Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, August 2003, p. 8524-8531, Vol. 77, No. 15
0022-538X/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.77.15.8524-8531.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Developmental Therapeutics ProgramTarget Structure Based Drug Discovery Group,1 AIDS Vaccine Program, Science Applications International CorporationFrederick, Inc., National Cancer Institute at Frederick, Frederick, Maryland 21702-12012
Received 16 December 2002/ Accepted 8 May 2003
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
It was observed that a number of NC mutant murine leukemia and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) viruses were still able to package their RNA genomes, and yet they were replication defective (20, 22, 25). NC in these mutants is still able to coordinate significant levels of Zn2+ since the metal-coordinating residues are substituted with other Zn2+ coordinating amino acids (36). The replication defects in these mutants manifest themselves at the level of reverse transcription, since there is a reduction in the level of viral DNA (vDNA) produced upon infection. There is also a major defect in the ability of the these NC mutant virions to protect their vDNA once it is generated (7, 24, 51). In one particular HIV-1 NC mutant (NCH23C), there is also a defect in the ability of virions to mediate the end processing of the vDNA prior to integration, suggesting that NC and its Zn2+ fingers function in the preintegration with the viral integrase protein (7). Thus, one can observe the central importance of NC and the conserved Zn2+ finger structures at various critical stages of the viral life cycle.
Surprisingly, there is a class of proteins called cellular nucleic acid binding proteins (CNBPs) that contain seven Zn2+ finger sequences that are very similar to those found in retroviral NC (3, 6, 12, 35, 45, 47, 55). Retroviral NC and CNBP Zn2+ fingers have arrangements of amino acids with the general sequence: "-Cys-
-X-Cys-Gly-±-X-Gly-His-X3-
-Cys-," where X is a variable amino acid,
is an aromatic residue, "±" is a charged amino acid, and
is a carbonyl-containing residue. There is absolute amino acid homology between retroviral NC and CNBP Zn2+ fingers among the Cys and His metal ion-binding residues (CCHC) and the two Gly residues listed above. Additionally, there is conservation of the positions of functionally homologous residues within the Zn2+ finger loops with an aromatic residue (
) in the first loop, a charged residue (±) in the second loop, and a carbonyl-containing amino acid (
) in the third loop (Table 1). CNBPs from a number of vertebrates are highly homologous at the protein and nucleic acid levels. They have been found in humans (45), rodents (6, 35, 55), chickens (47), and amphibians (3, 12).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Comparison of the HIV-1 NC Zn2+ fingers with the seven Zn2+ fingers from human CNBP
|
As the CNBP and retroviral NC Zn2+ fingers generally appear to function in nucleic acid interactions in their respective systems and have quite similar sequences, we wished to determine whether CNBP Zn2+ fingers could serve as suitable substitutes for the proximal NC Zn2+ finger in HIV-1 NC. In the present study, the seven Zn2+ fingers from human CNBP were individually exchanged into HIV-1 NC, and mutant viruses were characterized. An analysis was also performed to model the Zn2+ finger structures from CNBP and HIV-1 NC in an attempt to identify possible divergent structural features, which may partially explain why one of the mutants was replication defective.
|
|
|---|
Mutagenesis. Primers were obtained from either the DNA Support Laboratory to the National Cancer Institute at Frederick, Science Applications International CorporationFrederick, Inc., Frederick, Md.; from Operon Technologies, Inc. (Alameda, Calif.); or Invitrogen (Carlsbad, Calif.). Restriction enzymes and T4 DNA ligase were from Invitrogen or New England BioLabs, Inc. (Beverly, Mass.).
Mutations were introduced by PCR using a Perkin-Elmer PE9600 thermocycler and Applied Biosystems AmpliTaq core reagents (Foster City, Calif.) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Sequences used for the CNBP Zn2+ finger substitutions were obtained from that reported by Rajavashisth and coworkers (45) (GenBank accession number M28372). The sense and antisense primers contain SpeI and ApaI sites, respectively (that correspond to sites at bp 1507 and 2006, respectively, in pNL4-3), which were used for subsequent cloning of the PCR products into pNL4-3 (GenBank accession number AF324493 [1]). pDR0 (23) was used as the DNA source for the PCR. The PCR fragments were reintroduced into pDR0 and then the mutant pDR0 plasmids and pNL3-4 were digested with SpeI and SalI. The appropriate fragments were isolated by agarose gel electrophoresis and then ligated, yielding the full-length pNL4-3-based proviral plasmid clones designated pCNBP-1 through pCNBP-7.
Virus characterization. Exogenous template reverse transcriptase (RT) assays were performed on clarified supernatants as described previously (7, 27). Immunoblot analysis was performed as described previously (25, 27). Viral p24CA antigen levels were determined by using the reagents and procedures for the AVP, Biological Products Laboratory's (National Cancer Institute at Frederick, Frederick, Md.) HIV-1 p24 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit. RNA was isolated as described previously (18, 25). HIV-1 RNA blot analysis was performed as described previously (27); however, instead of examining blots by autoradiography, phosphorimager analysis was performed with a Bio-Rad (Hercules, Calif.) Molecular Imager FX instrument. Long-term and single-round infectivity analyses of NC mutant and wild-type viruses were performed with clarified samples from transfected 293T cells by limiting dilution with H9 and HCLZ cells, respectively, as described previously (23, 25, 27). vDNA was prepared from infected cells, and quantitative PCR analysis was performed to detect the R/U5, U3/U5, gag, and R/5'-untranslated region target sequences as described previously (7).
Computational modeling. To note any obvious differences in Zn2+ finger structures and to attempt to find additional correlates of why one of the HIV-1 NC mutants was defective in replication and RNA packaging (see below), comparisons were performed on structural models of a number of CNBP and the NH2-terminal HIV-1 NC Zn2+ fingers. Molecular dynamics, hydropathic analysis (31, 34), and classical factor analysis techniques (30, 38, 48) were used, and the collective techniques are referred to as "hydropathic orthogonal dynamic analysis of protein" (HODAP). Published coordinates for the NH2-terminal HIV-1 NC Zn2+ finger (50) were used to homology model (Accelrys; Insight 2000 Molecular Modeling Workbench, San Diego, Calif.) the CNBP-3 and CNBP-5 structures. Identical amino acid residues in the CNBP model structures were directly superimposed on the HIV template structure, and nonidentical residues were placed with the side chain maximally overlapping the template side chain. This set of three starting structures was subjected to a protocol of molecular dynamics calculations. Individual geometries were samples from the trajectory at 1-ps intervals for 200 ps.
The HINT intramolecular hydropathic potential function (31, 34), which measures atom-atom interactions in terms of four hydropathic interaction categories, was utilized. This methodology reduces the empirical information from bulk molecular solvent partitioning to discrete atom-atom interactions. Because of this approach, the hydrophobic constants derived include a linear-free estimate of entropy, which is ignored in most molecular mechanics models. Unfavorable interactions consist of hydrophobic-polar and base-base pairs, while the favorable interactions consist of hydrophobic-hydrophobic and acid-base pairs. Hydrogen bonds fall under the category of acid-base interactions in this scheme. This method has been used successfully in a number of structure activity surveys (2, 28, 29, 31-33, 40). Two hundred frames from each of the dynamic trajectories were analyzed by using HINT, which produced a trajectory data set in 14 dimensions, one for each of the residues in each of the model Zn2+ finger peptides studied. This data set contains geometric information in the form of the distance-dependent N 2 interactions and hydropathic information. Salient patterns of variation were extracted from this data set by using factor analysis (30, 38, 48) and examined in light of the phenotypic data available for the particular Zn2+ finger. The resulting set of factor loading coefficients could be interpreted as measures of the unique contribution made by each factor to the variance of the original variables.
The original HINT data set for a single Zn2+ finger trajectory consists of over 67,000 lines of specific atom-atom interactions. Identifying amino acids with high factor loadings as indicated by the factor analysis provides a basis for filtering this large data set to permit a more detailed examination of predominant interactions between amino acids. Used in combination with animated playbacks of the trajectory, these techniques allow for the rapid elimination of all but the most persistent amino acid interactions in the model systems.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. RT and p24CA properties of NC mutant and wild-type HIV-1
|
![]() View larger version (57K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Immunoblot analysis of NC mutant and wild-type HIV-1. Proteins were fractionated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and transferred to an Immobilon-P (Millipore) membrane. A total of 6.1 x 106 cpm of RT activity/ml for each sample was loaded onto the gel. The membrane was incubated sequentially with -p7NC (bottom panel), -p24CA (middle panel), and -gp120SU (top panel). Bands were detected by chemiluminescence as described previously (25, 27). Molecular weight markers are indicated on the left, the virus analyzed is designated at the top, and the pertinent proteins detected by the various antibodies are specified on the right.
|
![]() View larger version (59K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Hybridized RNA blot and phosphorimager analysis of NC mutant and wild-type HIV-1 transiently expressed in 293T cells. (A) Particles were analyzed for full-length HIV-1 genomic RNA by using a 32P-labeled probe comprised of an 8.1-kbp AvaI pNL4-3 fragment. All samples were adjusted for equal RT levels (4.1 x 106 cpm), fractionated, and treated as described in Materials and Methods. Dilutions (undiluted, 5-, 25-, and 125-fold) of the wild-type sample were also tested. (-)-Control, samples isolated and prepared from centrifuged supernatants from 293T cells transfected with sheared salmon sperm DNA. The RNA markers are indicated on the left and the size of full-length HIV-1 RNA genome is noted on the right. (B) Band intensities were obtained by phosphorimager analysis from Northern blots (performed as described in Materials and Methods and in part A of this figure) from three independent transfections. The samples for each Northern blot were adjusted for equal levels of RT activity. The intensity of the undiluted wild-type sample (WT) was set to 100% and the intensities of the remaining samples and dilutions of the wild-type sample were calculated relative to the undiluted wild-type sample. The percentage of full-length wild-type RNA levels obtained is representative of the average of three independent RNA blots. Error bars depicting the standard deviation from the mean are also presented. (-)-Control is as described for panel A.
|
5% that of wild-type.
![]() View larger version (50K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Infectivity analysis of NC mutant and wild-type HIV-1 samples. (A) Single-round infectivity titers were obtained by infecting HCLZ cells as described in Materials and Methods and corrected for a constant level of RT activity within an assay series. The titer levels of the mutants are reported as the percentage of the wild-type sample for a particular assay series with the wild-type sample (WT) set to 100%. The percentage of wild-type HCLZ titers presented is representative of the average infectivity of samples from four independent transfections. Error bars, indicating the standard deviation from the mean, are also presented. (-)-Control samples are from 293T cells transfected with sheared salmon sperm DNA. (B) Long-term H9 replication assays of NC mutant and wild-type HIV-1 viruses are presented. RT activities of the starting inoculum, corrected for background (in counts per minute of [3H]TMP incorporated/ml) are as follows: (CNBP-3), 2.1 x 106; (CNBP-5), 1.8 x 106; and (wild-type), 0.4 x 106. Symbols: , undiluted; , 1/20; , 1/400; , 1/8,000; , 1/160,000; , (-)-Control (supernatants from 293T cells transfected with sheared salmon sperm DNA).
|
Quantitative PCR of reverse transcription intermediates. In an effort to determine mechanistically why the CNBP-5 mutant was replication defective in the infectivity assays, we analyzed reverse transcription products after 24 h of infection by using the quantitative PCR-based approach with the TaqMan system described by Buckman et al. (7). It is apparent from results presented in Table 3 (data obtained from two independent transfection-infection experiments) that substitution of the CNBP-3 sequence results in little, if any, difference from the wild-type, as expected. In contrast, the CNBP-5 substitution results in a reduction of all reverse transcription intermediates examined, to a similar extent. Only 4 to 5% wild-type levels of all of the intermediates were observed for CNBP-5.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Reverse transcription intermediate levels from mutant and wild-type virus infections
|
Factor analysis reveals that the first five principal components of these data accounted for 50 to 60% of the variance in the HODAP data. Further examination of the first three components revealed some interesting features of the interactions within each Zn2+ finger trajectory, and residues identified by this method are listed below and shown in Fig. 4. Identification of the specific atom-atom interactions responsible for observed patterns was accomplished by filtering the raw data in accordance with the results of the HODAP.
![]() View larger version (83K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Partial structures of mutant and wild-type Zn2+ fingers. Ribbon diagrams of the Zn2+ fingers are presented with the purple sphere representing the Zn2+ ion. Significant interactions are shown by the light-blue dashed lines. (A) The NH2-terminal HIV-1 NC Zn2+ finger is shown with the persistent hydrophobic interactions between the -carbons of Ile-10 and the ring carbons in Phe-2. (B) The CNBP-3 Zn2+ finger is shown with similar hydrophobic interactions between the Tyr-2 ring and the Ile-10 -carbons. (C) The CNBP-5 Zn2+ finger shown has the indicated hydrogen bonds between the Ser-3 hydroxyl group and the backbone oxygen of Tyr-2, and the Tyr-2 hydroxyl and the carboxyl group on Gln-11, which have disrupted the hydrophobic interactions between the -carbons of Ile-10 and the ring carbons of Tyr-2.
|
-carbons of Ile-10 and the ring carbons in Phe-2 (position numbering is as presented in Table 1). A similar pattern of hydrophobic interaction was observed between the Tyr-2 ring and the
-carbons of Ile-10 in the CNBP-3 peptide trajectory. This indicates that the substitution of one aromatic residue for another (a Tyr for the Phe in this position) does not affect the persistent interaction of hydrophobic ring carbons with Ile-10 (Fig. 4A and B). It should be noted that previous in vivo results show that aromatic residue exchanges can be made and replication is still accommodated (14). The interaction of hydrophobic ring carbons from the aromatic residue at position 2 with Ile-10 is absent in CNBP-5. Instead, an interaction between the Ser-3 hydroxyl group and the backbone oxygen of Tyr-2 dominates the HODAP pattern. Additionally, the Tyr-2 hydroxyl and the carboxyl group on Gln-11 remain in close proximity throughout the trajectory. Both of these interactions appear to occur at the expense of any hydrophobic interaction between the Ile-10 and Tyr-2 (Fig. 4C). The differences observed between CNBP-5 and the other Zn2+ finger models examined point to a possible structural explanation for the functional differences observed between the CNBP-5 mutant and the replication-competent viruses.
|
|
|---|
Surprisingly, the substitutions yielded structurally and functionally competent viruses. The only exception was the CNBP-5 Zn2+ finger mutant (Table 1). Previous observations suggested that retroviral NC Zn2+ fingers were quite sensitive to alteration, even when the positions of the NH2- and COOH-terminal NC Zn2+ finger sequences are switched (23). All of the viruses except CNBP-5 appear normal with respect to protein content and processing (Table 2 and Fig. 1). CNBP-5 particles have a slight defect shown by the accumulation of Gag-processing intermediates. The RNA content of most of the mutant viruses is similar to that of wild-type virus, with CNBP-5, again, being the outlier. CNBP-5 diverges from the other viruses with respect to infectivity as well. It is the most defective mutant in the single-round infection HCLZ assay (Fig. 3A), with only 5% of the titer found in the wild-type virus. Additionally, CNBP-5 is replication defective in a long-term infectivity assay when cultivated in H9 cells (Fig. 3B). Like HIV-1 NC, CNBP shows a preference for GT-rich sequences (16, 45). Perhaps the ability of many of the CNBP Zn2+ fingers to substitute faithfully for the NH2-terminal Zn2+ finger in NC results from recognition of GT (U) sequences that are critical for NC binding during the viral life cycle (e.g., the stem-loop structures within the
site and also at the LTR ends where protection of the full-length linear vDNA ends is critical for the subsequent integration process [7]).
The reverse transcription intermediate levels of cells infected with CNBP-5 were measured and compared to two replication-competent viruses (Table 3) by using techniques described previously (7). CNBP-5 clearly has a deficiency in its ability to synthesize vDNA upon infection. The defect in infectivity cannot be accounted for solely by the reduction in full-length genomic RNA as this virus packages
45% wild-type RNA genome levels and the quantities of reverse transcription intermediates is 3 to 5% that of wild-type virus. The reduction in reverse transcription intermediates correlates with the results obtained from the HCLZ infectivity analysis (Fig. 3A). The reduction in reverse transcription intermediates is similar for all of the target sequences analyzed, suggesting that there may be an initiation defect or a defect in tRNALys,3 primer placement. Thus, once reverse transcription starts, it is able to proceed normally. In addition, a reduction in the level of tRNALys,3 primer on the primer binding site of the genomic RNA would account for the overall observed reduction in reverse transcription in cells infected with the CNBP-5 mutant.
The protein processing and RNA packaging defects may account for some of the reduction in replication and infectivity. Other reasons why CNBP-5 is defective may have to do with the following points: (i) CNBP-5 has only one basic residue, whereas all other HIV-1 and CNBP Zn2+ fingers have at least two; (ii) there is a Ser residue after the aromatic amino acid in loop 1all others have Arg, Asn, or Lys residues at this position; and (iii) CNBP-5 is the only Zn2+ finger with a net negative 2 charge, whereas all other Zn2+ fingers have a -1, 0, or +1 charge. Additionally, the HODAP procedure shows limitations of conformations that the CNBP-5 Zn2+ finger can adopt, which can be accommodated in CNBP-3 and the NH2-terminal HIV-1 NC Zn2+ finger (Fig. 4). Intercalation of the aromatic Trp residue between nucleic acid bases during binding of NC to RNA has been demonstrated with the COOH-terminal NC Zn2+ finger (37); presumably, the aromatic residue in the NH2-terminal finger of HIV-1 NC participates in a similar interaction. Thus, the limited conformations that the CNBP-5 Zn2+ finger can adopt may prevent proper intercalations from taking place. This may decrease the binding affinity of CNBP-5 NC to the genomic RNA
site, explaining the reduction in full-length genomic RNA levels in the mutant viruses. In addition, DeGuzman et al. (13) have shown that Phe-2 and Ile-10, along with Ala-11 in the wild-type Zn2+ finger, interact with a hydrophobic cleft in the loop of SL3, which may be disrupted by the aberrant interactions that take place in CNBP-5. This may also account for the defects seen in RNA packaging in the CNBP-5 NC mutant.
The HODAP technique employed in the present study permits the comparison of critical features within a set of Zn2+ finger peptides. Because the method accounts for every atom-atom interaction and because it is distance dependent, the interaction data contains a spatial component. Analysis of sequence data alone does not yield three-dimensional spatial information. Similarly, the analysis of three-dimensional atom positions without interaction information does not yield chemical information. The HINT function included in this analysis supplements the spatial component of the data with entropic interaction information. Critical features in Zn2+ finger peptides are revealed by using the methods employed here because the features are dynamic physicochemical phenomena with a spatial component. Furthermore, because the essentials of these trajectory motions are viewed through the hydropathic, entropic lens provided by these techniques, a more complete picture of protein design emerges.
The critical and central requirement for NC and the Zn2+ fingers in the replication of retroviruses makes them attractive targets for antiviral therapies. However, the results of the present study indicate a need for some caution. For the most part, Zn2+ fingers from CNBP are suitable substitutes for the NH2-terminal NC Zn2+ finger of HIV-1. It is remotely possible that mutations in genes coding for NC Zn2+ fingers could be complemented by genes that encode cellular (CNBP) Zn2+ fingers. Thus, NC mutant DNA vaccines such as those described previously (21) would have to be engineered so that lesions are introduced in other regions in addition to those in the NC-coding region. Additionally, antiviral compounds specific to NC Zn2+ fingers may affect CNBP and related proteins; therefore, precautions must be employed during their development so as not to disrupt any critical cellular functions provided by these Zn2+ finger-containing proteins.
This work has been funded in whole or in part with Federal funds from the National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, under contract NO1-CO-12400 with SAICFrederick, Inc.
The contents of this publication do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the Department of Health and Human Services, nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organization imply endorsement by the U.S. Government.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»