the RNA polymerase of dsRNA bacteriophage
6 RdRp applicable to Flavivirus RNA synthesis?
The replication strategy of flaviviruses has some striking parallels with that of the segmented double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) bacteriophage
6 (35). In both cases the polymerase can function without a primer on a single-stranded RNA template and use dsRNA as a recycling template for semiconservative and asymmetric replication of RNA positive strands that are destined to function as mRNAs and also as the single-stranded template for RNA negative-strand synthesis, thus reforming the genomic dsRNA (
6) or RF (flaviviruses). Thus, the models proposed independently for KUN (11, 37, 51) and
6 phage (35) are virtually identical in their major features of replication strategy. The determination of the crystal structure of the
6 polymerase protein L2 (9) and of the flavivirus HCV RdRp NS5B (5, 6, 29) and the associated comparative analyses have indicated the commonality of the molecular architecture of these enzymes, as emphasized by Butcher et al. (9), who suggested an evolutionary link. Their common features include the roughly spherical topology and superimposition of 418 C
atoms, such that "they resemble each other much more than either resembles any other known polymerase structure" (9). Comparisons with the
6 polymerase show that there are 12 fully conserved amino acid residues for KUN NS5 in the sequence comprising the C, D, and E polymerase motifs (E. G. Westaway, unpublished observations) compared with only 3 in the corresponding conserved palm region of HCV NS5B (9). The RNA positive and negative strands of the
6 L, M, and S segments all terminate similarly to KUN RNA with a 3' pyrimidine and a penultimate cytidine (GenBank accession no. NC_003715, NC_003716, and NC_003714) other than one relatively inefficient exception. Butcher et al. (9) proposed that the 3' terminus of the RNA negative strand is separated from dsRNA and fed directly into the template channel past the catalytic site and thence temporarily into a specific binding pocket (the "S" pocket) that is too small to accommodate a 3'-terminal purine. Initiation of
6 RNA positive-strand synthesis is apparently facilitated by fraying of the ends of the dsRNA template associated with a low melting point of the first 9 bp in the helix (7 of 9 bp are AU) (9). Similarly, at the 3' end of the RNA negative strand in the KUN RF on which initiation of RNA positive-strand synthesis must occur, five of the seven terminal nucleotides can form AU pairs with the 5' terminus of the cRNA positive strand 5'AGUAGUU3' (21), and there are only 2 well-separated GC bp in the first 8 bp in the predicted 3'-terminal stem-loop of KUN replicon RNA (free energy, -9.7 kcal) (Fig. 1).
Assuming the analogy with the
6 replicase is reasonable, the results described above for the effects of mutations at the 5' and 3' termini on replication of the KUN replicon are readily interpreted. The 3'-penultimate cytidine and 3'-terminal uridine in the RNA positive and negative strands are essential recognition sites in a promoter sequence for the replicase complex to efficiently initiate RNA synthesis at the catalytic site in the template tunnel of NS5. Their mutations had drastic effects on synthesis of either strand (Fig. 2 and Table 1). Other sites, such as the conserved pentanucleotide at the top of the 3'-terminal stem-loop, may also be essential as attachment sites for components of the RC as mentioned above. Mutations at the 5' terminus of the KUN replicon RNA probably blocked synthesis of RNA positive strands (i) by causing loss of the 3'-penultimate cytidine in the recognition site of the RNA negative template strand of the RF, thus preventing the correct positioning of the template in the replicase; (ii) by causing a change from 3'-terminal uridine to the bulky purine adenosine in the RNA negative template that was thus too large to initially enter the putative binding pocket; or (iii) by increasing the GC base pairing at the terminus of the helix, thus inhibiting fraying of the ends that normally facilitates initiation.
In summary, replication by flaviviruses exhibits a very strong preference for a 3'-penultimate or 3'-terminal cytidine in both RNA positive and negative template strands, and a penultimate cytidine is invariably adjacent to a 3'-terminal pyrimidine.
ADDENDUM IN PROOF Using recombinant NS5 of dengue-2 virus in an in vitro RNA-dependent RNA assay, Nomaguchi et al. (M. Nomaguchi, M. Ackermann, C. Yon, S. You, and R. Padmanabhan, J. Virol. 77: 8831-8842, 2003) measured elongation (hairpin) and de novo RNA synthesis by using a subgenomic template with mutations in the 3'-terminal dinucleotide. The inhibition of mutant de novo RNA synthesis relative to that of wild-type RNA was similar to our data for in vivo synthesis of transfected Kunjin virus genomic RNA at 45 h, as shown in Table 1, for 3'-terminal mutations of -CU to -CC, -CA, or -CG (the mutation to -CC was the most inhibited in both systems). However, the effect of mutations in the penultimate C was strikingly different for the two systems: a C-to-U mutation did not affect the template activity for de novo dengue-2 virus RNA synthesis in vitro, whereas all three mutations of the Kunjin virus RNA penultimate C (to A, U, or G) caused a complete block of RNA synthesis in vivo (Table 1). It should be noted that the environment for replication of transfected Kunjin virus genomic RNA in cell culture differed from that of the in vitro RNA replication system involving only a single protein (purified recombinant NS5), a small 3'-terminal dengue-2 virus RNA template (770 nucleotides), excess of nucleoside triphosphates, and no cellular or other viral components.
This is publication no. 181 from the Sir Albert Sakzewski Virus Research Centre. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»