Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Virology, August 2002, p. 7473-7484, Vol. 76, No. 15
0022-538X/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JVI.76.15.7473-7484.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
HIV Drug Resistance Program,1 AIDS Vaccine Program, Science Applications International Corporation Frederick, National Cancer Institute at Frederick, Frederick, Maryland 21702,4 Department of Biology,2 Department of Microbiology and Immunology, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia 265063
Received 14 November 2001/ Accepted 22 April 2002
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Retroviral vectors containing directly repeated sequences provide a powerful in vivo experimental system for elucidating the mechanism of RT template switching (47-49). The frequency of direct-repeat deletion appears to correlate with the size of the repeat and the distance between direct repeats (13, 47). We recently proposed the dynamic copy choice model for template switching, which suggests that a steady state between the rates of DNA polymerization and RNA template degradation by RNase H determines the amount of nascent DNA that is available for annealing to the acceptor RNA template and thus strongly influences the frequency of RT template switching (Fig. 1). Conditions that slow down the rate of DNA polymerization, such as mutations in the polymerase domain or depletion of intracellular nucleotide pools, result in a higher frequency of template switching by allowing more efficient degradation of the template RNA by RNase H and/or provide more time for annealing between the nascent DNA and the acceptor template. On the other hand, mutations in RNase H that reduce the ability of RNase H to degrade the template RNA result in a lower frequency of RT template switching, because less nascent DNA is available for annealing with the acceptor template. Several other factors could also influence template switching by affecting the balance between DNA synthesis and annealing between the nascent DNA and acceptor RNA. These factors include effective RT concentration, hydrogen bonding between the nascent DNA and the acceptor template, and the efficiency of reinitiation of DNA synthesis by RT on the acceptor template.
![]() View larger version (22K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Dynamic copy choice model for RT template switching. The thick lines represent direct repeats in an RNA template. The horizontal arrows represent nascent DNA. The thick dashed lines represent RNA degraded by the RNase H activity of RT. Annealing between the RNA template and nascent DNA is designated by short vertical lines. Vertical arrows of various thicknesses indicate the relative efficiency of template switching. Annealing between the nascent DNA and acceptor template RNA (upper direct repeat) stimulates RT template switching. A higher frequency of template switching results in a higher rate of direct-repeat deletion, whereas a lower frequency of template switching results in a lower rate of direct-repeat deletion. Increased ( ) or decreased ( ) levels of template switching relative to wild-type RT are indicated.
|
Retroviral NC protein is released from the C-terminal portion of the Gag precursor upon proteolytic processing during virion maturation. Murine leukemia virus (MLV) NC contains one zinc-binding motif (termed the zinc finger domain or CCHC motif) and numerous basic amino acids and is tightly associated with the genomic RNA dimer in the virion core (9). NC has a strong affinity for both DNA and RNA in vitro and exhibits both specific and nonspecific RNA-binding activity (3, 4, 20). Studies have indicated that the basic residues are important for nonspecific RNA binding and the zinc finger is indispensable for specific RNA recognition (3, 4, 8, 10, 24, 59). The basic residues and the zinc finger domains of NC both contribute to tight RNA binding in vitro (8, 12, 14, 60) and play a role in selecting and packaging viral genomic RNA (24, 54).
NC exhibits nucleic acid chaperone activity that catalyzes nucleic acid rearrangements to favor more thermodynamically stable conformations (11, 29, 63). It is able to transiently break base pairs in nucleic acid secondary structures and then reanneal the bases in alternative conformations to maximize the number of base pairs, which accelerates annealing of complementary sequences and directly contributes to viral RNA dimerization and maturation (55).
The chaperone activity of NC may contribute to the process of reverse transcription by several mechanisms. Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag polyprotein has been shown to be involved in tRNA primer unwinding and its placement on the primer-binding site (6, 19); other in vitro studies suggest that the NC domain of Gag is important for this activity (7, 33). HIV-1 NC also plays essential roles in suppression of nonspecific self-priming (18, 26, 44) and minus- and plus-strand DNA transfers (26, 27, 50). Furthermore, addition of HIV-1 NC to in vitro reverse transcription reactions reduces the total amounts of DNA synthesized, but the amounts of full-length DNA products relative to shorter products are increased in the presence of NC, especially when extensive RNA secondary structures are present in the template RNA (36, 42, 65). These in vitro studies have suggested that HIV-1 NC increases the processivity of DNA synthesis by reducing RT pausing at regions of stable secondary structures in the template RNA (36, 42). Studies have also shown that MLV NC contributes to the synthesis of full-length viral cDNA (21, 22, 31, 53) and stimulation of minus-strand DNA transfer (1, 53).
The role of HIV-1 NC in facilitating minus-strand DNA transfer is clearly demonstrated through in vitro assays. In vitro observations that RT pausing stimulates strand transfer and that HIV-1 NC reduces pausing but increases strand transfer seem to be a paradox. Based on previous in vitro studies, it has been postulated that NC might have both stimulatory and inhibitory effects on RT template switching (57). The ability of NC to reduce pausing should inhibit template switching (64, 65). On the other hand, NC might also promote template switching by stimulating base pairing of the nascent DNA with the homologous acceptor template upon degradation of the donor template by RNase H (15, 16, 50). In vitro studies using different assay conditions might have introduced some bias toward one or the other activity (46). In this report, we describe the first in vivo experiments to analyze the role of NC in RT template switching during reverse transcription, using templates with different lengths of homologous sequences and/or the presence of a predicted RNA secondary structure. Our results indicate that one of the in vivo roles of MLV NC is to enhance the rate of DNA synthesis, especially through regions of template containing RNA secondary structure.
|
|
|---|
Plasmids and retroviral vectors. The construction of the MLV-based retroviral vector pES-GF250FP was previously described (61). The vector contains the selectable neomycin phosphotransferase gene (neo), which is expressed from an internal ribosomal entry site (IRES) of encephalomyocarditis virus and confers resistance to G418 (a neomycin analog) (35). The pES-GF250FP vector also contains overlapping fragments of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene that are 250 bp in length and are called the F portion.
A new pair of vectors named pGF100FP and pGFSLFP were constructed. The structures of the MLV-based retroviral vectors pGF100FP and pGFSLFP are similar to that of pES-GF250FP. However, the length of the F portion of GFP in vectors pGF100FP and pGFSLFP is 100 bp. In addition to the 100-bp repeated F portion, pGFSLFP contains a 41-bp sequence between the overlapping fragments that is predicted to form a stem-loop structure. The sequences of the GF and FP fragments and the intervening regions present were confirmed by PCR amplification and DNA sequencing of both strands (data not shown).
Plasmid pLGPS expresses MLV gag and pol from a truncated MLV LTR promoter (45). Plasmid pD150E, derived from pLGPS, expresses MLV gag-pol containing a replacement of one of the catalytic-site aspartic acid residues with a glutamic acid, which renders it replication defective (28). Plasmid pSV-A-MLV-env expresses the amphotropic MLV envelope gene from the LTR promoter and simian virus 40 enhancer (43). Plasmid pSV
3.6 encodes the
subunit of the murine Na+/K+ ATPase gene and confers resistance to ouabain (40). Plasmid pSVhygro encodes the hygro gene and thus confers resistance to hygromycin (25).
Mutagenesis and plasmid construction. To facilitate cloning, a silent mutation was introduced into the MLV gag-pol construct pLGPS by site-directed mutagenesis to create a unique ClaI site. The resulting gag-pol expression construct was named pWZH30. The mutations in NC were introduced into pWZH30 by PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis (30) or by the QuickChange mutagenesis kit (Stratagene). Most of the mutagenic oligonucleotide primers were designed to introduce additional silent mutations and generate new restriction sites. Restriction digestion analysis was performed to identify plasmids containing mutations. Detailed descriptions of the mutagenic oligonucleotides and the strategies used to generate individual mutants are available upon request. The PflMI-ClaI fragment containing mutations in NC was subcloned back into pWZH30. The inserted 577-bp fragment was analyzed by DNA sequencing to verify the presence of the desired mutations and the absence of any undesired mutations.
Cell culture, DNA transfection, and virus infection. D17 is a dog osteosarcoma cell line permissive to infection by MLV. All D17 cells and D17-derived cells were grown in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) supplemented with 6% calf serum and maintained in a 37°C incubator with 5% CO2. The cells were transfected and selected for resistance to ouabain, hygromycin, or G418 as previously described (37, 38). In addition, 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine (AZT) (1 µM final concentration) was added to all transfected cells to reduce the probability of reinfection of the virus-producing cells (61).
A3 is a single-cell clone that was generated by stably transfecting D17 cells with pSV-A-MLV-env, which expresses the MLV envelope (61). A3 cells were maintained, transfected, and selected for drug resistance in a manner similar to that described above for D17 cells. PG13 is a murine helper cell line expressing MLV gag-pol and the gibbon ape leukemia virus envelope (45). The absence of a gibbon ape leukemia virus receptor on murine cells prevents reinfection of the PG13 helper cells. PG13 cells were grown in DMEM supplemented with 10% calf serum and maintained in a 37°C incubator with 5% CO2. PG13 cells were transfected and selected for resistance to G418 as previously described (2).
Hydroxyurea (HU) treatment was performed as previously described (61). Briefly, D17 cells were treated with DMEM containing 1 mM HU 4 h prior to infection, 4 h during infection, and 24 h postinfection. The cells were then placed under selection with G418 and analyzed by flow cytometry.
Construction of cell lines cGF100Fp and cGFSLFP. Cell lines cGF100FP and cGFSLFP were constructed in a manner similar to cGF250FP. First, pGF100FP or pGFSLFP was transfected into PG13 cells. The transfected cells were subjected to G418 selection, and the drug-resistant colonies were pooled and expanded. Virus was harvested from the transfected PG13 cells and used to infect A3 cells, which express the MLV amphotropic envelope. After G418 selection was complete, individual drug-resistant colonies that did not exhibit detectable fluorescence were isolated and expanded. One of the GF100FP cell clones, named cGF100FP and used in subsequent studies, was able to produce high viral titers upon transfection with wild-type MLV gag-pol construct. Similarly, a cell clone expressing vGFSLFP, named cGFSLFP, was identified and used in subsequent studies. Genomic DNA was isolated from cell lines cGF100FP and cGFSLFP, and the proviral structures were analyzed by PCR and Southern blot hybridization using standard procedures (58). The Southern analysis verified that only one provirus was integrated in each of the cell lines (data not shown).
Protocol for determination of in vivo direct-repeat deletion frequency. cGF250FP, cGF100FP, or cGFSLFP cells were plated at a density of 2 x 105 per 60-mm-diameter dish and 24 h later cotransfected with wild-type or mutant MLV gag-pol constructs and pSVhygro. The transfected cells were maintained in the presence of 1 µM AZT and selected for resistance to hygromycin; the resistant colonies were pooled and expanded. Before virus was collected, the culture medium containing AZT was removed and the cells were plated at a density of 5 x 106 per 100-mm-diameter dish. Twenty-four hours later, 7 ml of fresh medium was added to each dish; the culture medium containing vGF250FP, vGF100FP, or vGFSLFP virus was harvested the next day and used to infect D17 target cells. Flow cytometry analysis was performed to ensure that GFP expression was not detected in the virus-producing cells. The infected D17 target cells were subjected to G418 selection; the numbers of G418-resistant colonies were used to determine viral titers. Subsequently, approximately 500 to 5,000 G418-resistant colonies were pooled and analyzed by flow cytometry to obtain the percentage of cells that expressed GFP.
In vivo trans-complementation assay.
A gag-pol expression plasmid containing the replication-defective D150E RT mutation was introduced into cGF250FP, cGF100FP, or cGFSLFP cells by cotransfection with pSV
3.6. Pools of ouabain-resistant colonies (>2,000 colonies) were used to generate cGF250FP(D150E), cGF100FP(D150E), and cGFSLFP(D150E) cells, respectively. The replication-defective NC mutants were then cotransfected into cGF250FP(D150E), cGF100FP(D150E), and cGFSLFP(D150E) cells with pSVhygro and selected for resistance to hygromycin. The assays for determination of in vivo direct-repeat deletion frequency described above were subsequently performed.
Flow cytometry analysis. To quantify the numbers of cells expressing GFP, approximately 500 to 5,000 drug-resistant colonies were pooled and subjected to flow cytometry analyses using a FACScan flow cytometer and CellQuest software (Becton Dickinson Immunocytometry Systems, San Jose, Calif.). Some of the flow cytometry analyses were performed by the Clinical Support Laboratory, Clinical Services Program, Science Applications International Corporation Frederick.
Statistical analysis. The statistical analysis consisted of pairwise comparisons of means among the wild-type group, which served as a control, and the various NC mutants (41). Two different strategies were used for the statistical-significance analysis. First, two-tailed two-sample independent t tests were used. Furthermore, Bonferroni adjustment was used to set the criterion for the statistical significance for each comparison at 0.05/N. Thus, the probability of any type I error is maintained at 0.05 across all comparisons. In this study, for each comparison between the mutant and the wild type, the P value for statistical significance was set at 0.05/5 (0.01) for Table 1 and 0.05/10 (0.005) for Table 2. Therefore, a P value of <0.01 for Table 1 and a P value of <0.005 for Table 2 were considered statistically significant.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Effects of lysine residue substitutions in zinc finger domain of MLV NC on frequency of direct-repeat deletion
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. trans-complementation of zinc finger mutants in MLV NC and effects on frequency of direct-repeat deletion
|
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (27K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Protocol for analyzing the effects of NC mutations on RT template switching in vivo. (A) Structure of MLV-based vector pES-GF250FP, structure of provirus after direct-repeat deletion, and flow cytometry analysis. pES-GF250FP contains LTRs and all of the cis-acting elements of MLV. The GFFP and neo genes are transcribed from the LTR promoter. The IRES of encephalomyocarditis virus is used to express neo. The directly repeated F portions of GFP are shaded and indicated by right-facing arrows. During reverse transcription, one of the repeated F portions may be deleted to reconstitute a functional GFP. The cells containing a functional GFP gene are fluorescent and can be detected by flow cytometry. A typical graph obtained from flow cytometry is shown after one round of viral replication using wild-type MLV gag-pol. The y axis is the number of events scored, which is interpreted as the number of cells, and the x axis is the intensity of the fluorescence. The cell population that does not express GFP is gated as M1, whereas the cell population that expresses GFP is gated as M2 (GFP+ cells). In this plot, M1 is 89.2% and the M2 is 10.8%. , MLV packaging signal. (B) Protocol for in vivo direct-repeat deletion assay. cGF250FP is a D17-based cell line expressing pES-GF250FP and pSV-A-MLV-env. Wild-type or mutated MLV gag-pol constructs with NC mutations were separately cotransfected with pSVhygro into the cGF250FP cells, and the virus produced was harvested and used to infect D17 cells. After G418 selection, the infected cell clones resistant to G418 were analyzed by flow cytometry, and the frequencies of direct-repeat deletion were determined. (C) Protocol for in vivo trans-complementation assay. The RT mutant D150E was transfected into cGF250FP cells to construct the cell line cGF250FP(D150E). The D150E mutant expresses wild-type NC and defective RT. The wild-type or mutated MLV gag-pol constructs with NC mutations were subsequently transfected into the cGF250FP(D150E) cells, and the virus produced was harvested and used to infect D17 cells. After G418 selection, the infected cell clones resistant to G418 were analyzed by flow cytometry, and the frequencies of direct-repeat deletion were determined.
|
In this system, viral titers and frequencies of template switching were examined during a single round of the viral replication cycle. The multiplicity of infection for the experiments analyzed by flow cytometry was <0.001; therefore, the probability of double infection was very low. The frequency of direct-repeat deletion provided a measure of the template-switching events.
Substitutions of basic residues and CCHC motif residues in the MLV NC zinc finger domain. To determine the role of the MLV NC zinc finger domain in RT template switching, we introduced single amino acid substitutions in the zinc finger domain (Fig. 3). The first set of substitution mutations was designed to change positively charged residues in the zinc finger domain to neutral amino acids, because several studies have indicated that the basic residues in NC proteins play an important role in RNA binding (8, 10, 12). The second set of mutations was designed to disrupt the structure of the zinc finger motif, because multiple lines of evidence indicate that this structure is important for various functions of NC (22, 23, 27). The zinc finger domain of MLV NC contains three lysine residues. First, each of the three lysine residues was replaced with a neutral amino acid to generate mutants K30A, K30I, K32A, K37L, and K37Q. In addition, we also constructed one double mutant named WZH43 (K30I-K32A) and one triple mutant named WZH46 (K30I-K32A-K37L) in which two or all three of the lysine residues were simultaneously replaced with neutral residues. Finally, the conserved aromatic amino acid in the zinc finger domain, W35, was replaced with a serine residue to generate the W35S mutant (Fig. 3).
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Mutations in zinc finger domain of MLV NC. The MLV NC primary sequence (amino acids 6 to 51) containing the zinc finger domain is shown. The numbers above the primary sequence indicate the amino acid positions. The zinc finger domain is bracketed, CCHC residues are in italics and underlined, and the basic residues in the zinc finger domain are in boldface. The substitution mutations analyzed at each amino acid position are indicated below the primary sequence. The names of the corresponding plasmid constructs are shown on the left.
|
Effects of basic residue substitutions in the MLV NC zinc finger motif on template switching. The viral titers and frequencies of template switching were determined for MLV NC mutants in which each of the lysine residues in the zinc finger motif was replaced with a neutral residue. In this set of experiments, the pES-GF250FP vector was used, and the frequency of direct-repeat deletion and GFP reconstitution for the wild-type NC was 10.8% (Table 1). Each NC mutant was analyzed in two independent experiments so that the statistical significance of the results could be determined. The single-residue substitution mutations had various effects on the viral titers. The K30I mutant had the most significant reduction in viral titer (70-fold). The K30A and K37Q mutations resulted in approximately 5- to 10-fold reductions in viral titers. The K32A and K37L mutations had no significant effect on viral titers (t test; P > 0.05). Only the K30I and K37Q mutants displayed statistically significant increases in the RT template-switching frequencies of 2.0- and 1.6-fold, respectively. Neutral amino acid substitutions at the same lysine residues had different effects on the RT template-switching frequency, since the K30I mutation increased the template-switching frequency but the K30A mutation had no effect on template switching. This result suggested that the structure of the amino acid side chain at this position had a more significant effect on the viral titer and RT template switching than the change in charge of the side chain.
To further investigate the roles of the positively charged residues of the NC zinc finger domain in template switching, we constructed a double and a triple mutant in which two or all three of the basic residues in the zinc finger domain were replaced by neutral amino acids (Fig. 3). These two mutants were severely defective in viral replication and exhibited viral titers that were 1,000- to 10,000-fold lower than the wild-type titer (Table 1). Therefore, these mutants were not able to produce sufficient numbers of colonies for analysis of the frequency of template switching.
To determine the effects of NC mutants that were severely defective in viral replication on template switching, we used the in vivo trans-complementation assay, which was similar to an assay previously used to analyze complementation between polymerase and RNase H domain mutants of RT (34). In this assay (Fig. 2C), the D150E mutant expressed a wild-type NC but was defective in RT activity, whereas the NC mutants expressed a defective NC and a functional RT. Assuming that the Gag-Pol proteins from the D150E mutant and the NC mutants could coassemble, we expected that the virion produced would contain a functional RT. In addition, the virion would contain a mixture of wild-type and mutant NC proteins. Therefore, complementation of these two gag-pol mutants (NC- RT+ and NC+ RT-) resulted in virions that could complete one cycle of viral replication. In this manner, we could rescue the viral titers of replication-defective NC mutants and determine whether the presence of the defective NC proteins affected the frequency of direct-repeat deletion. It was conceivable that the conditions of the trans-complementation assay affected the frequency of RT template switching. However, the rates of template switching for wild-type NC were not different in the trans-complementation assay and the standard assay (Table 2), suggesting that the conditions of the trans-complementation assay did not cause an increase in RT template switching in this system.
The mutants that exhibited 1,000- to 10,000-fold reduction in viral titer were rescued in the trans-complementation assay (Table 2). After trans-complementation, the titers were 1,000 to 2,000 CFU/ml. The frequencies of direct-repeat deletions of vGF250FP after trans-complementation were 22.0% for WZH43 (K30I-K32A) and 22.1% for WZH46 (K30I-K32A-K37L), which was similar to the frequency for K30I alone (21.5%), suggesting there was no correlation between the degree of positive charge in the zinc finger domain and the frequency of template switching.
trans-complementation of zinc finger CCHC motif mutants and frequency of template switching. Because most previously characterized zinc finger domain mutants have been shown to be noninfectious, we used the trans-complementation assay to determine the effects of zinc finger domain CCHC motif mutations on RT template switching (Table 2). The zinc finger domain mutants with substitutions in the CCHC motif could be rescued in trans; the titers after trans-complementation were 1,000 to 5,000 CFU/ml. Mutants H34C and C39H showed 1.9- and 1.8-fold increases in the frequency of template switching, respectively. The other five mutants contained substitutions in which one (C26S, C29S, or C39S), two (C26S-C29S), or all three (SSHS) cysteine residues were replaced with serines; this set of mutations severely disrupted the zinc finger motif conformation. All of these mutants were rescued in trans and displayed increased frequencies of template switching, ranging from 1.5- to 1.8-fold higher than that of the wild type. Thus, all NC zinc finger domain mutants exhibited statistically significant increases in the frequency of RT template switching.
Effects of mutations in the zinc finger domain on RT template switching in regions of template containing RNA secondary structure.
Mutations in the zinc finger domain of MLV NC resulted in modest but statistically significant increases in RT template switching for vGF250FP. We hypothesized that the effects of the NC mutations on RT template switching might be dependent on the extent of template RNA secondary structure. To study the role of NC during reverse transcription of template regions containing RNA secondary structure, we used a pair of retroviral vectors, named pGF100FP and pGFSLFP, with 100-bp direct repeats of the GFP gene (Fig. 4). The vector pGFSLFP was very similar to pGF100FP; however, a predicted stem-loop structure (41 bp;
G = -25.6 kcal/mol) was present in pGFSLFP in the noncoding sequence between the two F portions. Cell lines cGF100FP and cGFSLFP, containing one provirus from each vector, were constructed to study the effects of mutations in NC on the frequency of template switching.
![]() View larger version (20K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Structure of MLV-based vectors pGF100FP and pGFSLFP, which contain LTRs and all of the cis-acting elements of MLV. The GF and FP fragments, as well as neo, are transcribed from the LTR promoter. The IRES of encephalomyocarditis virus is used to express neo. The directly repeated F portions of GFP are shaded and indicated by overhead arrows, which are 100 bp in length. GF End and FP Start mark the exact sequence where the first F portion ends and the second F portion starts. The intervening sequence between the two F portions is shown below each vector. The stem-loop structure is predicted by RNAstructure (version 2.5) software. The total RNA secondary-structure energy value of the sequence shown in boldface for vGF100FP is -1.9 kcal/mol, whereas the secondary-structure energy value of the RNA sequence shown in boldface for vGFSLFP is -25.6 kcal/mol (DNASIS version 2.6 software).
|
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Comparison of the effects of MLV NC basic substitution mutations in the zinc finger domain on frequency of template switching in the presence or absence of a predicted stem-loop structure in the template. The mean is averaged from two to five experiments, and the error bars represent standard errors of the mean.
|
Both the K30I and K37Q mutants exhibited statistically significant increases in template switching (2.0- and 1.6-fold, respectively) when vGF250FP was used (Table 1). We therefore expected K30I and K37Q mutations to have greater effects on RT template switching for vGFSLFP than wild-type NC. The K30I mutant exhibited only a 1.5% frequency of template switching for vGF100FP, which was similar to the 1.7% frequency observed with wild-type NC; in sharp contrast, the frequency of template switching increased to 45% for vGFSLFP (Fig. 5). Therefore, the predicted RNA secondary structure in vGFSLFP resulted in a 30-fold overall increase in the template switching frequency for the K30I mutant. Similarly, the K37Q mutant displayed a frequency of template switching of 23% for vGFSLFP, which was 16-fold higher than the 1.5% frequency of template switching for vGF100FP.
To study the role of the CCHC motif of MLV NC, we used the trans-complementation assays with cGF100FP(D150E) and cGFSLFP(D150E) cells to rescue replication-defective CCHC mutants. As shown in Fig. 5 and 6, the frequencies of template switching for wild-type NC with and without complementation with D150E were not different. As additional controls, the K30I and K30A mutants were also subjected to the trans-complementation assay (Fig. 6). Upon trans-complementation, the template-switching frequency for the K30I mutant was reduced from 45 to 29%, and the frequency for the K30A mutant was reduced from 24 to 19%. These results suggested that, because of the presence of wild-type NC in the infectious virion, the effects of the NC mutations on template switching were reduced. All of the CCHC mutants exhibited frequencies of template switching similar to that of wild-type NC for cGF100FP(D150E) (1.7 to 2.4%). In contrast, when the CCHC motif mutants were introduced into cGFSLFP(D150E) cells, the frequencies of template switching increased significantly, ranging from 24 to 34%. Thus, the substitution mutations in the CCHC motif of MLV NC increased the frequency of template switching approximately 10- to 20-fold when a predicted secondary structure was present in the template. Similar to the lysine substitution mutants, the effect of the predicted secondary structure was substantially greater for the CCHC motif mutants than the 8.2% template-switching frequency obtained with the wild-type NC.
![]() View larger version (34K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. trans-complementation of MLV NC zinc finger mutants and effects of substitutions in CCHC motif of MLV NC on frequency of template switching in the presence or absence of a predicted stem-loop structure in the template. The wild type (WT), K30I, and K30A are controls of the experimental system. The mean is averaged from two to four experiments, and the error bars represent standard errors of the mean.
|
The effects of HU treatment on RT template switching are summarized in Table 3. First, the frequencies of RT template switching for wild-type NC were compared in the absence and presence of HU treatment for vGF100FP and vGFSLFP. The frequency of template switching increased 3.7-fold (from 1.7 to 6.3%) with HU treatment for wild-type vGF100FP. In contrast, the frequency of template switching increased only slightly (1.5-fold) with HU treatment for wild-type vGFSLFP. This result suggested that the enhancing effect of the RNA structure on RT template switching was insensitive to HU treatment.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Comparison of the effect of HU treatment on frequency of template switching in the presence of predicted secondary structure
|
It was also interesting that the RT template-switching frequencies for the NC mutants in the presence of HU during vGF100FP infection were 3 to 4.5%, which were significantly lower than the 6.3% frequency obtained with wild-type vGF100FP in the presence of HU treatment (t test; P < 0.05/3 = 0.0167). Therefore, under these conditions, mutations in NC decreased the frequency of RT template switching.
|
|
|---|
The potential roles of NC in reverse transcription and template switching are illustrated in Fig. 7. NC could increase the overall rate of polymerization by facilitating the unfolding of RNA secondary structures that may act as RT pause sites. Mutations or conditions that slow down DNA polymerization, such as depletion of intracellular dNTP pools with HU treatment, increase the frequency of template switching (34, 61). NC proteins have been shown to facilitate in vitro DNA synthesis by reducing RT pausing caused by secondary structures (26, 27, 36, 65). These studies suggest that NC facilitates the melting of RNA secondary structures and thus increases the processivity of reverse transcription. Based on these in vitro results, mutations in NC would be expected to increase the frequency of template switching. On the other hand, NC proteins have also been found to facilitate the annealing of nascent DNA with acceptor template upon RNase H degradation of the donor template in vitro (16, 50), as well as to facilitate minus-strand transfer (1, 18, 27, 53). These findings suggest that mutations in NC should decrease annealing and thus reduce the frequency of template switching.
![]() View larger version (27K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. Roles of NC in RT template switching. For simplicity, only intramolecular template switching is shown. The thick black lines represent direct repeats in an RNA template. The horizontal arrows represent nascent DNA. The thick dotted lines represent RNA template degraded by RNase H. Annealing between the nascent DNA and RNA template is designated by short vertical lines.
|
Retroviral NC protein is generally considered to be an RNA chaperone during reverse transcription. The nucleic acid chaperone activities of NC have been well demonstrated during in vitro tRNA primer placement and minus-strand DNA transfer reactions by catalyzing the annealing of complementary sequences (1, 7, 18, 21, 22, 26, 27, 31, 44, 50, 53). The ability of NC to chaperone processive viral DNA synthesis by destabilizing secondary structures has also been studied in vitro (36, 42, 65). The results of our in vivo study indicate that, during viral DNA synthesis, the chaperone function of NC in destabilizing secondary structure is predominant over the annealing of nascent DNA to acceptor RNA. One possibility is that the annealing reaction between the nascent DNA and acceptor RNA is in competition with elongation of DNA synthesis on the donor template; the annealing of nascent DNA and the acceptor template may be a slow event relative to elongation of DNA synthesis. In this assay, the annealing reaction and the subsequent template switching must occur within the relatively short time required for RT to reverse transcribe through one copy of the direct repeat. On the other hand, NC is bound to the viral RNA as part of the viral nucleoprotein complex and presumably will have ample time to unfold any secondary structures that might act as RT pause sites to facilitate rapid DNA polymerization.
It is conceivable that the chaperone activity of NC might stabilize the DNA-RNA hybrids that form between nascent DNA and donor template RNA; enhancing the stability of these hybrids would suppress annealing between nascent DNA and acceptor RNA and reduce the frequency of template switching. However, the well-defined nucleic acid chaperone activity of NC argues against this possibility. NC, through its nucleic acid chaperone function, acts to maximize base pairing in nucleic acids (reviewed in reference 55 and references therein). Since the template RNA is degraded by RNase H after it is copied, the extent of base pairing between nascent DNA and acceptor nucleic acid should be greater than the base pairing between nascent DNA and donor template RNA fragments. Therefore, the effect of NC on promoting annealing between nascent DNA and acceptor template should be more pronounced than its effect on stabilizing hybridization to donor RNA fragments.
Does NC play a role in annealing nascent DNA and acceptor RNA during DNA synthesis? The results obtained with HU treatment during vGF100FP infection (Table 3) suggest that NC indeed promotes annealing of nascent DNA and acceptor template under certain conditions. HU treatment during infection with wild-type vGF100FP increased the RT template-switching frequency to 6.3%; however, HU treatment during infection with vGF100FP containing mutations in NC increased template switching to only 3 to 4.5%. Thus, under these conditions, mutations in NC actually resulted in a decrease in RT template switching (3 to 4.5% for NC mutants versus 6.3% for the wild type), suggesting that wild-type NC promoted annealing between nascent DNA and the acceptor template. In this case, the direct repeats were rather short (100 bp) and probably did not have extensive secondary structure in the template. In addition, the rate of DNA synthesis was reduced with HU treatment, allowing more time for annealing between the nascent DNA and the acceptor template. This result suggests that NC can facilitate both melting of RNA secondary structure and annealing between complementary sequences. When the repeat length is short and does not contain extensive RNA secondary structures, and the rate of DNA synthesis is low, the effect of NC on annealing is more evident.
Several in vitro studies have indicated that NC enhances minus-strand DNA transfer by promoting annealing between nascent DNA and template RNA (16, 50). During minus-strand DNA transfer, RT reaches the end of the template; therefore, the rate of DNA polymerization is zero. Under this extreme condition, there is no DNA synthesis, so that the effect of NC on annealing nascent DNA and acceptor RNA would predominate and NC would be expected to stimulate minus-strand DNA transfer. However, the minus-strand DNA transfer reaction for HIV-1 is made more complex by the presence of the transactivation response element (TAR) stem-loop structure in the R region. It was recently shown that NC stimulates the HIV-1 minus-strand transfer reaction by unfolding the TAR secondary structure and inhibiting TAR-induced self-priming of DNA synthesis (18, 27). Presumably, the NC-induced unfolding of the TAR secondary structure prevents premature weak-stop DNA transfer caused by RT pausing at the site of TAR. Our proposal that MLV NC denatures RNA secondary structure in vivo is analogous to the NC-induced unfolding of the TAR secondary structure. Other in vitro studies have also shown a stimulation of internal template switching by NC (46, 52, 57). As suggested earlier, the length of homology, the extent of RNA secondary structure, and the rate of DNA synthesis could all play a role in determining whether the net effect of NC is to promote template switching or to increase the rate of DNA synthesis on the donor template.
The results obtained with the basic residues in the zinc finger domain suggest that the structure of the side chain, rather than the loss of a positively charged side chain, has a greater impact on viral titers and RT template switching. For example, the K30A mutant, which contained a small side chain, showed only a fivefold reduction in viral titer, no change in template switching for vGF250FP, and a 15-fold increase in the frequency of template switching for vGFSLFP. In contrast, the K30I mutant containing a bulky side chain had a 70-fold reduction in viral titer, a twofold increase in the frequency of template switching for vGF250FP, and a 30-fold increase in the frequency of template switching for vGFSLFP. We speculate that the bulky isoleucine side chain altered the conformation of the zinc finger motif. The strictly conserved structure of the zinc finger motif has been shown to be critical for viral replication (23, 56).
By using an in vivo trans-complementation assay, we show that replication-defective NC mutants can be rescued by trans-complementation with an RT-inactivating mutant expressing wild-type NC. Infectious viral particles produced after trans-complementation contained a mixture of Gag and Gag-Pol polyproteins expressed from both NC+ RT- and NC- RT+ variants of gag-pol. The functional RT in the infectious virion can only be produced by the Gag-Pol proteins derived from the NC mutants. Because the processing of the Gag-Pol proteins from the NC mutants resulted in production of the mutated NC proteins as well as wild-type RT, the mutated NC proteins must be present in the infectious virion.
The ratio of the wild-type and mutated NC proteins in the infectious virion cannot be determined in this trans-complementation system. If the Gag and Gag-Pol proteins of the NC mutants and the RT mutant are expressed equally and copackaged randomly, then the wild-type and mutant NC proteins are likely to be present in a 1:1 ratio in the infectious virion. However, the efficiency with which the NC mutants bind to RNA and are proteolytically processed could affect the ratio of the wild-type and mutated NC proteins present in the infectious virion. Nevertheless, these infectious viruses produced after trans-complementation of NC zinc finger mutants exhibited an increase in the frequency of template switching.
It was theoretically possible that the inactive RT from the D150E mutant interfered with the efficiency of DNA synthesis by binding to the template and preventing the progression of wild-type RT. However, our results do not support this notion, because the D150E mutation did not affect the frequency of template switching when complemented with wild-type gag-pol (Fig. 6). In addition, trans-complementation of the K30I mutant with the D150E mutant was shown to decrease the frequency of template switching for vGFSLFP from 45 to 29%, representing a 36% decrease. Similarly, the K30A trans-complemented with D150E resulted in a slightly decreased frequency of RT template switching from 23.0 to 19.7%. Because the viral particles contain wild-type NC as well as mutated NC, the enhancing effects of the NC mutations on template switching are most likely to be underestimated in this assay. The decrease in the effect of K30I and K30A mutations on the template-switching frequency in the trans-complementation assay may be due to various effects of these mutations on other functions of NC, such as RNA packaging or tRNA placement, and the extent to which they can be complemented in trans by the replication-defective RT mutant.
The exact nature of the RNA secondary structure present in vGFSLFP that resulted in increasing RT template switching is unknown. Furthermore, the RNA secondary structure may take alternative forms during the process of reverse transcription through interactions with viral proteins as the template RNA is being copied into DNA. Nevertheless, the presence of this 41-bp sequence in vGFSLFP substantially increased the frequency of template switching. Although several mechanisms could be postulated, one attractive hypothesis is that the RNA secondary structure acts as an RT pause site to stall or slow down the rate of DNA synthesis, allowing more time for base pairing between nascent DNA and the acceptor template. The observation in this study that the effect of the RNA secondary structure was not sensitive to HU treatment suggests that the RNA secondary structure causes RT to stall or reduce the rate of DNA synthesis to such a low level that RT binding to the nucleotide substrate is no longer the rate-limiting step in reverse transcription. As a consequence, depletion of intracellular nucleotide pools with HU treatment has little effect on the high frequency of template switching associated with the RNA secondary structure.
In summary, one important in vivo role of MLV NC is to increase the rate of viral DNA synthesis. We hypothesize that MLV NC increases the rate of DNA polymerization through its chaperone activity, which involves breaking base pairs in the viral RNA secondary structure. The effect of NC on DNA synthesis and thus frequency of template switching is highly dependent on the extent of RNA secondary structure present in the template RNA. The zinc finger domain contributes significantly to the chaperone activity of MLV NC. It will be of interest to determine the roles of MLV NC basic regions that flank the zinc finger domain in RT template switching.
This work was supported by the HIV Drug Resistance Program, National Cancer Institute, and by the National Cancer Institute under contract NO1-CO-56000 with SAIC Frederick.
|
|
|---|
-RNA recognition element. Science 279:384-388.
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»